Old Post Office Bagel Shop

23 Ocean Ave, New Shoreham I-02807-7728, United States

🛍 Vegan, Coffee, Seafood, American

4.3 💬 310 Reviews
Old Post Office Bagel Shop

Phone: +14014665959

Address: 23 Ocean Ave, New Shoreham I-02807-7728, United States

City: New Shoreham

Menu Dishes: 8

Reviews: 310

"Their bagels are fresh and soft, and they also have a selection of pre-made yogurt parfaits, cut fruit, and egg sandwiches (which I didn't try but looked fantastic and are not microwaved!). I also love that their prices are very reasonable; they don’t overcharge just because they’re in a tourist area. Now, let's talk about the service—it's incredible. Even amidst the hustle and bustle, they take the time to recognize their regulars. For instance, the man in front of me this morning had forgotten his wallet the day before, so he paid double for his order today since they had let him go without paying! He was clearly a regular, but I still thought that was really impressive. Additionally, the woman who served me yesterday morning (maybe she’s the owner? I didn’t catch her name but she looked a bit older than some of the others at the counter and seemed to have an Irish accent) noticed me while I was paying this morning. She stopped to say hello and mentioned how nice it was to see me again, commenting on the lovely weather. That kind of personal touch means a lot to me. She must see hundreds of people each day, so remembering someone and taking the time to acknowledge them is a testament to outstanding service. If you're on Block Island, make this your go-to breakfast spot; you won’t regret it!"

Full menu - 8 options

All prices are estimates on menu.

Sandwiches

Dessert

Indian

Bread

Dameche Dameche

Excellent! Help are very kind and they great options!

Address

Show Map

Reviews

LCD
LCD

Super busy. Line out the door but moves quickly. Good sized portions.


Albert
Albert

I enjoyed the BLT breakfast sandwich served on an everything bagel with avocado, and it was absolutely delicious!


Brian
Brian

Have had their bagels for years , and it must be the water. They are dense, almost to dense. But good. Its just weird. View menu


Christopher
Christopher

The bagel was excellent. The seating was decent, the portion size was satisfying, and it really hit the spot. Definitely worth a visit if you're on Block Island.


Jason
Jason

When I went there, there were 6 types of bagels. They have different types of cream cheese available and they have drinks available from a cooler fridge. I would recommend this 100% for anyone who wants a nice breakfast or brunch!


Bryan
Bryan

I was recommended this spot by a friend, and the bagel sandwiches were outstanding. It's nice to sit outside and enjoy the view of the world passing by. It might be a bit on the expensive side, but that’s just how it is on the island. View menu


Brian
Brian

If you're in search of the best bagels outside of NYC, this is the spot to visit. Every time I've gone to Block Island, I've made a point to stop here before catching the ferry to grab some bagels to take home. They are absolutely delicious!


Lexi
Lexi

I had a great experience with my bagel and cream cheese, muffin, and iced chai. The prices are reasonable, particularly considering that everything tends to be pricier on the island. I loved dining outdoors on the patio. Although we've had a few mix-ups with our orders—like receiving a sandwich with cheese instead of without and getting iced coffee instead of iced chai—the staff was always friendly and quick to resolve the issues. It's a laid-back and budget-friendly place, but be sure to arrive before noon on weekends, as the bagels tend to sell out quickly!


Ali
Ali

Their bagels are fresh and soft, and they also have a selection of pre-made yogurt parfaits, cut fruit, and egg sandwiches (which I didn't try but looked fantastic and are not microwaved!). I also love that their prices are very reasonable; they don’t overcharge just because they’re in a tourist area. Now, let's talk about the service—it's incredible. Even amidst the hustle and bustle, they take the time to recognize their regulars. For instance, the man in front of me this morning had forgotten his wallet the day before, so he paid double for his order today since they had let him go without paying! He was clearly a regular, but I still thought that was really impressive. Additionally, th... View menu

Categories

  • Vegan "Delight in our vegan menu, offering a vibrant selection of plant-based dishes crafted with fresh, seasonal ingredients. Savor flavorsome meals that are as nourishing as they are delicious."
  • Coffee Savor our selection of expertly crafted coffees, from rich espressos to creamy cappuccinos. Whether you need a morning boost or a leisurely sip, our coffee options promise warmth and comfort in every cup. View menu
  • Seafood Dive into the freshest catches of the sea with our seafood selection, featuring exquisite dishes prepared with high-quality fish and shellfish. Savor the flavors of the ocean in every bite!
  • American Enjoy classic American flavors with our diverse menu, featuring juicy burgers, crispy fried chicken, hearty BBQ ribs, and fresh salads. Indulge in timeless comfort with each bite, crafted to satisfy all tastes.

Amenities

  • Street Parking
  • Outdoor Seating
  • menu
  • Accepts Credit Cards
  • menu

Similar Restaurants

Eli's

Eli's

Block Island, 456 Chapel St, 02807-9800, BLOCK ISLAND, United States

Menu • Seafood • Burgers • American • Vegetarian Friendly


"One of my favorite eating experiences on the island and otherwise! We were so happy with our meal that we bought the cook a drink. She should be celebrated!!! In the context of the island I didn't know how much the other places we died were short. Eli's staff treated us like old friends; no single smile felt compelled. They take care of the little things: The bathroom feels like entering a massage salon for dogs (everybody who has been there understands why), the sound-absorbing boards on the ceiling, even the hosts give potential guests very true answers to waiting times and suggestions, where they are taking a drink nearby in the meantime. All this the parsley on the right plate: the menu! This cook knows what she's doing. My partner is a cook, and here is what she had to say about it: she definitely studied somewhere, how the flavors mean that she really cares about the experience and KNOWS what she does! You have carefully the menu around ingredients that are seasonal and can be used in a variety of ways. I would be about 20 or less items over the entire menu, everyone prepared to the theme of the dish whether it is animal protein or cauliflower. I am vegetarian and I decided to dinate here because the separate Veg menu was actually interesting! Not only one beyond burger or salad; who designed this menu may eat vegetables! I ordered the Roasted Cauliflower and couldn't believe what I tasted. The dish was all kinds of vegetables on a bed of rice Fuccine, sitting in a sauce that I think is based on garlic, but not in an overwhelming way. My partner commented “that’s the best I have seen you eat this whole trip” that I answered “I don’t want to stop eating this!” I have never been in a restaurant that has been targeted for meat eaters and thought that a vegetarian dish was on the same level as the “Entrees” section of a menu. My partner ordered Steak and we both had the same experience – what a fairy! I think everyone should dinate here, but I push the groups that are a mixed bag of Veg, gluten-free, and carnivores to try Eli’s because they have delicious accommodation for everyone!"