"Gatehouse is a family-friendly tavern with a relaxed and welcoming atmosphere, and the service is warm and attentive. Beer enthusiasts will appreciate the extensive selection, with over 30 draft options and more than 40 bottles and cans, featuring classic favorites as well as many locally crafted specialties. It’s also an excellent spot to catch your favorite sports teams on TV, with the promise: “If it’s on, we’ll find it.”
We kicked off our evening with the House Nacho Tray ($11, with the option to add Pork, Chicken, or Chili for $6) and the Fried Wisconsin Cheese Curds ($12). The nachos were among the best I've ever had, generously topped with Queso, Sour Cream, Black Beans, Salsa, Scallions, and Jalapeños. The cheese curds had a perfect balance of crunch on the outside and gooey warmth inside, complemented by a tangy Marinara dipping sauce.
For the main course, I enjoyed the Double Bacon Smash Burger ($17, served with Fries, Chips, Pasta Salad, or Green Salad). It was everything you desire in a big, juicy burger, and the flavorful House Burger Sauce was an ideal finishing touch. The Smoked Brisket Burnt Ends Sandwich ($17) is also worth trying, or opt for the Platter ($20) served with Coleslaw and Potato Salad. The sandwiches come on a freshly baked Brioche bun, making for a fantastic experience. I also tried the Philly Cheese Steak Sandwich ($16, which includes a side). The tender steak, along with Peppers, Mushrooms, Onions, and Provolone cheese, was delicious, but my sandwich initially had only a small amount of cheese. A quick trip back to the kitchen resolved that issue, and the Potato Salad was a nice side addition.
However, there were a few disappointments. The Tavern Chili ($10 for a large bowl) was bland, even with the added Cheese, Sour Cream, Scallions, and Jalapeños; I wouldn’t recommend it to serious chili fans. The Fish and Chips ($17) also fell short; the “hand-battered” fish was more breaded than battered and lacked the expected crunch. The two medium-sized pieces of fish reminded me of those found in the frozen food aisle at a grocery store.
Overall, I encourage you to give Gatehouse a try; there are plenty of popular options on their extensive menu that you’re likely to enjoy."
