Island Empanada - Menu

2142 Merrick Ave, Merrick, New York, USA, 11566, United States

🛍 Seafood, Catering, Caribbean, Latin-american

4 💬 1277 Reviews
Island Empanada

Phone: +15166082663

Address: 2142 Merrick Ave, Merrick, New York, USA, 11566, United States

City: Merrick

Menu Dishes: 35

Reviews: 1277

Website: http://Islandempanada.com

"Review: This restaurant offers nothing remarkable. Here’s a brief overview of the issues: It only caters to those who can handle lactose and eat spicy foods. The ambiance is dull and monotonous, and the majority of the staff is teenagers who frequently make mistakes. The space is extremely small and cramped, and they've removed the outdoor bench! There's a heavy focus on takeout orders, which contributes to the slow and inflexible service. The bathroom is public, not private, and the waiting area is limited and crowded, often resulting in wait times that spill over into the dining area. Unfortunately, there are no fresh beverage options, only machine-dispensed drinks. The staff's service processes never seem to improve, and the checkout process is always cumbersome. The shop opens late and closes early, and there are far too many loud, rowdy customers. Expect a chaotic environment with constant lines both inside and outside. While the interior is clean, it often feels messy, with rarely-cleaned tabletops. Overall, the noise level is uncomfortably high due to the chaotic atmosphere, making it a magnet for stress, tension, and disputes. The vibe resembles a bar, with constant foot traffic at the entrance. The food and drink selection is extremely limited, only offering fresh items when they’re just made. The menu never changes and only features cold drinks—sugary sodas and a few desserts. Prices are exorbitantly high, with frequent increases, yet the availability of napkins and utensils is limited. The packaging for orders is poorly done, resulting in spills, leaks, and other mishaps. If you encounter any issues, refunds are not an option, and there’s no owner on site to address problems. Most customers seem to be disruptive or problematic, leading to a tense environment where conflicts brew regularly. This place is essentially a Hispanic/Latino version of "Fast Food Hell." In summary, it may be convenient, but the quality is average at best. *Vegetarian options: Limited. Dietary restrictions: Not suitable for those with restrictions, as most food is fried, cheesy, or pre-packaged. No customization options are accepted on the ethnic menu, which lacks diversity and consistency in pricing. Parking: Available in the shopping mall lot. Kid-friendliness: Appears to be accommodating. Wheelchair accessibility: None.*"

Full menu - 35 options

All prices are estimates on menu.

Hot Sauce

Empanadas

Dessert

Chicken

Get'em By The Box

Chicken Wings

Main Entrees

Mexican-American Food

Other Things

Veggie Subs

Potato, Mac & Cheese Balls

Entrées

Veggies & Cheese Empanadas

Chicken Dishes

Main Course

Featured Items

Plant Based

Side Orders & Extras

James James

good empanadas but way too expensive. I couldn't believe 4 of them came out to like $16. Go to any hood and they're a dollar or two

Address

Show Map

Reviews

Karina
Karina

We've ordered from this restaurant before and loved the food. However, this time the plantains were quite hard, and two of the beef empanadas turned out to be chicken instead.


Kiera
Kiera

This restaurant has completely captivated me! The food is absolutely delicious. I can't predict when I'll get over this obsession, but for now, I'm thoroughly enjoying every bite. Thank you!


Kevin
Kevin

My order was completely wrong! They didn't include the sauce I requested, left out one shrimp empanada, and the plantains were burnt to a crisp! I would never recommend spending your money here! View menu


Samantha
Samantha

Every time I order from this restaurant, there's always an issue with my order. They never include the sauces I choose in the app. For instance, if I order spicy empanadas with sour cream, they end up sending red and green sauce instead.


kimbe313
kimbe313

I ordered food online for my boyfriend and me and picked it up. This is a wonderful restaurant to visit with friends who enjoy meat, as they have a wide variety of options for meat lovers, along with some selections for vegans and vegetarians. We tried the lunch special, and it was truly delightful.


Jiovani
Jiovani

The empanadas at this restaurant are outstanding. However, the chipotle-style ones tend to have an aftertaste that I don't particularly enjoy. I usually prefer chicken, but surprisingly, I found the ground beef option to be better in this case. As for the maduros, they're inconsistent—sometimes they're delicious, but at other times they are quite dry. View menu


Judith
Judith

It might have just been a matter of bad timing, but the staff was made up of a group of young guys who were joking and discussing topics definitely not suited for a work environment. I ordered chicken fingers and fries, and I was let down to discover that I paid $14 for chicken fingers that were completely burnt. One bite actually hurt my tooth, and they had a taste that was old and stale.


Jiovani
Jiovani

I was quite disappointed with my experience at the restaurant. When I think of maduros, I expect a dish that exceeds the standard, but what I received were under ripe plantains from the steam table that tasted like cardboard. I was told there would be a wait, and I thought that meant they were preparing fresh ones. Unfortunately, I was wrong; the delay was actually because they were taking phone orders instead. As for the empanadas, they were just kept warm in a display case, which didn't look very appetizing.


Angie
Angie

Review: This restaurant offers nothing remarkable. Here’s a brief overview of the issues: It only caters to those who can handle lactose and eat spicy foods. The ambiance is dull and monotonous, and the majority of the staff is teenagers who frequently make mistakes. The space is extremely small and cramped, and they've removed the outdoor bench! There's a heavy focus on takeout orders, which contributes to the slow and inflexible service. The bathroom is public, not private, and the waiting area is limited and crowded, often resulting in wait times that spill over into the dining area. Unfortunately, there are no fresh beverage options, only machine-dispensed drinks. The staff's servi... View menu

Categories

  • Seafood Dive into the freshest catches of the sea with our seafood selection, featuring exquisite dishes prepared with high-quality fish and shellfish. Savor the flavors of the ocean in every bite!
  • Catering Catering services offering a diverse range of delicious and beautifully presented dishes, perfect for any event or gathering. Our menu combines creativity with quality ingredients to delight your guests. View menu
  • Caribbean Savor the vibrant flavors of the Caribbean, where spicy jerk, fresh seafood, tropical fruits, and rich stews blend to create a delightful and exotic dining experience reminiscent of island breezes.
  • Latin-american Explore a vibrant array of Latin-American dishes that bring the rich flavors of the region to your plate, from zesty ceviches to hearty empanadas, each dish is a celebration of tradition and culinary creativity.

Amenities

  • Wifi
  • Delivery
  • menu
  • Television
  • menu
  • Outdoor Seating

Similar Restaurants