Umberto's Of Oyster Bay

Greek Cove East Norwich

➤ 1003 Oyster Bay Rd, 11732, EAST NORWICH, United States

Piatti • Meat • Pizza • Greek • Falafel

---

"Im tire the front desk get the orders wrong !!! The managers answer today was: Ok for me to go to another place or speak with the owner… Potatoes old if you don’t remind the to be fresh,,, They give rice if you ask for potatoes. The owner need to bethere pr one of their kids More rice than anything."

Coach Meeting House

➤ 160 Mill River RoadNY 11771, OYSTER BAY, United States

Piatti • Steak • Asiatic • Seafood • American

---

"I had been really looking forward to going here with my girlfriends, unfortunately we were all disappointed. I ordered a s’mores martini, waitress/bartender brought it over and said they were out of graham cracker rim and marshmallows. Handed me a regular looking espresso martini that I was charged $19.99 for as a “s’mores”. Did not provide opportunity to switch to another martini before delivering this sad, overpriced drink that was missing the main ingredients making it a “special” one. Food was mediocre at best. Had ala vodka pasta and asked to add grilled shrimp instead of chicken. They gave me 3 shrimp and charged $12.99 for it. Again, a little sad and overpriced. Service was greatly lacking. Waitress never came by to check on us during the apps or main course. Had to ask bus boy 2x for salt/pepper, which we didn’t get until end of meal. The dining room/bar area is pretty, however the giant mirror/specials board was completely smudged/erased is several spots couldn't really make out what it was saying and it looked super sloppy. For the price they charge and the terrible service received I would not recommend and will not be coming back. Food: 2 Service: 1 Atmosphere: 2"

Sabeli

➤ 623 Jericho Turnpike, Syosset, United States

Piatti • Soup • Pizza • Delis • Salads

---

"THIS IS THE HOLY GRAIL OF DELIS. I wish that was an exaggeration, but I am NYC born and Queens-bred, so judging delis and bodegas is in my blood. Sabeli is 12/10 in every single category, every time I have ordered. I needed to write a review this time because on this occasion, I asked Ms. Michelle to re-create a sandwich I love from a restaurant in the city. She absolutely nailed it- it required caramelized onions which they do not have ready but they took the time to do it for me during their busiest hour of the day (1 pm lunch) and it's those little things that keep us going during our crazy days. Sabeli treats their customers like family, the quality of the food is unbelievable; perfect and fresh to order every time. The service is as fast as possible without compromising on courtesy, friendliness and professionalism. And for those who may be skeptical about the price, I assure you that given the sky-rocketing costs of everything their prices are still extremely competitive and reasonable and barely reflects the incredible quality of the food you get. Sabeli is worth every dollar and visit. Love this place!"

Rare650

➤ 650 Jericho Turnpike Syosset, NY 11791, 11791-4566, United States

Piatti • Tea • Steak • Sushi • Coffee

---

"Rerurned to Rare 650 tonight after a few years. Overall the dinner was ok. Not amazing but not terrible. I was surprised that they had openings every 30 minutes on a Saturday night. Ok, maybe it's a slow season after summer is over. We we seated right away, great : But got the worst table right by the kitchen path. So, every time someone passed by they hit the back of my chair without a word of apology. The drinks came afrer 25 min wait. Every table got a bread basket with butter, we didn't get any butter. At the middle of the meal the waiter came and took the olive oil bottle that was on the table, ok, they might've really needed it : Overall, the service was underwhelming. Nobody came to check on us after we ordered. Now to food. Starters were tuna watermelon ceviche and short rib wellington. Tuna had a little fishy taste and was so fatty, def not sushi-grade tuna. I left 90% of it untouched on the plate. Nobody even asked me why when they took my plate. Short rib wellington was ok. Short rib tasted good but the pastry was served on the side and didn't add anything to the dish. Entres were seared lamb chops, marimated skirt steak with chimichurri sauce and mushrooms. The lamb chops were really good, so were the mushrooms. The skirt steak ordered medium rare came out rare. Better than overdone. So, it wasn't sent back. It came with a weird bbq/ horseradish sauce which was so overpowering, so glad we ordered chimichurri. Drinks were good. Smoked old fashioned was very balanced and mild in bourbon flavor. The first drink came under the dome with the smoke comimg out of it, the second one was just delivered to the table with no presentation. I guess it was an ok meal, but considefing the price point and the restaurant's reputation, I expected much more."

It's Greek To Me

➤ 127 Jackson Ave, 11791, Syosset, United States

Piatti • Meat • Greek • Seafood • Mediterranean

---

"Outstanding! We finally discovered an authentic Greek restaurant with a genuine mom-and-pop vibe. I just returned home after ordering food for my family, and with every bite, we felt so grateful to have chosen this place. We’re quite particular about where we eat and always prioritize cleanliness alongside the taste of the food. From the moment you step inside, it feels like you’re entering your grandparents’ restaurant, filled with warmth and charm. You can clearly see the professional way they prepare the food. I had a lovely conversation with the lady who made my meal, and she was incredibly kind. The flavors were so authentic and genuine; I really can’t stand mass-produced food chains (like Chipotle), as their offerings often taste mechanical. But the food at It's Greek to Me made me feel cozy and satisfied! I can’t wait to order from this restaurant again! There’s absolutely no hesitation in recommending it. Clean and delicious!"