Arthur's Island Kitchen

First time visiting. Great atmosphere; really, really enjoyed the food. My entire meal was great, the callaloo soup was delicious! The stew fish my husband got, awesome!!!Parking: No problems

Fantastic people and food. The host was super friendly, and Arthur came out and answered all our questions regarding the different fresh fish…absolutely outstanding meal! A must visit when in key largo.

Arthur's is fantastic! The service is exceptional; I even had the opportunity to meet Arthur himself, and he's remarkable. The food was superb—definitely try the Shrimp Scampi. I hope you enjoy it as much as I did! View menu

Excellent food and great people! Arthur came out and talked to us and gave us some tips on our upcoming Bahamas trip. Bartender was a fellow live aboard. Very friendly and knowledgeable. Awesome experience. Couldn’t recommend it enough

It seems like these guys have no idea what they’re doing. Food took too long. The fries are ready 20 minutes before the entrée so by the time the meal arrives, the fries are already cold. The half chicken jerked tasted like microwaved fish. It all went in the bin and had to go out again for dinner somewhere else.

A refreshing new taste for the Upper Keys! Unfortunately, they had run out of oxtail when we got there, which is a good sign of its popularity but also a bit disappointing. The restaurant features a full bar and hosts reggae nights on Fridays. My only complaint is that the portion sizes were smaller than what I’ve experienced at other Jamaican restaurants. Overall, I’d rate the food 4 out of 5. View menu

The bar tender Nicole is very friendly and accommodating not to mention always dressed so cute. Server Craig is so polite. And Authur himself is such a kind and caring person of his own. Did you know during covid lock down Arthur was preparing food and handing out for free to those in need? Arthur is the heart and compassion of Key Largo! Stop in and experience a taste of the Caribbean for yourself and be sure to say Elizabeth says hello

We came here on the recommendations of our crew at the dove shop and wow it did not disappoint. We checked reviews and I’m surprised to see anything negative. We had Oxtail Stew, Curry goat, and blackened prime rib and shrimp and everything was AMAZING! Also had the conch ceviche plus local beer and cocktails and again, it was all delicious! Our waiter was a veteran as are we and their business supports veterans. The owner came out to see if we were satisfied and of course we were. Parking is in the back so don’t let the lack of cars out front fool you! They have live reggae at 9pm so if you are into a more “bar” atmosphere just wait a bit later to go.

On a positive note, my son mentioned that the onion rings were quite good, and my daughter enjoyed her jumbo butterflied shrimp. Our kids are 11 years old. Interestingly, when we were seated, the server asked where we were from before handing us menus. To our surprise, the prices on the menu didn't match those listed on the restaurant's website. It left us wondering if they cater primarily to locals and overcharge tourists. The atmosphere reminded me of a dingy pool hall—not exactly inviting. As we walked in, it felt a bit like stepping into a less-than-reputable establishment. Unfortunately, I don’t think I’ll be returning. Overall, the food was overpriced and felt like it came from the fr... View menu