Agave - Menu

Pesce Italian

➤ 1 American Yacht Harbour Smith Bay RdVI 00802, St. John, United States

Menu • Fish • Pasta • Diners • Coffee

---

"The restaurant is located in a cute area. You walk into and there is a nice bar off to the right and then the dining area. The ambiance is very nice. As for the food we order the tuna carpaccio for the appetizer and it just melted in your mouth. My fiancé ordered the snapper piccata which was just delicious. I had the chicken parmigiana which I figured you can’t go wrong with it. And it was perfectly made. Everything was fresh and flavorful. Server was attentive and staff was friendly. Highly recommend."

Sunset Grille

➤ 6280 Estate Nazareth, St. Thomas, United States Of America

Menu • Full • Wine • Desserts • Steakhouse

---

"We absolutely enjoyed our entire experience at Sunset Grille. The view from our table was beautiful, the service was great and the food was outstanding. My husband said his cabrales oporto filet and mashed potatoes were some of the best he’s ever had. I had the lobster and shrimp tostada appetizer which was delicious and a Caesar salad which was awesome. Our waiter was excellent, very attentive without hovering and the desserts were awesome. The key lime crème brûlée was delicious and I had a bite of hubby’s tempura cheesecake which was also outstanding."

3 Palms

➤ 6100 Red Hook Qtrs, St. Thomas, United States Of America

Menu • Full • Wine • Steak • French

---

"We had our best restaurant experience last year, so we were excited to return this year, which we did on our first night back on the island. We were pleased to find it just as wonderful the second time around. There were six of us, and everyone thoroughly enjoyed their appetizers and main courses. The service was professional, and the ambiance by the water was fantastic. I highly recommend it!"

Raw

➤ 2 American Yacht HarbourVI 00802, St. Thomas, United States

Menu • Full • Wine • Sushi • Seafood

---

"One of our favorite dining experiences on the island. We visited the night before we left and wish we would've tried it earlier- would've gone several times! We started with the fish bites and the edamame. After those, we knew we were in for some good food. We followed that up with some red snapper and hamachi nigiri (phenomenal). For our main, we had a surf n' turf roll and a RAWkin' roll. Everything was cooked perfectly, flavors paired well and was plated beautifully. The atmosphere was perfect for our date night and we would highly recommend to any sushi lovers traveling to Red Hook."

Mirador by Chef Benny

➤ 6600 Estate Smith BayVI 00802, St. John, United States

Menu • Wine • Fish • Meat • Pasta

---

"Pretty underwhelming experience here. The location and views are awesome. The ambiance and decor is classy and nice as well. Server was nice and friendly as well. But unfortunately we were here for a nice dinner. The ceviche with plantain chips was decent, although not a whole lot going on and was pretty small have had cevichetuna tartarepoke type dishes with my wife all over the place and this would rank in the bottom half. The green papaya salad was pretty good, probably my favorite from our lineup, decent flavors, etc. Then came our entrees. My wife's fettuccine made fresh daily was basically flavorless now it wasn't rosemary pasta or something like that, but fresh pasta has more flavor, and it was a bit soft as well, just didn't have the consistency we were expecting. It wasn't bad, and I'm sure they did make it fresh, but it just wasn't great. The pomodoro sauce was nonexistent, and the meatball was solid, but I don't think the fact that it was Wagyu made much difference over other solid meatballs. I got the catch of the day which was Wahoo, and it was okay, fish was cooked raremedium rare and it was solid, but nothing to write home about. And it came with Asian fried rice and vegetables. The rice was pretty salty, too salty, and I don't mind salt and I love fried rice. So that was a bit of a letdown. The fish didn't have any great distinct flavor, so because I didn't love the rice as well... was just a sort of meh entree. So overall, location and view from up on the hill to the water was incredible, very nice decor, good people, just thought the food was not great for the price. If it was the price at a waterfront bar that are a dime a dozen on STT, all good. So partially this pretty critical review is because the price point of this place sets a very high bar, and it didn't reach it. Not really even close. We went to Pesce in Red Hook the next night and that meal blew this one out of the water good, fresh pasta, at the price too"