The Original Goodfella's Brick Oven Pizza

Beautiful, classy, generous and fun. Staff are very kind and really love their job. Go every chance you can!

This place is awesome, everyone is so friendly and welcoming, the food was amazing, best spot in Staten Island!!!

I live in Brooklyn and I love taking the ride to Staten Island to enjoy a delicious meal at the Goodfella’s restaurant! The new location it’s amazing! The environment, the food and the service are spectacular! These guys know what they are doing! Amazing job! Keep going! Ver carta

Excellent service, amazing food. Grilled Octopus Long Hots and Smoked Burrata appetizers. All were tender, thoughtfully seasoned and prepared. The Smoked Burrata was delicious and delightfully presented. Puttanesca pizza was a hit, excellent flavors and crisp, perfect crust. Kudos!

Great local spot for a nice night out with family or friends. Inside nice ambiance between old and modern look setting a relaxed and positive vibe as you dine in. The food was delicious and of good portion. The only complaint we had was the waitress constantly going over our plate to pass or grab items.

We’re from VA and family lives on Long Island. Traffic was real bad and decided to get off to take a break and enjoy some food. Family got pizzas and I ordered the spaghetti and meatballs, just an original classic. It was delicious. I love the small place feel with the pizza stove. Really makes it hard to enjoy anything Italian back south. Ver carta

We went to dinner with friends at Goodgella's (Great Kills) tonite. We walked in as first time visitors and left feeling like we just had dinner with family! Appetizers, Dinner, Staff, Chef and Owner were amazing from the minute we walked in the door till the moment we left. Totally recommend!! Thank you for making us feel like home! We Will Be Back!

My wife and I went for dinner at the new location. The staff and help were wonderful. The food was delicious as usual. Ben a good fellow's a number of times over the years. I do recommend going there. We met the owner Scott. We wish them well and new place very guy. Although they were crowded the service was very good the entire staff was on (A) game. Once again I do recommend going there food is very good.

Gonna give a honest review. Gotta say I was excited for the new location on Hylan, when I entered the restaurant me, my wife and my parents were greeted by the bartender, which made me feel welcome. We then got seated rather quickly which was great for a Friday night. Our waitress then came over read us the specials, and asked us the usual what we wanted to drink and entrees. The service wasn’t good drinks were forgotten, we got 3 Little pieces of bread even though there was 4 of us which we ha … – show Ver carta