Baking Betty's - Menu

Superb! Cookies big enough to put you in a sugar coma. My favorite was the lemon meringue and the s’mores.

Our favorite place to get cookies!! They are all delicious!! Amazing customer service! We picked up our order and had this note in our bag!!

The cookies were absolutely delicious! To top it off, the packaging had a delightful surprise—Proverbs 3:5-6, which happens to be my favorite verse. View menu

The crème brûlée cookie is one of the best desserts I've ever tasted. This place is truly fantastic, and the staff are much friendlier than at your average restaurant. I loved it so much that I ended up buying four cookies to take home the next day!

We love the buckeye, lemon, and iced oatmeal flavors- so tasty!We ordered pizzas for our child's birthday party at TUC. It was a convenient 2 min walk, pizzas were ready on time, and they tasted so good!! It was a great experience and we look forward to frequenting this shop in the future.

Yeah, this place is really exceptional. We got the peanut butter and oatmeal raisin cookies and they were phenomenal. LOVELY lady staffing the place there too, and the hours might not be right, they were open later than posted. I think they pretty much close when the mall closes?(They have a religious thing on their packaging, FYI. View menu

If there’s a dessert spot you MUST try at the MofA, this place is IT. The S’mores cookie absolutely delivers on the hype. I also had the Buckeye cookie which does not skimp out on the peanut buttery goodness. I took home four cookies for me and my partner and it took us three nights to eat them because they were so delectable. Hopefully this independently owned company expands to more locations, I just had a some “boutique chain” cookies in my area and they reminded me how much better this place was.

While the cookies at this restaurant certainly have an appealing appearance, they sadly fall short in terms of taste. We anticipated the best cookies ever for $5 each, but our expectations were not met. The lemon meringue had an unpleasant odor reminiscent of feet and was undercooked, making it inedible. The Nutella cookie was overly salty and greasy, while the s’mores just tasted like a tough graham cracker. The oatmeal cookie was dry, and the peanut butter variety was also greasy. I cannot recommend these cookies. However, I do want to commend the employee who assisted us; they were very friendly!

I was pretty disappointed in the treat I purchased.I bought one of their s'mores bars, which consists of honey grams, marshmallows, and chocolate. Think a s'mores flavored Rice krispie bar. Anyway, the value of what they give you for the money is great. I believe I paid $5 and some odd cents for a giant bar. But It was very stale, the ratio of marshmallows in the bar made it really goopy, and I feel like the oil that was used to grease the pan was canola because there was a gross oily aftertaste.I ended up throwing most of the bar away. I wish I would have taken a bite before leaving their stand because I probably would have asked for a refund. It was gross to say the least.Their employees w... View menu