The Bagelry - Menu

1401 Walnut St, Cincinnati, United States

🛍 Bagels, Coffee, Cheese, Catering

4.7 💬 5478 Reviews

Phone: (+1)5139750631

Address: 1401 Walnut St, Cincinnati, United States

City: Cincinnati

Menu Dishes: 14

Reviews: 5478

Website: http://bagelrycincy.com/

"Update 2023: 5 stars 3 stars. The bagels are still top notch, but I really have a huge problem with them making a very skimpy lox bagel. 4 oz of smoked salmon on a bagel has been the standard for forever. Their lox bagel now only has 2 oz… not even enough to be satisfying. I love a nice lox bagel but that's just a massive letdown. $10 for a lox bagel with only 2 oz of salmon is a ripoff. $16 for a lox bagel with 4 oz of salmon is far more expensive than anywhere else in this entire city (this is not Chicago SF NYC). Please bring the lox bagel prices back to reality. I'm so excited for OTR to get a bagel shop!The Bagelry soft opened today at their first brick mortar location which is at 14th Walnut in OTR. The grand opening is Friday October 5th and then they'll be open 7 days a week. I'd had their bagels a few times at Findlay Market and Second Sunday, so I was excited to check it out.I ordered the bacon, egg cheddar bagel sandwich on a pumpkin spice bagel (cause basic is life). Overall it was great. The eggs were fluffy and the bacon was crisp. The only change I'd suggest to the bagel sandwich itself is to add a bit of cream cheese.They also have local coffee available from Urbana Cafe!The ordering and pick up experience was pretty smooth and very fast. I was in and out in 5 minutes, and they have a standing bar around the windows if you want to stay and eat. I definitely encourage you to come by and check it out."

Full menu - 14 options

All prices are estimates on menu.

Sandwiches

Salads

Bread

Extras

Wraps

Bagels

X-Treme Melt

Bagels And Spreads

Bakery

Bagels & Spreads

Andrew Andrew

Omg what a place. Food here is amazing. Definitely going back.

Address

Show Map

Reviews

Justin
Justin

These bagels are consistently the best and freshest I have found in Ohio so far.


SweetMystique
SweetMystique

I love this place. The bagels are simple and delicious and the customer service is sweet and comfy. Love the atmosphere


Connor
Connor

Loved this place for years but they’ve messed up a few of my recent orders. Just ordered a BYO breakfast sandwich and received just a bagel and cream cheese. View menu


Programmaring
Programmaring

Was looking for a great bagle place. Hard to impress me growing up Jewish around Chicago. Bagelry's great. Recommend you order ahead online and pick up. It can get super busy.


Jennie
Jennie

I love the bagels at this restaurant! The everything bagel is seasoned on both sides, which makes it even better. I ordered a bacon, egg, and cream cheese bagel via Grubhub, and it arrived warm and delicious.


Emily
Emily

Truly my favorite bagel shop in town. Their bagels and crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. Plus they make their own vegan herb cream cheese that is amazing (get it on the rosemary bagel). Their staff is always friendly and helpful. It’s my favorite way to start my morning. View menu


Halo
Halo

I am amazed by this restaurant. As a picky eater, I decided to try something new before summer ends and I am so glad I did. I followed the personalized directions provided with adorable writing. The bagels were warm and soft inside, and the way they were sliced was perfect for enjoying little bites in between swimming laps.


Niyasia
Niyasia

This place was incredibly disappointing. I ordered a bagel with egg, cheese, ham and strawberry jam on it. The ham was deli meat which was either expired or just poor quality. The egg was not seasoned, I’m not sure who doesn’t season their eggs or atleast provide salt and pepper packets but it’s terrible. There was hardly ANY strawberry jam on my bagel either. This place is not really good at all and it shows based on location, and how they prepare their food. I would not eat here unless you’ve just moved downtown within the last year or so and have some sort of job that is high demanding and results in you not being able to make your own breakfast! My 5 year old sister could’ve made this 10...


T
T

Update 2023: 5 stars 3 stars. The bagels are still top notch, but I really have a huge problem with them making a very skimpy lox bagel. 4 oz of smoked salmon on a bagel has been the standard for forever. Their lox bagel now only has 2 oz… not even enough to be satisfying. I love a nice lox bagel but that's just a massive letdown. $10 for a lox bagel with only 2 oz of salmon is a ripoff. $16 for a lox bagel with 4 oz of salmon is far more expensive than anywhere else in this entire city (this is not Chicago SF NYC). Please bring the lox bagel prices back to reality. I'm so excited for OTR to get a bagel shop!The Bagelry soft opened today at their first brick mortar location which is at 14th... View menu

Cincinnati

Cincinnati

Cincinnati, known for its chili served over spaghetti, offers a distinctive culinary scene blending German heritage with American flavors, highlighted by breweries and Goetta.

Categories

  • Bagels Freshly baked bagels, crisp on the outside and chewy inside, served plain or with a variety of delightful spreads and toppings to suit every taste and preference. Choose your favorite to start your day right!
  • Coffee Indulge in our rich and aromatic coffee selection, expertly brewed to awaken your senses. From classic espresso to creamy lattes, discover the perfect blend to start your day on a flavorful note. View menu
  • Cheese A curated selection of artisanal cheeses from around the world, featuring diverse flavors and textures that delight the palate. Perfect for sharing or savored individually with the ideal accompaniments.
  • Catering Catering services offering a diverse range of delicious and beautifully presented dishes, perfect for any event or gathering. Our menu combines creativity with quality ingredients to delight your guests.

Amenities

  • Takeout
  • Delivery
  • menu
  • Street Parking
  • menu
  • Accepts Credit Cards

Similar Restaurants

Metropole

Metropole

609 Walnut Street, Cincinnati, 45202, United States Of America, 45202-1191

Menu • Full • Hotels • American • Breakfast


"Fountain Square in Cincinnati is an absolute gem. This iconic public space is the heart and soul of downtown Cincinnati, and it never fails to impress. The beautiful fountain, surrounded by vibrant greenery and stunning architecture, creates a picturesque setting that is perfect for relaxation or people-watching. The square is always buzzing with activity, offering a wide range of events and entertainment throughout the year. From live music concerts to food festivals to ice skating in the winter, there is always something fun happening at Fountain Square. It truly brings the community together and fosters a sense of belonging. One of the things I love most about Fountain Square is its central location. It is conveniently situated near numerous restaurants, shops, and attractions, making it the perfect spot to grab a bite to eat or do some shopping before or after enjoying the square. The surrounding area is filled with energy and vitality, adding to the overall experience. The atmosphere at Fountain Square is simply electric. Whether it's a sunny day with families enjoying a picnic on the grass or a lively evening with friends gathered around the fountain, there is a palpable sense of joy and camaraderie. It's a place where people from all walks of life can come together and create lasting memories. In addition to its vibrant ambiance, Fountain Square also boasts excellent amenities. The seating areas are comfortable and plentiful, providing ample space for relaxation and socializing. The free Wi-Fi is a nice touch, allowing visitors to stay connected while enjoying the outdoors. The accessibility of the square is also noteworthy, with ramps and elevators making it easy for everyone to enjoy. Fountain Square in Cincinnati is a must-visit destination. It is a true urban oasis that offers a delightful mix of beauty, entertainment, and community spirit. Whether you're a local or a visitor, spending time at Fountain Square is an experience that will leave you with a lasting impression."