Explore restaurant menus in PORT JEFFERSON

Z Pizza

➤ 217 Main StNY 11777, PORT JEFFERSON, United States

Pizza • Fondue • Italian • Seafood

---

"I ordered a chicken parm hero and a chicken gyro, and it was the worst experience I've ever had! The chicken in the gyro was dry and lacking flavor. The pita was stale and tough. The fries had a strange taste, likely due to old oil. The chicken parm hero was priced at $10.99, but it was only half a sandwich! It was bland, and there was hardly any chicken in it. Overall, the experience was terrible, and I would never order from here again!"

The Pie

➤ 216 Main St, Port Jefferson, United States Of America, 11777, PORT JEFFERSON

Pizza • Pasta • Salad • Italian

---

"We took the ferry from Connecticut and decided to skip our usual seafood lunch in favor of pizza. I believe the best way to evaluate a pizzeria is to order the classic cheese, though I also enjoy a half-and-half with pepperoni. The pizza was outstanding! The crust was large, thin yet foldable, with a delicious sauce and fresh mozzarella. The interior of the restaurant was really nice, the server was pleasant, and the service was quick. The only downside was that the pizza got cold pretty quickly, but it was still delicious! I will definitely return and spread the word; this place is a must-visit for anyone looking for pizza while on a trip to Port Jeff! I also noticed that the rest of the menu and specials sounded tempting—maybe I’ll try them next time!"

Pasta Pasta

➤ 234 East Main Street Port Jefferson, NY 11777, 11777-1865, PORT JEFFERSON, United States

Wine • Pizza • Italian • Seafood

---

"The food here is amazing. I actually didn’t get the pasta when I went so I can’t say it’s the best pasta on Long Island. I had the lobster pizza and it was absolutely amazing. They also bring out a huge loaf of garlic bread right out of the oven it’s so fluffy and moist and delicious! Some of the best bread I’ve ever had. All their ingredients are quality and everything tastes really fresh. The place is a bit small and the first time I went it was a Saturday and they kinda rudely said you had to have a reservation on Saturdays but the food by far makes up for it."

Fifth Season

➤ 34 East Broadway, 11777, PORT JEFFERSON, United States

Beer • Wine • American • Bar-lounge

---

"After many years in Port Jefferson village, The Fifth Season is still by far the best in food and hospitality in the area. Every member of the staff does their best to take care of you from the moment you walk in the door to the moment you leave. Each dish is executed and presented with care. The staff always treats me like family and I consider every bartender, cook, and server at the restaurant to be my family as well. Cheers to Deborah, Johnny, Yaw, Noah, and everyone else on the staff for curating a truly great restaurant experience for all of us."

Old Fields

➤ 318 Wynn Ln, PORT JEFFERSON, United States

Pizza • Steak • Salads • American

---

"I recently moved to Port Jeff about four months ago and I order from OF about four times a week, but it’s definitely not just to support the owners. The food is simply that amazing—every single time! You really can’t beat it. On top of that, their exceptional customer service is the cherry on top. The attention to detail from the hostess to the chef is something I will remember for a long time. So far, I’ve only ordered delivery, but the fact that they recognized my name when it popped up on their screen made me feel special. This place is busy and popular, so for them to show appreciation for my support is why I’m now a lifelong customer. I can’t wait to visit in person because the location looks beautiful too!"

Salsa Salsa A Burrito

➤ 142 Main St, 11777, PORT JEFFERSON, United States

Pizza • Cheese • American • North American

---

"My partner ordered me Salsa Salsa for lunch through doordash in the picture it shows three tacos he ordered me pork tacos and shrimp tacos it's literally one of each taco disgracefully packed in a tin with mostly tomatoes obscenely over priced for disgusting quality if I wanted tomatoes I would have went to the store and gotten tomatoes.... Definitely do NOT recommended and don't see the hype... Plenty of other authentic taquerias local To make matters even worse I tried the pork out of the taco is was basically as dry as a piece of leather."

Slurp Ramen

➤ 109 West Broadway, 11777, PORT JEFFERSON, United States

Soup • Ramen • Noodles • Japanese

---

"Yes, the vegan options are somewhat limited But only if you stick to the menu as written. You can choose from two vegan broths regular OR spicy. There are many vegetables you can substitute or add in, so if there are things you don’t like and want to eliminate, or things you DO like and want to add, you can. That said, their straight-up vegan option is delicious and plentiful, so you feel well taken care of regardless of being surrounded by a plethora of meaty dishes."

Ruvo Restaurant Bar

➤ 105 Wynn Lane Port Jefferson, NY 11777, 11777-1691, PORT JEFFERSON, United States

Fish • Pizza • Italian • Seafood

---

"The Saltwater Grill has been a Galveston staple for some time. I was encouraged that the menu has been updated with new items, while preserving some of their best offerings - I swear the Shanghai Delight is laced with Prozac because I'm always happy when I eat it. This time I tried one of their new "naked" offerings, hoping the fish would be allowed to shine. I had the grilled redfish, which was done perfectly - the very thin edges were a little crisp and carmelized but the fish was still moist and flavorful. I did miss the bread - this was one of the few restaurants in town that started with something with substance, so I was quite disappointed when a little crock of crackers appeared instead of bread. The restaurant is very noisy - I was ok hearing my companions but certainly couldn't hear the server well."

Local's Cafe

➤ 106 E Main St, Port Jefferson, New York, USA, 11777, 11777-1856, PORT JEFFERSON, United States

Pizza • Cafés • Indian • Coffee

---

"I always enjoy the food at this restaurant! I won't mention my favorite dishes because they might raise the prices. The tofu bhurji was tasty, but messy when wrapped. I would prefer it as a tofu scramble so I could eat it with a fork. The prosciutto is always cut too thick, so I would recommend avoiding it. Overall, the food and beverages here are delicious."

Local's Cafe

➤ 106 E Main St, Port Jefferson, United States Of America, PORT JEFFERSON

Cafe • Coffee • Cheese • Breakfast

---

"You can learn a great deal about someone, especially a restaurateur, by the ketchups, condiments, and oils they choose. Owner Jitendra scored exceptionally high on my scale for high-quality, health-conscious food in numerous ways. For starters, his salmon pita is so exceptional that my husband insisted we stop in on our way to the hotel. Despite the kitchen nearing closing time and it being a relatively quiet night, Jitendra graciously agreed to prepare the salmon pita for us. It was beyond delightful—truly unforgettable. The dish was served with a homemade wasabi-aioli that dripped over the lettuce and tomato on the sturdy, delicious pita. Absolutely fantastic. I eyed the ketchup bottles for our side of French fries, which we ordered in addition to the included coleslaw—a generously portioned, delicious slaw without mayo. Remarkably, the ketchup was Trader Joe's organic, with NO HIGH FRUCTOSE CORN SYRUP. Amazing. This choice alone speaks volumes about the quality of food at this place. I forgot to ask Jitendra what kind of oil he uses in the fryer—hoping it’s not canola. I’ll update once I find out. However, I suspect he uses a better oil, given the rest of the offerings. Our cashier, Caroline, was lovely and helpful. This will definitely be our go-to spot in Port Jefferson."

Toast Coffeehouse

➤ 650 NY-112, Port Jefferson, New York, USA, 11776, PORT JEFFERSON, United States

Vegan • Coffee • American • Vegetarian Friendly

---

"I love toast in Port Jeff. Since its 4 times and every time is a pleasure.Friendly greets and the staff is amazingly efficient I drink tea and love the great beautiful cups in which they serve it. I wish I could buy a My favorite dish is the BLT Omelette. with extra avocado! Excellent delicious! I like the way the bacon tomatoes are bite-size pieces, easy to eat, and the roasted potatoes should die. .Sooo delicious My friend, I always eat it.. What a treat I also want to try the grilled reuben.Looking at our next great experience there. Yes, Rick the owner is always asking for greeting as everyone makes visiting the food."

Sweet N' Savory

➤ 104 Main St, PORT JEFFERSON, United States

French • American • Breakfast • North American

---

"Hey guys I'm gonna fix this rating it's more of a question for all of you I have my nieces coming to visit I haven't seem in 3 years they love crepes omg there really nuts about them I saw this place and fresco creperiein Williston park im torn I don't care if it's closer if one has a Groupon I want them to have the best possible crepes and I saw sweet and savory I need your advise best taste best food best fun time for them when they love it so please help me decide and is there a time you are closed or stop serving or have certain ones not available . Plus been promising them this fir awhile thanks hopeful aunt Christina"

The Secret Garden Tea Cafe Gift Shoppe

➤ 225 Main St, Port Jefferson, United States Of America, PORT JEFFERSON

Tea • Pizza • Salad • Sandwiches

---

"I have been visiting this place for many years, and every time I walk through the door, it feels like being transported to a fairytale cottage. The staff is consistently friendly, and both the owner and her father create an atmosphere that feels like a home away from home. They are incredibly kind and attentive to all guests, even during busy times. The tea room is beautifully decorated for every holiday in an elegant manner, and there’s always soft, lovely music playing in the background. They also offer seasonal teas, adding an extra layer of charm to the experience. I've never seen anyone in this tea room without a smile on their face. It's truly a delightful atmosphere that everyone should experience at least once in their life."

PJ Lobster House

➤ 1 N Country RdNY 11777, PORT JEFFERSON, United States

Fish • Tapas • Tacos • Seafood

---

"So good! We came for lunch and had the prickly pear margaritas, which we added jalapeño to, and they were amazing. Not too sweet and very fresh tasting. Mom had the watermelon slammer and it was very natural fresh squeezed juice. The cocktails were a 10/10 for sure. We then had 6 oysters on the half shell, which were a good value all things considered. Pretty big and delicious. Then we had a cold lobster roll and hot lobster roll, with waffle and regular fries. The bread for the lobster rolls are amazing, and soooo much delicious lobster. The fries were crispy and flavorful. I’m not huge on cole slaw and even that was great. We loved everything we ordered here and will definitely be back! Bonus: we had my chocolate lab with us and we were able to sit on the patio with him."

Gourmet Burger Bistro

➤ Gourmet Burger Bistro, 5 Mill Creek Rd, Port Jefferson, NY 11777, USA, PORT JEFFERSON, United States

Food • Wine • Pizza • Salad

---

"I was not let down by this place! It is situated in a fantastic location, tucked away in a delightful area of town. The restaurant may be small, but it is welcoming and cozy, with a comfortable and..."

Tiger Lily Cafe

➤ 158 E Main St,NY 11777-1856, United States, PORT JEFFERSON

Cafe • Salad • Juice • Salads

---

"Tiger Lily Cafe in Port Jefferson, New York, is a charming little gem that offers a delightful dining experience. Known for its cozy atmosphere and welcoming environment, this cafe is perfect for a casual meal, coffee break, or brunch with friends. The menu is diverse, featuring a variety of breakfast and lunch options that cater to different tastes. From hearty breakfast burritos and fluffy pancakes to fresh salads and sandwiches, there's something for everyone. The ingredients are fresh, and the dishes are prepared with care, making each bite enjoyable. One of the highlights of Tiger Lily Cafe is its coffee selection, which is expertly brewed and pairs perfectly with their homemade pastries and desserts. The cozy vibe, complete with lovely decor and friendly staff, creates a relaxing space to unwind. The service is attentive and personable, ensuring that guests feel valued and well taken care of. Whether you're a local or just visiting, Tiger Lily Cafe is a lovely spot to enjoy a meal or catch up with friends over a cup of coffee. Overall, Tiger Lily Cafe is a delightful addition to Port Jefferson's dining scene, offering tasty food, great coffee, and a warm atmosphere that makes it worth a visit."

Tara Inn

➤ 1519 Main St, Port Jefferson I-11777-2238, United States, PORT JEFFERSON

Pub • Pizza • Salad • Burgers

---

"Had the pleasure of choosing Tara Inn for lunch today, every establishment can learn a lesson from the customer service that my friend and I experienced. Upon walking in we were greeted by Peter, Tara’s husband and son-in-law of the founder who named the bar for his daughter 47 years ago. We told him it was our first visit and he offered us seats and welcomed us. The regulars at the bar guided us through the menu and we each had a burger with lettuce, tomato, onion and pickles for $1 per burger expecting very small burgers we were surprised to find them standard sized and deliciously prepared to medium. My friend had the fried shrimp and I had a $13 steamed lobster! Excellent! They offer daily specials and one of the gentleman at the bar told me their steaks are very good. Every staff person went out of their way to make us feel at home. A charismatic women came out from the back and introduced herself as Tara she thanked us for choosing to lunch there. Why can’t other places realize the importance of making a first time patron feel welcome. I Had a great afternoon enjoying the excellent variety of beers that they provide on tap. The charming decor has probably changed little since the ‘70s and that adds to the vibe. If you want to go to the friendliest bar on Long Island, head over to Tara Inn."

Wave Seafood Kitchen at Danford's Hotel and Marina

➤ 25 East Broadway Port Jefferson, NY 11777, 11777-1838, PORT JEFFERSON, United States

Pizza • Hotels • Seafood • American

---

"Not my kind of place. The bar / tavern had screaming, loud customers on a day when there was no one around. Really a tasting menu, teen plate, teen servings, bad value for money. The waitress told me that the green peppers in my clam chowder were mild - they weren't and had to spit out with a burning mouth. Really embarrassing when I was treated. Instead, they gave me asparagus. Your only vegetable. They didn't notice that my water glass was empty and I had to request it. Backless benches to sit in the tavern / bar, but you can request an uncomfortable chair. Not a place where you, like me, eat a lot of healthy protein and vegetables. I don't like leaving a restaurant where I feel bloated with too much food, but I don't want to go hungry either. The coffee was good after the meal."

Steamroom The

➤ 4 E Broadway, 11777, PORT JEFFERSON, United States

Fish • Salad • Seafood • Burgers

---

"Great food. This place was found while waiting for the ferry. Ideal location with a beautiful atmosphere by the sea. The staff was very polite. The food was great. So many good looking elements on the menu. This visit I had the New England Clam Chowder, it was great and hit the place. I had no good cup of shells in a long time, and that hit the place. I also had the fish and chips. It was excellent. The bread was very good, I thought it had a season on it that tasted great. This will be my place every time I come here. A new favorite place."

Cest Cheese

➤ 216B Main St, Port Jefferson I-11777, United States, PORT JEFFERSON

Salad • Lunch • American • Sandwiches

---

"This place is a gem! I dine here nearly every day; the ambiance is fantastic, the food is delicious, and the staff is incredibly friendly. I can't praise this place enough. And for anyone on the hunt for gluten-free options, they offer the best gluten-free bread I've found anywhere! (Trust me, I've tried them all.)"