Phone: (+1)6313314646
Address: 216 Main St, Port Jefferson, United States Of America, 11777, PORT JEFFERSON
City: PORT JEFFERSON
Menu Dishes: 35
Reviews: 1264
Website: http://www.thepieofportjeff.com/
"We took the ferry from Connecticut and decided to skip our usual seafood lunch in favor of pizza. I believe the best way to evaluate a pizzeria is to order the classic cheese, though I also enjoy a half-and-half with pepperoni. The pizza was outstanding! The crust was large, thin yet foldable, with a delicious sauce and fresh mozzarella. The interior of the restaurant was really nice, the server was pleasant, and the service was quick. The only downside was that the pizza got cold pretty quickly, but it was still delicious! I will definitely return and spread the word; this place is a must-visit for anyone looking for pizza while on a trip to Port Jeff! I also noticed that the rest of the menu and specials sounded tempting—maybe I’ll try them next time!"
Full menu - 35 options
All prices are estimates on menu.
Salads
Tomato
Fresh tomatoes sliced and layered with mozzarella, finished with basil and a drizzle of balsamic glaze.
House Salad
Classic garden salad with mixed greens, cherry tomatoes, cucumbers, and carrots with your choice of dressing.
Caesar Salad
Crisp romaine lettuce tossed with creamy Caesar dressing, garlic croutons, and grated Parmesan cheese.
Gorgonzola Salad
Mixed greens topped with creamy Gorgonzola cheese, crunchy walnuts, and sweet pears, drizzled with balsamic vinaigrette.
Pasta
Ravioli
Pasta pockets filled with ricotta and spinach, served in a rich tomato sauce.
Penne Alla Vodka
Penne pasta in a creamy tomato vodka sauce with hints of garlic and parmesan.
Pizza
1 Topping
A fresh and savory pizza topped with your choice of topping, baked to perfection with a golden crust and melted cheese.
Meat Calzone
A folded pizza filled with savory meats, melted cheese, and tangy marinara sauce, baked to golden perfection.
Entrées
Baked Clams menu
Tender clams topped with garlic and breadcrumbs, baked to golden perfection.
Buffalo Wings
Spicy, tangy chicken wings, served with celery sticks and blue cheese or ranch dressing for dipping.
Fried Ravioli
Crispy golden ravioli filled with cheese, served with a side of marinara sauce.
Chicken
Buffalo Chicken
Spicy buffalo sauce draped over crispy chicken, served with a side of creamy ranch for a savory, tangy punch.
Grilled Chicken
Juicy grilled chicken seasoned to perfection, served hot and tender.
Spaghetti
Shrimp
Succulent shrimp grilled to perfection, served with a zesty garlic butter sauce and a side of fresh lemon wedges.
Burger – Aberdeen Angus Beef
Baked
Lasagna
Layers of pasta, rich meat sauce, creamy béchamel, and melted cheese baked to perfection.
Main Dishes
Eggplant
Grilled eggplant with a smoky flavor, seasoned with herbs and drizzled with olive oil.
Crunchy Salads
Al Forno*
Baked Ziti
Baked ziti with ricotta, mozzarella, and tomato sauce, oven-baked to perfection for a cheesy and savory Italian delight.
Pizza Pies
Sides
Garlic Knots
Soft, warm dough knots infused with garlic and herbs, served with marinara dipping sauce.
Suppe
Specialty Pies
Specialty Pie
Seafood Dishes
Fried Calamari
Crispy fried calamari served with a side of marinara sauce for dipping.
Dinner Enticements
Entree
Hot Heros (Lunch)
Sausage Peppers
Sautéed sausages with sweet bell peppers and onions in a savory sauce.
Rigatoni
Chicken Dishes
Chicken Broccoli
Tender chicken breast and crisp broccoli florets in a savory garlic sauce served over steamed rice.
Pasta-Nudelgerichte
Large Calzone
Antipasti - Starters
User
Great food great service best pizza on Long Island 5 stars
Address
Reviews
User
The restaurant is clean, the food is fresh and delicious and the staff is always friendly! I would totally recommend it!
User
The food here never fails. No matter what we order it is absolutely delicious. I must say though their pizza is on a whole other level.
User
The staff of the beautiful lady Is it clean please, Beautiful pizza, I recommend my friends Nassau country, Queen, Great choice food, wine old school!! View menu
User
Great Pie, living in TX now I only come home a couple of times a year and this was my first time here. I'll definitely be making it one of my routine stops.
User
Nice friendly service and atmosphere. The food is delicious , especially the portabella mushroom appetizer !! I highly recommend the Pie to others and you can't beat the Port Jeff location !!
User
The food here is excellent, the staff is very friendly, and the prices are truly great value. It's a fantastic spot for families, singles, and basically anyone. Jessica, in particular, was very welcoming and checked on me multiple times, which really shows their commitment to outstanding customer service. You definitely deserve your success! View menu
User
The food is fantastic. I 'm a huge fan of the Buffalo Pizza but it 's all good. The service can be a little on the slow side but the servers themselves have always been friendly. One negative might be the cost. $27 bucks for that large Buffalo Pie but I 'm not taking away a star because you know that going in and like I said... it 's fantastic. We love walking down to the water after a meal.
User
The staff at this restaurant is always friendly and attentive. My son and I visit Pie twice a year because we are pizza fanatics, and their pizza is simply amazing. I have to admit that on our last visit, my son tried the pepper chocolate pizza, while I was hoping for an Italian dish. One of my favorites is chicken marsala, and even though it wasn't on the menu, the waitress kindly asked the cook if he could prepare it for me, and he did. It turned out to be the best chicken marsala I've ever had (aside from my own, of course). If you're in Port Jefferson, be sure to stop by for a bite—you won't be disappointed!
User
We took the ferry from Connecticut and decided to skip our usual seafood lunch in favor of pizza. I believe the best way to evaluate a pizzeria is to order the classic cheese, though I also enjoy a half-and-half with pepperoni. The pizza was outstanding! The crust was large, thin yet foldable, with a delicious sauce and fresh mozzarella. The interior of the restaurant was really nice, the server was pleasant, and the service was quick. The only downside was that the pizza got cold pretty quickly, but it was still delicious! I will definitely return and spread the word; this place is a must-visit for anyone looking for pizza while on a trip to Port Jeff! I also noticed that the rest of the me... View menu
Categories
-
Pizza Delve into our perfectly baked pizzas, crafted with hand-tossed dough, rich tomato sauce, and a blend of gourmet cheeses. Each slice bursts with fresh toppings, ensuring a delightful bite every time.
-
Pasta Delight in our selection of classic and contemporary pasta dishes, each crafted with fresh, quality ingredients and flavorful sauces that capture the essence of Italian cuisine in every bite. View menu
-
Salad A delightful assortment of vibrant salads, featuring fresh greens, seasonal vegetables, and savory toppings, drizzled with our signature dressings for a refreshing and wholesome meal experience.
-
Italian Savor the rich and diverse flavors of Italy with our menu, offering classic pasta, savory risottos, and traditional meat and seafood dishes, all crafted with authentic ingredients and passion. Buon appetito!
Amenities
-
Takeout
