"We were hesitant to eat here after being turned away by every other nearby restaurant, especially given the mixed reviews and the restaurant’s relatively empty appearance. However, we ended up having a really enjoyable meal with attentive and friendly service. My martini was solid—something that’s often hard to come by—and the oysters were good, though not exceptional. The lobster roll was excellent, and the Mexican spice mussels were delicious. Our daughter’s pesto pasta with grilled shrimp was flavorful and cooked perfectly. Although we started with low expectations, having dined at nearly every restaurant in Sag Harbor, MTK Lobster House held its own that night. We will definitely be returning."
