Fratelli’s Pizzeria

Mama Lisa

➤ 1226 Montauk Hwy, 11950, Mastic, United States

Piatti • Pizza • Seafood • Italian • American

---

"This restaurant is usually always good. A go to for our family for everything down to big birthday parties but lately the food has been just okay. Their customer service is great but the food has been coming out so sloppily made. It’s getting worseevery time, I figured I’d order early and I’d get a better result but I just got my delivery at 4:00pm and it looks superrushed. $85 dollar order and everything looks like they just didn’t care how it was sent out to someone’s home. It sucksbecause there aren’t many good Italian restaurants out here. I think this will be my last order.."

Mediterranean Kitchen

➤ 1171 Montauk Highway, Mastic, 11950, United States Of America

Piatti • Greek • Seafood • Vegetarian • Mediterranean

---

"This is the best Mediterranean/Turkish food is Suffolk (and quite possibly entire long island). Our family take out and dine in here for almost 20 years. The food has been consistently amazing. Their chicken kebab and lamb kebab taste so good, so is their salad with their chicken. Over time we have tasted their cold and hot appetizers hummus, baba ganoush, cheese rolls and spinach pie are our favorite. A very fast and friendly service, reasonable prices and a cozy atmosphere, you will not regret trying."

La Buena Vida

➤ 714 Montauk HwyNY 11955, Moriches, United States

Piatti • Beer • Kebab • Seafood • Spanish

---

"I took my wife for her birthday, we live local but haven’t eaten in this building since many years ago. the truth is we had a certain stigma about it owing to the previous restaurant, one we both disliked even before we met. Anyway, today was her birthday, we made reservations at Daphne’s in West Hampton but bailed because of the small menu and far drive. In trying to come up with a back up plan I remembered seeing the parking lot of La Buena Vida often packed, so I looked it up and saw almost 300 reviews averaging 4.5 stars. So I looked at the menu, I saw Paella, Tapas, I was sold. When I sent her the menu she was sold. We arrived and it was a beautiful early fall/late summer night so we decided to dine out on the deck, it was a great decision. Our server couldn’t have been more accommodating she offered to re seat us if the flies from the pond were to much, they weren‘t and we enjoyed the ambiance. After looking at the drink menu, we were again very impressed with service. My wife really wanted a la. buena vida margarita, but wanted it made blue. She graciously had the bar tender added the blue liquor to change the color. When time came to order we stared with the avocado crab bruschetta, it was a great decision and service was very quick. Next was the entree order, so we both ordered paella marinera. Again our server made a suggestion and informed us its a big serving, we could easily share it an order another tapa (which means she was also a mind reader). So after seeing how torn we were, she suggested an off menu item stuffed sweet plantain and upon hearing I didn’t wast meat graciously swapped out beef for shrimp. Our food was hand delivered and served onto our plates by the chef. This service was phenomenal, but even the amazing service did not compare to the perfection of our meal. The shrimp was perfectly cooked and season, the sweetness of the plantain pair beautifully with the savory of the shrimp. The paella was also perfectly cooked, the saffron rice was amazing, with the generous amount of shrimp, scallops, clams, and mussels. The meal was very satisfying. For dessert the fried cheesecake was highly recommended and “Wow” is all either of us had to say. It was easily the apex of the meal, sweet savory, with a crunch, and a hot/cold temperatures balancing to perfection. Dessert even came with a song and ”Happy Birthday” in caramel. We strongly recommend this neighborhood gem. There is nothing like it around, the chef is talented, the staff is amazing. if you haven’t tried it yet, what are you waiting for!? Dietary restrictions: I’m pescatarian, they were very accommodating. Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $30–50 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 4"

Nino's Pizzeria Cucina

➤ 201 Mastic Beach Rd, United States

Piatti • Pizza • Italian • Pizzeria • Fast Food

---

"I can't even begin to tell you how impressed I am with this restaurant. I had to put in an order for my son's birthday last minute with pizzas and 2 catering trays. Usually they need 24 hrs in advance for catering but the woman on the phone and the owner worked with my situation. They communicated and called me back promptly with solutions and the grilled vegetables and pizzas (including gluten free) that we got were amazing, people kept going for seconds. I had no idea they were in Mastic so close to us, and will continue to use them in the future. Thank you guys so much!"

Pupuseria Y Taqueria

➤ 1025 Montauk Hwy, 11967, Shirley, US, United States

Piatti • Sushi • Pizza • Kebab • Seafood

---

"I had the pleasure of trying the Pupusa De Queso, Shrimp Burrito, and Carne Asada Tacos at this restaurant, and they were all delicious! While there can be a bit of a wait sometimes, it's definitely worth it. The burrito is thick, cheesy, and packed with flavor, and the pupusas are spot on. I didn’t manage to take a picture, but I enjoyed everything. The side of cabbage (similar to pikliz) could use a bit more spice, but that's just my personal preference. The tacos taste authentic, with flavorful and juicy meat. The horchata is always refreshing, and the staff is friendly. Best of all, the prices are reasonable and reminiscent of old-school bodegas—so I don't have to pay $5 for just one taco. I highly recommend this place!"