Fogarty's - Menu

Order to go NYE 2022! Ready to serve, no dishes and a great menu. Broiled Salmon, Turkey dinner, Reuben sandwich, Buffalo Chicken tenders, mashed potatoes, gravy, onion rings, sweet potato fries, squash, pickle spear and Cheese Cake from the bakery for dessert!

We had a lovely late lunch on Saturday with family members visiting from different places. Everyone finished their meals entirely! We took home some butternut cranberry soup and Indian pudding for the next day. We'll definitely be returning. The servers were friendly and prompt.

Excellent food! We ordered a large order of onion rings as an appetizer not to recognize that their portion sizes are HUGE! There were enough onion rings for a small army! The burger was amazing and the house made cake beautiful treat! Wait staff super helpful and extremely nice! View menu

This place is amazing! The portions are huge, reasonably priced and most importantly, absolutely delicious! Our server was Travis and let me tell you, he’s fantastic and makes you feel like you’re part of the Fogarty’s family. If you’re in the area, you need to check this place out!

Lobster roll $30) and lobster stew $20) were good. There is a large out door patio which is what attracted us to this restaurant for safe pandemic time eating. They also have a large number of indoor tables. The bathroom was spacious and clean. Overall, pleased with food and outdoor option.

We LOVE this place! Moved to the area about a year ago. Finally tried this place and it is our new go-to and favorite spot, and i expect it to stay that way. Huge menu, large portions, friendly staff, and everything we've ever ordered is great! We haven't ever had to wait long either. Kid friendly. Also amazing pies you can pick up or order ahead if you want a particular kind. Highly recommend!!! View menu

I recently visited Fogarty’s for the first time, and it certainly won't be my last. The restaurant is in a quiet location away from the hustle and bustle of other dining spots. I was in town for business and turned to Yelp for recommendations, and I wasn't disappointed. The waitress was friendly and very helpful; when I asked her for her signature dish, she suggested the Lobster Pie. As a lobster lover, I can tell you it was absolute heaven! The Clam Chowder on the side was also exceptional. Considering the generous portion sizes and reasonable prices, this place is definitely worth a visit. I give it five stars!

After years, I finally returned to South Berwick for dinner and had an amazing experience! My server, Joe, was outstanding and the food was incredible. I ordered the grilled lobster stew and the caprese sandwich, which featured fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, and basil—delicious! The fried vegetables were just as good as I remembered and didn't let me down this time. We were so full that we couldn't eat another bite, but we made sure to save room for cheesecake! Thank you for a perfect evening; we’ll definitely be back for our next date night. We went at 7:00 on a Saturday and only waited twenty minutes. Trust me, you won’t regret dining here!

When we opened our dinner at home, we noticed there were two small cups: one contained the lobster stew, while the other was a mystery. We didn’t receive the salad dressing we ordered, nor an extra side of dressing or tartar sauce for the fried fish, which we expected would be included. The mysterious cup contained warm Gorgonzola chunks with dressing that had a strange layer of either butter or oil on top. It was unpleasant and tasted terrible. The lobster stew was essentially chunks of lobster floating in that same hot butter/oil mixture. For nearly $70 for two people, the quality presented was unacceptable and rushed. Given our long history of dining at Fogarty’s, my fiancé decided to c... View menu