Dortoni Bakery - Menu

I ordered the Apple crumble pie and it was undercooked. As a first-time customer, I am very disappointed and most likely will not return.

Bought a napoleon cake. Overall, this bakery is very good. I would like more custard and no whip cream to make this more authentic. But everyone enjoyed it and the quality is very good on prior visits.

The cupcakes were delicious! Unfortunately, I ordered plain Italian bread but received the seeded ones instead. I cannot eat seeded bread due to a medical condition. Additionally, the bread was cold, as if it had been refrigerated. View menu

Although their baked goods are undeniably delicious, the prices are incredibly high for what you receive. I purchased two tres Leche tarts that were smaller than a mini muffin, and I was charged $12 for them. That's around 30% more than similar bakeries. Additionally, a small cake that serves 4-6 people costs between $30 and $40. That's a lot of money for a little flour!

I live on the opposite side of the country and wanted to order some Italian pastries for a friend's birthday. I stumbled upon this bakery in Long Island, which was highly recommended. I called in advance to request specific items to be included in the assorted cookie delivery I was ordering, and the staff was very accommodating and helpful over the phone. The order was beautifully wrapped when it arrived.

Dortoni is truly the best place for custom cakes! They accommodate your budget and create stunning designs. I recently ordered a cake for my baby shower, and it turned out beautifully while tasting incredible! The chocolate flavor was rich and decadent, and the vanilla and fruit options were also delicious and moist. I highly recommend them. Last year, I had a Gucci-themed cake made, and it was a tremendous success! Kawal, the manager, is fantastic to work with—so humble and kind. I can't wait to order from them again! View menu

I ordered a pie via DoorDash. I ordered a large pie because I have a group of people coming. A girl from the store named Gabby calls me and tells me that they dont have a large pie and only a small pie. I explained that I have a whole bunch of people coming and she goes Ill call you back and hung up on me. I receive a small pie and they refunded me the difference without a call back. The small pie is the equivalent of something I can eat myself. I called the store and spoke to this girl Gabby again and she said to me well Im sorry sir theres nothing I can do and if you have a problem you can take it up with DoorDash. A store Ive been shopping in for 15 years going back to levittown is going...

What truly sets Dortoni's apart is their expertise in crafting wedding cakes that align perfectly with your vision. Kawal played a crucial role in bringing my dream wedding cake to life. Her meticulous attention to detail and expertise were evident right from the start. She took the time to meet with both my spouse and me, attentively listening to our ideas and preferences. Kawal's insights were invaluable, helping us refine our vision to ensure every aspect of the cake was just as we envisioned. The customer service at Dortoni's is exceptional. Throughout the entire process—from the initial consultations to the delivery of the cake on our wedding day—the Dortoni's team went above and beyon...

Manger is a bit of a hustler in the back when it comes to speciality cakes- watch the price they offer if you come here. We were ready to go, and we feel that the manager tried to change the price last minute to make more money, so we walked out. Here’s the story:Walked in today to purchase a fondant cake for a party. Showed a picture of the cake (clearly fondant). We had called ahead and was told to come in when the manager was there.Walked in today, and a very nice woman helped us out. Told us it was about 290 for a 1 tier, 12 inch speciality fondant cake- which of course makes sense. We also wanted to purchase fondant cupcakes, so this was all adding up to around 400 plus, which was fine.... View menu