Peter's New York Pizzeria

144 Standart Ave, Auburn, NY, 13021, City of Auburn, United States

🛍 Pizza, Cheese, Pizzeria, Sandwiches

4.8 💬 321 Reviews

Phone: +13152589488

Address: 144 Standart Ave, Auburn, NY, 13021, City of Auburn, United States

City: City of Auburn

Menu Dishes: 35

Reviews: 321

"The staff were fantastic, the portion sizes were generous, and the food was delicious. I brought my family from abroad here for lunch while we were at the plaza, and even though we were a group of six (including three kids) in a small pizza shop, we were treated wonderfully. The service was quick and friendly, and we had plenty of leftovers to take home. We will definitely visit again—five stars!"

Full menu - 35 options

All prices are estimates on menu.

Cold Subs

Pizza

Salads

Appetizer

Entrées

From The Fryer

Subs/Wraps

Chicken Wings

Calzone

Main Courses

Fish Dishes

Specialties

Chicken Dishes

User User

Great calzone and pizza. Service is always good with pleasant people. Ordering times are accurate and fast.

Address

Show Map

Reviews

User
User

Toto makes incredible pizza, and the slices are huge. If you're in Auburn, it's definitely worth a visit at lunchtime!


User
User

This place is great! It's a small pizza shop with a friendly atmosphere and an impressive variety of delicious, fresh pizzas at reasonable prices. The slices are huge! You really have to try the pizza to fully appreciate it.


User
User

I have yet to find a place that makes a better cheese pizza. It's been a very long time since I've been shocked at how good a plain cheese pizza is, this places knocks it out of the park with its pizza, wings and variety of other foods! View menu


User
User

The staff were fantastic, the portion sizes were generous, and the food was delicious. I brought my family from abroad here for lunch while we were at the plaza, and even though we were a group of six (including three kids) in a small pizza shop, we were treated wonderfully. The service was quick and friendly, and we had plenty of leftovers to take home. We will definitely visit again—five stars!

Categories

  • Pizza Delve into our perfectly baked pizzas, crafted with hand-tossed dough, rich tomato sauce, and a blend of gourmet cheeses. Each slice bursts with fresh toppings, ensuring a delightful bite every time.
  • Cheese A curated selection of artisanal cheeses from around the world, featuring diverse flavors and textures that delight the palate. Perfect for sharing or savored individually with the ideal accompaniments. View menu
  • Pizzeria Enjoy freshly baked pizzas with crispy crusts, savory sauces, and a variety of delicious toppings. Our pizzeria offers a wide range of traditional and gourmet options to satisfy all your cravings.
  • Sandwiches A delightful assortment of freshly made sandwiches, crafted with premium ingredients and served on artisan bread. Perfect for a quick lunch or a satisfying meal, each bite is packed with flavor and goodness.

Amenities

  • Wifi
  • Delivery
  • menu
  • Parking Area
  • menu
  • Reservations

Similar Restaurants

Lasca's

Lasca's

252 Grant Avenue, City Of Auburn, 13021, United States Of America, City of Auburn

Menu • Pizza • Casual • Italian • American


"Worth the trip! We were seated right away. Even though we did not have a reservation. I highly recommended having one! Server Cassie, she was very sweet and efficient. Bread/rolls warm and fresh were brought right as we sat. With a red dipping sauce that had a slight kick. So good I could not keep myself from eating them!! Drinks served We had wine and Champaign. Only problem was they did not have the full bottle of the small one I tried and you have to save your cork, to try and recork left overs if you wish to take unfinished bottle. I would suggest to bring your own cork. They only pace it in a paper bag as well. This was a disappointment. Other places have corks and plastic bag they seal. My Husband started with a appetizer. I enjoyed the bread and warm spicy dipping sauce! He ordered Shrimp Cocktail. Nice cocktail sauce with chucks of horseradish! Nice cold fresh shrimp. Good size portions. Tender and not so cold it hurts your teeth to bite into. They were delicious! We ordered prime rib special for Friday Night. Queen cut. Could of feed a family of four on one piece! Thick and cooked to perfection! Melt in your mouth!. We order Medium Rare. It came with a nice creamy horseradish dip. Delish! Best baked potato I have had in a very long time. No foil wrap! To die for. Crisp on the out side and fluffy on the in side! With the best sour cream and chive. I was tossed between side salad and lobsterbisk soup. She was kind enough to offer us a sample. I did not care for it. My husband loved it. If you like the full flavor of lobster, this would be the soup you would order! My husband had already ordered the French onion. It did look good. He said it had tender onions ,but he has wished he had order the other. Said it was OK on taste. He eats Onion soup most always so he would know! I went with the side salad. I choose the house dressing. It had a nice flavor, on the sweet side. I only would of liked it better with more greens. I always have to pick half the salad out. Hard white pieces are bitter. Basic head of lettuce, and the normal toppings. Nothing special, but it was just the side salad. I recommend trying one of the others they offer if you are looking for a real salad. My husband ordered his prime rib with the lobster tail. It was well represented. Looked huge. Grilled it appeared. I did have a taste but I was not up for fish. The tail was a little on the tough side I thought but my husband devoured half. It looked like two tails or they split one huge tail in half. It came with a tea light candled serving dish. I was impressed. We ordered NY style cheese cake with strawberrys. The cheese cake was very tasty. I think I could of done without the strawberry. Not in season and a bit bitter and tough. But I did enjoy the sauce on the plate. Just dipped ansd ate. So full we only ate a few bites. I hope I have the name of the waiterss correct. She did a great job socializing with us old folks. She must of over heard us talking about cheese and hot pepper flakes. We did not ask for it. Everything was so good I did not need it. Next thing I knew she brought it over! She did that with one other thing I am just old and can not remmber at this moment. Lol. I was impressed on how quickly everyine was moving to serve people. They filled up quick!! Lots of your people. I had to stop and thick where we were. My husband laughed. We are in Auburn Not Geneva . I also wanted to mention that they seem to do a large take out serves. Lots of cars where lined up and they have a separate entrance for the to go orders. Again I was impressed!! I give five stars based on location, easy to find!. Service/Servers. Decore/Atmosphere. Presentation of food. Quality of food. Quantanty of food!"

Prison City Pub Brewery

Prison City Pub Brewery

28 State St, Auburn, New York, USA, 13021, United States

Menu • Pub • Cuban • Burgers • American


"They need to change their name to Prison City Restaurant instead of Prison City Brewing. We were in town visiting family and wanted a place to get a few drinks and talk. Every other brewery on the lakes, you walk in, order drinks and grab a table. This place apparently doesn't want to accommodate you if you only want drinks and not food. We told the hostess we just wanted drinks and she said we could sit at the bar or wait for a table. Since we didn't want to sit 5 across the bar where we wouldn't be able to talk to each other, we decided to wait for a table. Once sat, our server immediately came over and pushed us every way he could to either sit at the bar or per his recommendation go downstairs to their cocktail lounge, as he didn't want to lose a table to people that were not ordering food. We understood where he was coming from so decided to go downstairs to the lounge. A few of us waited down there while the others ordered beer flights at the bar. Once we carried it down there, we were told we couldn't sit down there because we didn't order down there. Well if our server or hostess would have told us that, we would have ordered down there. Plus downstairs is a VERY limited menu with only a few beers and no flights. It's more for cocktails, not beer, even though they claim to be a brewery. So back upstairs we went. I asked if we could sit at the hightop tables right in front of the bar, but lo and behold, those are also reserved for food ordering customers. So our only option was to be banished to the front corner of the restaurant where people sit and wait for tables when it's busy. How can you be a brewery but have absolutely no place in your entire establishment to sit and drink beer?!? At least have a few tables in the bar area for that!! Will definitely stick to the real breweries on the lakes going forward."