Vicario's Pizza - Menu

The pizza was excellent! The chef really nailed the sauce and cheese. The only downside was that the drinks had an odd taste, but aside from that, the food was fantastic, and the staff was very friendly.

Ordered carry out. We waited over and hour when they said it would be here. They said 6:20 it arrived at 7:15 pizza and bread sticks were cold. This is the 2nd time I've had a problem and will not be ordering again.

They are liars and rude as hell their managers are terrible their owners and managers do not communicate and their employees are disrespectful do not order here they lie their website is dishonest and they will not honor what their website says View menu

I'm newer to Bellefontaine but my boyfriend is from here, and we went out to eat here late last week and the sweet sauce, I didn't know it was even a thing but now, NO other pizza place is except able to me. This place has it all between being nice, amazing service ? terrific food. This place is a absolute blessing.

If you love mushrooms then you’ll love the buffet. Stopped for the first time to try the buffet and all the pizzas had mushrooms on them except one and it was hawaiian ?? Asked the waitress working if they had only pepperoni pizza coming out soon and she said they bring out what they make in the back. Gave the vibe that I was bothering her for asking. Won’t be going back.

The pizza was decent; the crust was thick, and the toppings were a bit sparse. The cheese was flavorful, but it felt like there was a bit too much for my liking. The soda didn’t taste quite right, but the server was kind enough to bring us cans instead. The service was slow, not because of the server, but due to the kitchen's pace. I’m glad I gave this place a shot, but I’m looking forward to trying other restaurants in the future. View menu

Placed our order for a party of 10 and waited almost an hour for the food to start arriving. The server then told me, after an hour, that I could not get a hamburger because they had ran out of hamburger. Should not take that long to figure out that they had run out of product. There were only about 15 to 20 other people eating inside. A lot of ? went out the door while waiting on our food to arrive. It appears that if one orders something besides pizza, you could be in for a long wait.

I’m done going to Vicarios, which is sad because I have been frequenting them since moving here 8 years ago! Within the last couple years they have CONSTANTLY raised their prices without reflecting the change in their menus. They added QR codes to their napkin holders which they claimed had updated price lists, but that proved to be wrong this last time I went. Yesterday after finding the flatbread pizza was 11.99 instead of 9.99 as listed on both menus, I asked it be corrected and the server talked to the manager and they refused. I asked to talk to the manager. They were on “break” and said I could call in tomorrow and talk to them. I paid my bill and left and will not return. There are to...

Loved the old location Vicario’s was in, this one, not so much. Went twice and was not impressed, decided to give it another try last night. When we arrived there was one other table with guests that were done but hanging out, we placed our order. Food took a little while, that’s ok as we like our food hot and fresh. The cheese bread appetizer came out after 3 of the 4 meals were delivered, thought that was odd considering no other buisness going on inside, the bread wasn’t piping hot so not fresh out the oven. One of our party ordered fries which his sandwich, his sandwich came without them, when asked the server she said something about them coming, they came out about 10 minutes later. I... View menu