Nightingale Supper Club

Great Wisconsin Fish Fry done in the true Supper Club tradition. Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $20–30 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Fish Fry

Very nice supper club. Excellent fish dinner Wednesday night. Superb prime rib on Thursday. The smoked whitefish cake was an excellent appetizer also and the creamed asparagus Superb was delicious!

We stopped at 4 when they openedto eat but reservations were booked until 615. It looked like a nice place friends told us that it was excellent will try later Parking space: Plenty of parking Parking options: Free parking lot Ver carta

Old school supper club. Prime rib sandwich was amazing. Loaded baked potato was okay. Server and bartender were very attentive. Service: Dine in Price per person: $30–50 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 3 Recommended dishes: Prime Rib Sandwich

Wonderful supper club with great service and bar staff. We come here every time we visit Door County and are never disappointed. The fish and prime rib are excellent. Thank you Nicole for being our server and the great bar tenders who mix a great old fashioned . We will be back soon.

Delicious dinner and great service! We were lucky enough to be there for the prime rib special and it was amazing! Reasonable prices, great service and amazing food! Highly recommend!!! Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $30–50 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Asparagus Crab Soup, Cheese Curds Ver carta

excellent meal. prime rib was perfect. kartoffeln were excellent (one was upgraded) we had different suppen and both were excellent. a couple of years ago, a roommate the sturgeon bay was told by nightingale. I never managed to curse it during one of our fish creeks. Two. 1. they were fully booked. Secondly, we booked a week before us. they have to get into the process of or you probably don't come in. we will certainly be back. they spoke to the neighbourly and could not speak much of it and had been there several times.

Came in admittedly later on a busy night, but were given a buzzer and asked to wait at the bar. Five minutes later the hostess came up to us and announced that they would be unable to serve a party of our size (5) this late in the day. A bit disappointed, we gathered our items and headed towards the door as another party (2) entered and were seated. Perhaps a coincidence that our party was mainly young Hispanic adults...or not. Gladly took and continue to take our money to other nearby establishments- with great food and great customer service. Sorry Nightingale, you are not that special.

Sad that I?m not able to experience such tasty food more often, lol.. If I lived in the area this would probably be my go-to. We had a 6pm reservation and we were sat promptly. Within 15 minutes of sitting we?d already had our drinks and our appetizer (thestuffed mushrooms ???? , I got a salad with my entree and would?ve preferred some more cucumbers and tomatoes but really wishedI would?ve gotten the lobster soup that my boyfriend got because it was SO tasty dipped with the warm bread. From the appetizerto dessert I was seriously impressed! Next time I?m in Door County I plan on stopping in again. Ver carta