Old Carolina Barbecue Company

Phone: (+1)3309300300

Address: 1330 N Main St, Orrville, OH, 44667, United States

City: Orrville

Menu Dishes: 35

Reviews: 10

Website: https://oldcarolina.com/

Full menu - 35 options

All prices are estimates on menu.

Sandwiches

Pulled Pork Sandwich

Tender pulled pork served on a soft bun with tangy BBQ sauce and crunchy coleslaw.

Pulled Chicken Sandwich

Tender pulled chicken marinated in BBQ sauce, served on a soft bun with pickles and coleslaw.

Sliced Brisket Sandwich

Sliced brisket served on a fresh bun, topped with BBQ sauce.

Chopped Brisket Sandwich

Tender chopped brisket served on a soft bun, complemented by a rich BBQ sauce for a savory delight.

Dessert

Banana Pudding

Creamy banana pudding layered with vanilla wafers and fresh bananas, topped with whipped cream.

Chocolate Brownie

Rich, gooey chocolate brownie with a fudgy center, topped with a dusting of powdered sugar.

Reg. Side

Bulk Add-Ons

Burger

Salads

Mediterranean Feast

Lunch Bowls

Base

Grilled chicken wrap with fresh veggies, tangy sauce, and a side of crispy fries.

Bulk Menu

Mains

Smoked Ribs

Tender, smoky ribs slow-cooked to perfection and glazed with a tangy BBQ sauce for a savory, melt-in-your-mouth experience.

Starters

Ala Cart Sides

Barbecue Ribs

Country Vegetables N' Sides

Country Green Beans

Tender green beans cooked with onions and bacon for a hearty, homestyle flavor.

Entrées

Bbq Plates

Western Meal

Sandwiches And Plates

Premium Side

Pub Fare

Kid's

Beef Brisket

Address

Amenities

Similar Restaurants

Que Pasa

➤ 525 N Main St, Orrville I-44667-1213, United States

Menu • Pizza • Lunch • Mexican • Terrace

"Loved everything about this place. Food was tasty, plentiful, and inexpensive. It was served sizzling hot within five minutes of ordering. Service was excellent (we ate in the bar area but not actually at the bar). Best of all draft beer served in a very frosted mug! Wish we lived closer."

Old Carolina Barbecue Company Orrville Restaurant

➤ 1330 N Main St, Orrville, United States Of America

Menu • Fish • Pizza • Cheese • Barbecue

"Drove 2 1/2 hours for this wonderful experience. The staff is always attentive, friendly and engaging the environment always appropriately accepting clean and inviting. Food reminiscing the days my brother and I will go visit our grandparents in North Carolina. Job well done all the way across-the-board"

Gionino's Pizzeria

➤ 127 E Water St, Orrville, OH, 44667, United States

Menu • Pizza • Italian • Pizzeria • Sandwiches

"I have always ordered the family feast and have always received great service and always got everything I ordered but we ordered the family feast today and didn't get our coleslaw and we called in and the person on the phone said that the delivery driver would drop it off on his way back out and the delivery driver was EXTREMELY RUDE!!!!!!! He said we didn't click on the coleslaw and that he didn't have to bring it back by and that he would not be doing that anymore. I don't know what happened to your customer service but I don't think we will be ordering from you anymore. Service: Delivery Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $30–50 Service: 1"

Jerry's Cafe & Bar

➤ 266 W Market St Orrville, OH 44667, United States

Menu • Fish • Soup • Cheese • Chicken

"After several attempts over many days no one will answer the phone now goes to a fax call, my spouce goes to Jerry's Cafe to tell them about the phone being out of service the waitress procedto to tell him they do not answer the calls because it take to much time! He proceeded to try and place a order in person and the same waitress said sorry are foods frozen and we have no one to prepare it nor do we have staff to keep up with the dirty dishes. The kitchen was visible enough for my spouce to see stavks of dirty dishes with dried food still stuck on them sitting on a prep table. My spouce observed the bar however was full and had two waitresses waiting on those customers.Please take down the website phone number as well as post on your restaurant door your not properly running a sanitary restaurant. False advertisements are illegal and Jerrys should be temporarily closed untill they correct all the issues or close your restaurant. We are not the only people who are disappointed with the lack of consideration for faithful loyal customers.."

Dravenstott's

➤ 401 W High St, Orrville, United States

Menu • Brunch • American • Breakfast • North American

"The food isn 't quite as stale as the decor was my response to the question How was everything , but the girl taking my payment didn 't get it. The exterior of the building is very misleading. It 's well taken care of, the plants are pretty, and the siding looks newer. Inside...it has the same decor as it did when it opened in 1969. We went because we were at another business in Orville and someone said that this place and the Amish place had a salad bar...we should have gone to the Amish place instead. We should of walked right back out when we saw the decor, and that the average age of the clientele was nearly dead. There are old menus badly framed on the wall going to the restroom and it looks like nothing much has changed in over 50 years. We had to pick through the lettuce to find some that wasn 't turning brown. The boast of over 60 toppings had attracted us...but there were nothing special about any of them. Most were prepackaged, nothing was homemade. The homemade bread consisted of a loaf of possibly freshly made origins (but maybe not made today), but it was badly presented on a side table with plastic wrap over it. The butter was in a dish that everyone had been digging out of, and was also of questionable age. The award winning soup wasn 't bad, but again the presentation sucked. The display cases and utensils all looked original from 1969. While at the salad bar I had to move out of the way because a waitress was loading a bowl for a guest. She didn 't say excuse me, just pushed past. I 'm a big guy and like a good soup and salad bar...I made one trip. That says a lot. Then there was the staff. They weren 't particularly unfriendly...but they weren 't very attentive. I know, we were getting the salad bar, and they seemed friendly to their regular customers...mostly old folks, who are probably the only people keeping the place in business. I looked at the food coming out and wouldn 't return for that either. For two of us we spent over $30...and it wasn 't worth half that."