Tally Ho Tavern - Menu

201-205 West Fourth Street Bethlehem, PA 18015-1554, United States

🛍 Pubs, Pizza, Grill, International

3.9 💬 1544 Reviews
Tally Ho Tavern

Phone: +16108652591

Address: 201-205 West Fourth Street Bethlehem, PA 18015-1554, United States

City: Bethlehem

Menu Dishes: 28

Reviews: 1544

Website: http://www.tallyho610.com/

"I recently visited the Tally Ho and was absolutely blown away by the experience. The drink specials were fantastic, offering a great variety at unbeatable prices. The newly renovated historic setting added a touch of charm and elegance to the evening, making it a truly memorable visit. The service was top-notch, and the overall atmosphere was inviting and delightful. It 's no wonder this place has received numerous 5-star reviews – it truly deserves every bit of praise. I can 't wait to visit again!"

Full menu - 28 options

All prices are estimates on menu.

Fresh Neapolitan Pizzas

Entrées

Sandwiches

Side Dishes

Tacos

Chicken

10" Toasted Grinders

Eggs And Specialities

12In Pizzas

Wings

Chicken Dishes

Country Breakfasts

Steampots

Appetizers

Choose Two Sides

Cheese Steaks

Starters

Michael Michael

Decent selection on tap. Excellent burgers, tater tots, and chicken tacos. Bartender was friendly and efficient.

Address

Show Map

Reviews

Darryl
Darryl

Amy is the best she’ll take care of you like family (the good kind). The vibes are amazing and the decorations really set the mood


Mary
Mary

Great atmosphere, good menu and food. The bartender Amy is upbeat and personable and makes great drinks. Look forward to coming back!


CAMI
CAMI

Great vibes. Cheap drinks. Can get a bit crowded but it’s always a good time coming out here from Jersey. Nice little gem. They always play bangers View menu


Jeremiah
Jeremiah

I had a blast tonight. Bartenders and bouncers were super friendly. They were playing hip hop and some deep house. Dj was on point, and it had a sick vibe.


Fuzy
Fuzy

Favorite bar in Bethlehem, I had Amy Burns as my bartender and she was so sweet and hard working. Made my friends and I laugh so many times and made our weekend.


Kolbey
Kolbey

Service was good. Just stopped for drinks after dinner one night with a group of friends. Not a single soul on the “club” side after 10pm on a Saturday. It didn’t seem like the Tally of yesteryear. But the drinks were good and staff was friendly. View menu


Evan
Evan

Had a great experience around Thanksgiving time. Great atmosphere and music and the karaoke wait was not long given that the place was packed. Shoutout Amy Burns for serving me and the extra effort she puts in to ensure the guests have a good time.


richard
richard

Had a great experience there. Food was delicious, you must try the cheesesteak sandwich! The staff are very polite and take their jobs seriously. The mixed drinks are always on point, made with a friendly smile by Amy. Highly recommend to all my friends!


Dirty
Dirty

I recently visited the Tally Ho and was absolutely blown away by the experience. The drink specials were fantastic, offering a great variety at unbeatable prices. The newly renovated historic setting added a touch of charm and elegance to the evening, making it a truly memorable visit. The service was top-notch, and the overall atmosphere was inviting and delightful. It 's no wonder this place has received numerous 5-star reviews – it truly deserves every bit of praise. I can 't wait to visit again! View menu

Bethlehem

Bethlehem

Bethlehem, PA is known for its industrial history and vibrant arts scene. Local cuisine often includes Pennsylvania Dutch specialties like scrapple and whoopie pies.

Categories

  • Pubs "Discover a cozy atmosphere with hearty meals, craft beers, and classic pub fare. Enjoy comfort food favorites like fish and chips, burgers, and wings, paired with a refreshing pint or creative cocktail."
  • Pizza Delve into our perfectly baked pizzas, crafted with hand-tossed dough, rich tomato sauce, and a blend of gourmet cheeses. Each slice bursts with fresh toppings, ensuring a delightful bite every time. View menu
  • Grill Succulent meats and fresh vegetables perfectly cooked over an open flame, delivering rich smoky flavors. Savor tender steaks, juicy burgers, and tangy marinated kebabs, all grilled to perfection for an unforgettable dining experience.
  • International Explore a world of flavors with our diverse selection of international dishes, crafted to offer a culinary journey across continents, filled with vibrant and authentic tastes from around the globe.

Amenities

  • Beer
  • Discover
  • menu
  • Visa Card
  • menu
  • Cocktails

Similar Restaurants

Edge

Edge

74 West Broad Street, Bethlehem, 18018, United States Of America

Menu • Fish • Asian • French • Drinks


"The first time I went here during Restaurant Week on a date with my significant other, I thought the atmosphere was great, the food wasn’t too bad, and the drinks were made very well. In fact, we liked this restaurant so much that we suggested having a company party here so others could try it, as well. Needless to say, that was a horrible idea. As we learned, this restaurant doesn’t know how to accomodate large parties. Our party included about 11 adults and we had made reservations at least two weeks in advance, maybe more. We willingly changed our reservation time to a later time to better accomodate the restaurant and they still did an awful job at accomodating us. They have a party room, but we were not offered to sit in there despite the fact that it was empty when we got there- and still empty when we left. When we got there, our table wasn’t ready and what they finally arranged for us was cramped and uncomfortable. It would have been nice to be able to talk with the rest of the people sitting at the table; however, it wasn’t really possible given the seating arrangements. As far as the food was concerned, the tuna tartare appetizer was the standout of the evening, and everything else was sort of mediocre. I ordered salmon and it came with potato and vegetable sides, all of which were cold or lukewarm when I got my plate. From what I heard from a few people around me, everyone else enjoyed what they got, but it wasn’t memorable food by any means- standard fare like crab cakes and steak. Boring. For dessert, quite a few people at the table ordered the chocolate pot du creme- which turned out to be a generous portion of thick, heavy CHOCOLATE GANACHE that was way too much to eat for a dessert portion. It might have been good if it was a smaller portion, or used to top a cake, but they served it in what looked like a small soup bowl. Ugh. During the course of our stay, everyone had at least 2-4 cocktails, an appetizer, main course, and dessert. You can do the math to roughtly figure out what the bill would be for 11 people before tax and tip. Keeping that in mind, not 10 minutes after we had finished our desserts, the manager came over and we were conspicuosly ASKED TO LEAVE because a party of 12 had just arrived. REALLY?! I looked around as we were walking out and noticed that more than half of the tables on the one side of the restaurant were EMPTY. The arriving party could have easily been seated in that area, and our party would have probably ordered at least a few more drinks per person!! The way I see it, they lost out on maybe an extra $100 or more for the bar – and future business – because of how we were innappropriately rushed out the door. The restaurant is OK for couples, but I wouldn’t consider going back with a group- if at all. I frankly haven’t been back there since this experience. It is a damn shame that we reccomended going there because I know it would have been a much better experience at the place we usually go to. The GM wouldn’t dare to kick paying customers out, especially a party of people, 10 minutes after they finished their dessert because they know how to plan reservations accordingly."