Big Mario's Pizza - Menu

The vibe here is perfect. Great pizza, great beer list. Feels like the neighborhood spot and perfect place to unwind.

Pizza, vhs tapes, red lights, kind of dive-y, this place has it all. Really enjoyed the vibe and service was friendly. Slices were good too!

The slices are enormous and incredibly flavorful. They are truly authentic New York-style slices, although they are pricier than those in New York, with a pepperoni slice costing $5.25. View menu

It's a decent slice of New York pizza, nothing special except I haven't been able to find anything like that since moving here. If you're a native who wants to see what NY pizza is like, or a transplant missing the taste of home then I highly recommend it. Too expensive, but everything is out here.

The thin pizza gets old after a bit but the staff is great. Occasionally getting a full specialty pizza is worth it, but mainly used for the drunk and stoned late night slices and shots while I'm over playing pinball. Huge movie collection and always something on worth watching. Little cramped if you don't like that.

Avoid ordering a full pizza at this place. The customer service is lacking. Full pizzas are prepared last, so if twenty customers arrive after you wanting slices, they'll prioritize those orders and won't even start on your pizza until after all the slices are made, baked, and sold. We waited nearly an hour for ours. The servers were rude, making the whole experience frustrating. What a disappointment. View menu

I met some friends for pizza and beer around 9:30. The slices were quite large, and I really enjoyed the sauce—it had a great amount of cheese on top. The crust was thin and flexible, making it easy to hold the slice. Haha! As for the toppings, they were pretty much what you’d expect. I guess it shows that I’m a bit particular when it comes to good pizza sauce and plenty of cheese! The wait staff was excellent, too!

The wife and I like to make it in here often, grab a couple slices and sit at the bar, order a cider and a beer to wash it down. The entire staff is pretty on point, the play old VHS movies and cool music. The pizza is thin crust and large slices and quality ingredients (hard to go wrong there). It is usually pretty busy, but we've been able to get a spot with now waiting. Lots of people taking pies to go. We love Big Mario's!

The restaurant has a generous and friendly atmosphere, serving delicious NY-style thin crust pizza. They even offered a pepperoni slice to our dog when we arrived just 30 minutes before closing! I particularly enjoyed the jalapeño tomato pizza—it's my favorite! The entire space has a cozy, welcoming vibe, and I loved the decorations, especially the nostalgic VHS tape collections and the unique bathroom mirrors. I will definitely return to try more items, including their tacos! View menu