"Despite living nearby in the 1990s, this was my first visit to the Holbrook Diner on July 21, 2023. The diner boasts a unique blend of retro and modern décor, featuring neon purple ceiling lights and chandeliers that complement the faux wooden flooring and floor-to-ceiling windows overlooking Main Street in Holbrook. From the moment we were seated, the service was outstanding. Our waiter was skilled and attentive without being rushed. The central location of the server hub and counter likely contributed to this efficient service.
Although the menu presented an extensive array of choices, I quickly decided on the eggplant parmigiana with spaghetti. This dish has been my summer vacation staple in Long Island, as reflected in my previous reviews. Priced at $21.95, it also came with a choice of soup or salad, and I opted for the Manhattan Clam Chowder. I’ve consistently found that diners serve exceptional Manhattan Clam Chowder, and the Holbrook Diner was no exception.
Before my entrée arrived, I enjoyed a house salad with honey mustard dressing, courtesy of my brother. When my eggplant parmigiana with spaghetti finally came, I was thoroughly pleased with both the portion size and flavor. While some might argue that this dish would be better at an Italian restaurant like Mama Lombardi's across the street, I believe that’s an unfair comparison. My brother wasn't in the mood for Italian, my dad had other preferences, and I craved Italian food, which is why we chose the diverse menu at the Holbrook Diner.
The meal was substantial enough to easily offer a second helping. I paired the food with a couple of Cokes, and our waiter was quick to keep my glass filled. As a fan of reputable Long Island diners, I can confidently say that the Holbrook Diner ranks among the best."
