Kellari Taverna - Piatti

Very pleasant enjoyable restaurant! Glad I chose it for my dinner

Each time we come to NY, we plan for a meal at Kellari. It never disappoints

Over the years we have dined at Kellari many times, but this was our first time back since the Pandemic. Sorry to say, while it is still a very pleasant interior, the quality of the food and service have gone way downhill. Visualizza piatti

This is the second time here and it was even better than the first. Our waiter was attentive but not intrusive. He was there just when you wanted something. The drinks and food were perfect. As was my whole dining experience.

Appetizer was very good. Entree was just awful, but it was the “special”. It was nothing like it was described, but it was so loud in there and the tables are close. Very hard to hear. Our waiter was covering 4-5 tables and would breeze by occasionally. The baklava saved the day.

We had a pre theater dinner at the restaurant. We chose the dinner special three course meal for $65. Food was delicious. Our waiter was quite accommodating and knowledgeable. Other staff and servers were friendly and very attentive. The ambience lived up to the website pictures. Visualizza piatti

Kellari is the best Greek/ seafood restaurant in NY. The food is simply amazing, service is great and my wife loves the restaurant setting. We got confused and went to Milos thinking that was the Greek restaurant we had visited before, so we had the chance to compare (by mistake) and I confirm that Kellaris is the best.

Started off not great but the waiter and food made up for it. The hostess was not friendly. I didn’t have a reservation and she said it would take 30 min so I got on open table and made a reservation in the moment. She was not pleased by that and it showed. But the waiter made up for her lack in service. He suggested a great geek wine and was very attentive. The wine was great and to my surprise only $60. The food was even better. Get one of the whole fish. The one he got was light and mild but so delicious! Paired well with the sautéed spinach.

To celebrate my birthday and impending trip to Greece, I chose Kellari Taverna. The service was a little slow, probably because it was pre show dinner time. But the food more than made up for having it. We chose several items from the Appetizers and Sides menu and had them served family style, which I understand to be the Greek way. The Greek salad (aka Horiatiki) was fresh and topped with the best feta I have ever tasted. The spanakopita topped with sesame seeds equalled my mom 's. And I can 't say enough about the wine I chose Assyrtiko from Santorini. Altogether, it was a delightful experience and can 't wait to go back. Visualizza piatti