New York Pizzeria Cato

Pleasant place, a decent vibe, great staff, and most of all....good pizza

The best pizza and charboiled wings in upstate New York located in Cato New York on the corner of 370 and 34

Great pizza. Made in a timely matter. Great to have good pizza near home in country. People there were very nice. View menu

This restaurant is one of the best in town! You must try their loaded fries and bacon wraps. Keep up the great work!

The pizza is great the wings are great and the subs are great and their staff is awesome. Never had anything bad from here. I live about 20 minutes from here and will make the trip because it's so good and their prices are amazing.

Their pizza is absolutely incredible. It hasn't changed in 20 years. I was greeted with a smile and treated as a customer. I was told thank you as I left and again with a smile. This made my day. I haven't been to this place in years and I will go back soon just because. Word to the wise, try the chicken wing pizza! Of course you got to get some blue cheese. Again, very impressed and please keep up the good work folks! View menu

I ordered a large chicken bacon ranch pizza and was disappointed with the lack of toppings. The teenage staff argued with me about pizza-making, despite my experience working in pizzerias for years. There was barely any chicken or bacon on the pizza, and it was not evenly distributed. I suggest better adult supervision at this restaurant. I will not be returning. Instead, I recommend trying Sals in Baldwinsville or Dimitris Pizzeria in Elbridge. You can get a better pizza in less time at those locations.

I live 20 miles away and if I get a craving for pizza and wings there is nothing better in New York State in my opinion! I never Miss A chance to stop on my way to and from Fairhaven ! the prices are excellent, the slices are huge ,the wings are amazing!! I finally got a salad and the house Italian is out of this world! They also sell the really good dense soft big chewy cookies at the corner as well ! very hard-working, focused crew, very friendly. If I lived cloer, I'd gain weight! one of my favorite places to go!!

I am a Cato native. Yet I haven't been to cato in a long while. Especially not to eat.. I really don't live that far away. I just live in the Jordan elbridge area. I had some work out that way a few weeks back and stopped in. Not much has changed. I picked up a slice and a soda and was amazed by the quality and the price. I've been back multiple times trying different items. It all takes me back to when I lived there. I'll be back more as well. Because of the quality, quantity and the affordability! Other pizza places should practice the same business model. View menu