"Before visiting Napper Tandy’s in Bay Shore, forget all assumptions you may have about Irish Pubs. My wife and I frequent Bay Shore for meals, and although we had passed by Napper Tandy’s many times, we never thought to go in, assuming it was just a loud and rowdy dive bar. How wrong we were! On our visit tonight (3/8/23), we sat at a table in a cozy corner opposite the bar. Our server, Ryan, who also tended the bar, greeted us warmly. We chatted about dining options in Bay Shore and other restaurants we had tried. After swiftly bringing our drinks, Ryan gave us time to peruse the menu (while offering some helpful suggestions). When he returned to take our orders, he assisted us in selecting from the specials menu. My wife opted for the chicken lettuce wraps, recommended by Ryan, while I started with the delicious potato leek soup before enjoying the Irish Bacon and Cabbage - leaner and more flavorful than the Corned Beef I had considered. Our food arrived promptly, was expertly prepared, and all of our choices were hot, perfectly cooked, and flavorful. Ryan checked on us several times throughout the meal but was never intrusive - always engaging and friendly. As regular diners (once or twice a week), we can confidently say that Napper Tandy’s in Bay Shore will definitely be a place we will return to soon. A big thank you to Ryan and the entire team at Napper Tandy’s for welcoming us and providing such an exceptional dining experience."
