Fortino's Tavern - Carte

This restaurant is fantastic! The food is incredible, the views are stunning, and the service is excellent. I also enjoy watching games at the bar!

Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $100+ Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 4 Recommended dishes: Lobster Roll, Pulled Pork, Mixed Green Salad with Balsamic Vinaigrette, Seafood Fra Diavolo

Fantastic food paired with exceptional service! Owner Nikki always makes you feel right at home. **Service**: Dine-in **Meal type**: Dinner **Price per person**: $100+ **Food**: 5/5 **Service**: 5/5 **Atmosphere**: 5/5 **Recommended dishes**: Lobster Roll, Key Lime Pie Voir le carte

In my view, there’s no need for any restaurant on Long Island to require a credit card for making a reservation! This policy completely turned me off, so I won’t be visiting this establishment. Please don’t alienate your neighbors—we want to support you, especially during the winter months.

This restaurant was amazing! On the recommendation of a barmaid in town, I tried the mushroom pappardelle, which was a small plate but absolutely perfect. We also shared the lobster roll, which came with a side of fantastic tortellini salad—it was the best I've ever had! I'm already looking forward to my next vacation so I can go back.

I had dinner with my friend Jill on Thursday night, and it was one of the best steaks I've ever had. The chefs did an incredible job, and the service was as smooth as butter. I honestly loved everything we tried, but the creamy Pappardelle pasta with mushrooms was absolutely mind-blowing! Thank you so much for a wonderful experience. I can't wait to come back again! Voir le carte

The ambiance of the restaurant was wonderful. However, the food was just average. The fish lacked flavor and was a bit dry, and it seemed slightly overcooked (though I suppose that's common with fish). The Pasta Diavolo was unmemorable, featuring just one scallop, two shrimp, half a lobster tail, and small pieces of fish mixed into the pasta. In hindsight, I should have opted for a lobster roll.

I absolutely loved everything about this restaurant. The food was outstanding—delicious and truly exceptional. The service was fantastic; the staff was attentive and clearly supported one another, ensuring that we received impeccable service throughout our visit. Dining under the stars on the dock added to the charm of the experience. With the perfect combination of delicious food, exceptional service, and a lovely atmosphere, this restaurant is a must-visit and one of the best in the entire Hamptons.

This restaurant likely offers the finest water views of any establishment on the North Fork of Long Island. The gourmet cuisine, inventive drinks, and highly attentive staff all contribute to a fantastic dining experience. You're seated right on the dock over the water, allowing you to be completely immersed in the beauty of the aquatic surroundings. The only downside is the price, which can easily exceed $200 for two, but that’s to be expected on the North Fork. Make this restaurant the grand finale of your vacation on the North Fork! Voir le carte