Uncle Matty's Eatery

Fantastic neighborhood restaurant. Delicious food, excellent service, and affordable prices. I absolutely love it!

Food is always high quality and consistently great. Beer selection is phenomenal as was the very knowledgeable bartender.

Uncle Matty's never disappoints! I moved to Montana years ago, but whenever I visit Carroll County, one of my must-see stops is Uncle Matty's. Everything on the menu is spot on. Don't miss it! View menu

Uncle Matty's Eatery is truly a gem! The staff is exceptional—very courteous and eager to assist with beer selections. There are food choices to satisfy every palate. I ordered the cheeseburger, which was delicious, with well-seasoned beef and plenty of toppings to choose from. The cream of crab soup made for a perfect starter on a chilly night. I highly recommend this place!

I was in the area for a meeting and this was the closest place to eat. The service was absolutely amazing, the food was delicious, and I am full for $21.00, and that included my 25% Tip. My only suggestion is to make the exterior look more like arestaurant open and in business. I almost didnt stop because the establishment looked closed. Otherwise I will be back if I'm inthe area again!

Absolutely! The chicken wings are incredibly juicy inside and perfectly crispy outside. As a wing enthusiast, I can confidently say these are among the largest I've ever had. The cold cut platter was equally impressive, showcasing generous portions of assorted meats, and the accompanying bread was particularly delicious. Don't miss the homemade potato chips—they're a must-try. I will definitely be back! View menu

I love a good steak sub and this one was perfect in every way. They have their sub rolls shipped in twice weekly and the meat is thick shaved ribeye that was seasoned perfectly. The feta fries were delicious and the home made garlic salad dressing on mysalad couldn't have been better. I can't believe I've driven by this place countless times and had no idea! I also wanted tonote that the waitress Bridget was right out of a Lifetime movie set in a restaurant in small town America pleasant, friendly,and welcoming.

I went to Uncle Matty's Eatery with a group, and I really enjoyed it. The atmosphere is relaxed, with plenty of seating options including booths and tables. The menu offers an impressive selection, featuring everything from sandwiches and subs to pasta, ribeyes, and chicken or fish. They even have a kids' menu, complete with sippy cups for drinks, which I thought was great. Both the service and the food were fantastic, just like the variety on the menu. It's about an hour away from my home, but I would definitely like to come back if I’m in the area again.

A very pleasing find in New Windsor we drive out into the scenic countryside just to enjoy lunch at this homey family friendly restaurant (they do serve wine beer and have a bar area). Can 't go wrong never an inferior dish. The salads are fresh, sammies and entrees tasty. Love the wings, crab dip, gator bites, quesadilla, and incredible boom boom shrimp in spicy sauce wow! My guests liked their loaded hot dogs. Prices are reasonable with very friendly service. We 'll have to try more entrees spinach ravioli was a good one. Bathroom is accessible. Free street parking right in front. Update: Chef 's fish Reuben sandwich on the menu was heaven! Take Nicodemus Road driving west from 97 for gorg... View menu