Paul's Live From New York Pizza

Literally one of the best pizzas we've ever had not sure if it was a manager or the owner but the guy is amazing! Customer service absolutely five star and above food made with love....not only will I be going there again I will be recommending Paul'slive especially in Fortuna to everyone !One of the best pizza pies ever ????

Probably would have given 4 stars for pricing but they do offer Gluten Free pizza also so that bumped it up. I love the pizza and I know the cost is rising everywhere. Probably better to buy these by the slice unless you're having a party but man....thin pizza is so good I usually buy a whole pizza when we do splurge just so we can have leftovers. Yum!

Probably would have given 4 stars for pricing but they do offer Gluten Free pizza also so that bumped it up. I love the pizza and I know the cost is rising everywhere. Probably better to buy these by the slice unless you're having a party but man.... thin pizza is so good I usually buy a whole pizza when we do splurge just so we can have leftovers. Yum! Ver carta

Hands down one of the best pizzas we've ever tasted. Not sure if the man we met was the manager or the owner, but he was fantastic! The customer service was truly five-star, and you can tell the food is made with genuine love. I’ll definitely be returning and recommending Paul's Live From New York Pizza to everyone in Fortuna. Truly one of the best pizza pies around!

I thoroughly enjoyed my visit to Paul's Live From New York Pizza. My second time there was just as amazing as the first. As you can tell, the fried ravioli and mozzarella sticks disappeared quickly. The mussels in marinara sauce were outstanding last time, and Cindy is a big fan of the pizza. It’s wonderful that you can easily grab a slice. Plus, they serve the best fries in town. Thanks for bringing this spot to Fortuna!

Unbelievable! The man wearing the flannel shirt was cooking the pizza, and I noticed him repeatedly touching his hair and face without washing his hands afterward. I watched him handle my pizza after it was cooked. This place is extremely unsanitary. Additionally, the woman behind the counter was eating the entire time while talking to customers with food in her mouth. I would advise caution to anyone considering eating here. Ver carta

Paul's is willing to work with vegan diets even though their menu isn't accommodating. On two occasions, they've let me bring in vegan cheese and vegan sausages (as long as they're in unopened packages) to supplement their gluten free crust (which isvegan). I feel like they could be a five-star vegan option if they just kept a few items on hand in a freezer and had some veganoptions on their menu, because the results were delicious.

The restaurant was clean, with roomy and comfortable seating. The staff were extremely friendly and accommodating. Although I’ve never been to New York to compare, the pizza was tasty—nothing extraordinary, but certainly enjoyable. The crust was thin, slightly greasy, and had a pleasant crunch. I would definitely come back for another slice! We only tried the pizza this time, but I’m looking forward to trying other dishes from the menu on my next visit.

No offence to anybody in Humboldt, but you all have been lied to about what good food is. They do the bare minimum to make your food edible in this county and sell it to you at prices more expensive than Portland or Seattle for something that cant evenhold a light up to the the food in other areas. Pizzas are cold, and sauce has no flavor, Mexican food is boring and has nospice/ salsa as bland as can be and Italian food might as well be made by your mother with tomatoes out of a can. I'll pray foryour county that somebody comes in with good deals and quality food cause they are ripping you all off. Ver carta