New York Pizza Fleming Island

Mellow Mushroom

➤ 1800 Town Center Blvd Orange Park, FL 32003-6312, United States

Menu • Bars • Pizza • Cheese • Seafood

---

"Came on a Monday evening and the place was packed. Got a seat at the bar immediately and our tender was quick to welcome us and tell us about the beer and drinks. My wife ordered a Captain and Coke with Cherry and I got the Sweetwater Dank Tank Series 710bHazy Double IPA which was amazing. We ordered the mushroom soup, absolutely fantastic. We also ordered a plain pizza and a white pizza called The Great White. We were not fans of the sweetness of the red sauce on the plain, but the Great White was sublime. Wonderful service, good prices and a great atmosphere. Great date night or night out with the boys destination."

Just A Pinch Cafe Catering

➤ 1615 County Rd 220 #180, Fleming Island, USA, 32003-4905, United States

Menu • Cafe • Pizza • Hawaiian • American

---

"First off, I have to mention that our server, Hannah, was outstanding - very sweet and attentive. The bottomless mimosas were a waste of money - just orange juice with a splash of champagne and took a long time to arrive despite the lack of customers in the restaurant. The huevos rancheros and waffles had no flavor at all, and the steak and eggs, which were supposed to be a 5oz filet, were tough and overcooked. It was so hard we needed extra effort and a good knife to cut it. It was completely tasteless. We asked for a larger table for our party of 4, but were told no, even though the restaurant was only a third full and there were empty tables all around us. The hostess was rude and the service was slow. This was our second visit and we won't be returning. Our bill was $130, which was overpriced for the quality of the food. The only thing that impressed us was Hannah's service. After reading the owner's response to other negative reviews, it's clear that they don't take criticism well. It's a shame because the food was lacking in taste and quality - especially the huevos rancheros. It was worse than "shake and bake" prepared by a blind person. The restaurant may have a long way to go, but attacking customers for giving honest feedback won't help them improve."

Your Pie

➤ 1545 County Rd 220, Ste 125, Fleming Island, Florida, USA, 32003, United States

Menu • Pizza • Italian • American • Fast Food

---

"We've dined at this location multiple times, and the service is excellent! Occasionally, it can be a bit slow, but we appreciate not being rushed through the line like we are at other restaurants, so the slower pace feels refreshing to us. You can create your own pizza or select from their menu, and they offer a gluten-free crust as well as a wide variety of vegetable toppings. The gelato is delicious, and they have local craft beers on tap, too. There's something for everyone here, so everyone can enjoy a pizza they love!"

The Loop Pizza Grill

➤ 1960 E West Pkwy #110, 32003, Fleming Island, US, United States

Menu • Pizza • Casual • American • Fast Food

---

"Visited the place today. I love their burgers and steak fries BUT I always struggle with the amount of blue cheese crumbles I get when I ask for it. I?m paying for the cheese anyway. I tipped like I normally do because their credit card machine asks youto . But today I requested extra crumbles hoping I?ll get double the amount for the $1.20 price I paid? this picture is what Igot. Before I walked away I asked if they actually gave me the extra and the older man said ?Yes, I made sure the cook gave youextra?. I said ?Ok, but it appears to be as much as I normally get and could I please have more?. He was obviously frustratedwith me and walked to the kitchen and said something to the cook who looked up at me and he walked back with an ounce ofcrumbles. I thanked him and ate my meal but was upset. When I finished I approached the registers with nobody around and askedthis older gentleman if I was in fact charged for the extra cheese, he said ?yes?. I told him that since I paid for it, Iexpected to have enough on my burger to satisfy me and that I was sorry it upset him for requesting more. Then I added that Ihad left a tip as I typically do and I clean off my table. Then I said that if I return in the future I will bring my own bluecheese crumbles and I refuse to ever tip again since I do all my own work. I literally paid $13 Just for this burger and tip (nodrink). He did say that the tip is for the employees to clear off the table and that he was not upset (despite his gestures andcomments made to the cook). It upsets me when people who work for an establishment don?t seek customer satisfaction anymore. Itused to be the goal. Just smile and give your customers what they are asking and do this with appreciation because THEY arepaying your salary. I won?t give up on the place over this experience but I?ll be the one saving $1.20 plus tip putting my owncheese on my burger and clearing off my own table."

Chick-fil-a

➤ 1541 County Road 220, 32003, Fleming Island, United States

Menu • Chicken • American • Sandwiches • North American

---

"The honey pepper pimento chicken sandwich is a culinary dream come true. It is, without a doubt, the best sandwich I've ever had, and I sincerely hope they never stop making it—otherwise, life would lose its joy. Additionally, I've never visited a Chick-fil-A anywhere without receiving friendly, speedy service every single time. They truly excel at customer service. Thank you so much! Service: Takeout"