Sutter's Mill - Menu

214 Route 59, Suffern, United States Of America, 10901-5200

🛍 Steak, Cheese, Seafood, Burgers

4 💬 1670 Reviews
Sutter's Mill

Phone: +18453576556

Address: 214 Route 59, Suffern, United States Of America, 10901-5200

City: Suffern

Menu Dishes: 9

Reviews: 1670

"Don't miss out on this hidden gem in the local area. The burgers are exceptional - juicy, flavorful, and packed with high-quality ingredients like beef, cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomato, onion, and pickles, all served on a perfectly buttery and toasted bun. Instead of the usual steak fries, they serve rustic-cut potatoes lightly salted to perfection. The chicken tenders are breaded and fried to perfection, without being greasy, and are generously sized. The wings are large, crispy, and available in a variety of flavors like teriyaki, buffalo, mango habanero, or traditional buffalo sauce. The pulled pork nachos are a delicious combination of savory pulled pork and tangy white cheese sauce, piled high on homemade tortilla chips. This restaurant comes highly recommended."

Full menu - 9 options

All prices are estimates on menu.

Burger

Chicken Wings

Main Courses

Egg Dishes

Entrées

Chicken

Chicken Dishes

Japanese Specialties

Nicholas Nicholas

Stopped her for a quick lunch between hockey games. Served fairly quick for the number of guests and food was good.

Address

Show Map

Reviews

Michelle
Michelle

The food was delicious! Able to sit immediately! The servers were attentive and kind, food was served without a feeling of waiting, and the prices were very reasonable!


S
S

Was always a great place. They had some issues with the cook for a while and the food became sub par but they are back! Everything was great tonight. New cook New menu Great Service Delicious food Will be back


E
E

I Ordered Buffalo wings and honestly forgot how good they are here. The cheese burger sliders were cooked just right. Steak Fries with gravy hit the spot and the beers are cold. Good spot I need to come here more often. View menu


u
u

Terrible! Limited menu and so we ordered 6 orders of wings and a burger for a total of $107.00 but you only came out with 1 order of wings and tell me to wait another 30 minutes for your mistake! Then the audacity to give us an attitude..THE NERVE!!! Took my $107.00 to Planet Wings instead!


Laura
Laura

Bar restaurant. Lots of bar food coices on the simple menu. At the corner of a small strip mall. Served quickly for a late lunch. Our waiter was very cordial and did a good job. Food was good and reasonably priced. I would recommend and return. Will probably try something different next time.


Jessica
Jessica

We took a break from dining at Sutters, but after hearing about their new kitchen, we decided to give it another try. And we were so glad we did! The burgers were amazing - big, juicy, and cooked to perfection. You can customize your burger however you like, which made it even better. We will definitely be coming back to Sutters for more delicious food. The staff is also fantastic - always friendly and welcoming. We had a great time laughing, eating, and enjoying the experience. Great job, Sutters! View menu


The
The

The bartender at this restaurant charged me and my friends $30 more than we should have paid. I contacted my credit card company, but there has been no refund processed yet. In addition to the initial overcharge, she added another $21 to our bill, bringing the total discrepancy to $51. I will be disputing this charge on my credit card. Despite her claim that she made a mistake in her head, I observed her using a calculator while reviewing the bill. I will not be returning to this establishment, even though the food was good. It is unacceptable to take advantage of customers, especially when they may be under the influence.


Nathalie
Nathalie

I dined in for a quick stop on the road. Found this spot on Google maps and decided to give it a chance. I had the cheeseburger with fries and a Guinness beer. It was one of the best medium rare burgers I’ve ever had. So juicy! I usually add mayo to my burgers but this one did not need any. perfection! However, I felt like the beer was served a bit too luke warm so I asked for a cup of ice. Not the best experience I’ve had with a beer. And it was a sad finish to my meal. But overall excellent customer service. Our server was very welcoming and kind. Also I’m willing to volunteer my graphic design skills for a drink menu! ‍


Investigator
Investigator

Don't miss out on this hidden gem in the local area. The burgers are exceptional - juicy, flavorful, and packed with high-quality ingredients like beef, cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomato, onion, and pickles, all served on a perfectly buttery and toasted bun. Instead of the usual steak fries, they serve rustic-cut potatoes lightly salted to perfection. The chicken tenders are breaded and fried to perfection, without being greasy, and are generously sized. The wings are large, crispy, and available in a variety of flavors like teriyaki, buffalo, mango habanero, or traditional buffalo sauce. The pulled pork nachos are a delicious combination of savory pulled pork and tangy white cheese sauce, pile... View menu

Categories

  • Steak Savor prime cuts of juicy, tender steaks, expertly grilled to perfection. Each bite offers a burst of flavor, served with classic sides and delectable sauces to enhance your dining experience.
  • Cheese A curated selection of artisanal cheeses from around the world, featuring diverse flavors and textures that delight the palate. Perfect for sharing or savored individually with the ideal accompaniments. View menu
  • Seafood Dive into the freshest catches of the sea with our seafood selection, featuring exquisite dishes prepared with high-quality fish and shellfish. Savor the flavors of the ocean in every bite!
  • Burgers Juicy, flavorful burgers crafted with premium ingredients, from classic beef to unique vegetarian options, all served with fresh toppings and a choice of hand-cut fries or a crisp salad.

Similar Restaurants