Hooked - Menu

We ordered Mahi and greens and a Mahi sandwich, also lobster bisque. The fish was cooked to perfection and delicious! The salad and fries equally fresh and delicious. My husband loved the bisque as well. Very friendly owner!

We ordered half a dozen oysters, the tuna poke bowl and fish and chips. The food came fast, fresh, and delicious. Prices were reasonable and they had plenty of benches around the shop. Staff at the front were also incredibly warm!

Me and my girlfriend stopped by from our stay in the Hamptons and it was one of the greatest decisions we've ever made. Prices are fair and the food is spectacular! The food is definitely worth trying and totally worth it, would definitely come back inthe future! View menu

My girlfriend and I visited a restaurant during our stay in the Hamptons, and it turned out to be one of the best decisions we made. The prices are reasonable, and the food is absolutely incredible! It’s definitely worth trying, and we would gladly go back in the future!

10/10 calamari! CALAMARI was so good! Cracked pepper in the breading and the red sweet pepper sauce was the best part. Best I?ve had ever. The fish and chips was a large portion but just average taste. Clam chowder was very good quality and the shrimps were huge! Overall it was a great experience! Would?ve liked a little bit more flavor out of the food

Hooked?s lobster roll is stuffed with lobster, has minimal mayo, and is just plain delicious. Definitely my favorite lobster roll in the Montauk area. Great fast casual joint with efficient service and plenty of outdoor seating. They also have avariety of alcoholic beverages available to enjoy with your meal. I?m looking forward to trying more of the menu during my nextvisit. View menu

10/10 for the calamari! It was absolutely delicious! The cracked pepper in the breading and the red pepper sauce were standout elements—truly the best calamari I've ever had. The fish and chips were a generous portion, but the flavor was just average. The clam chowder was of excellent quality, and the shrimp were enormous! Overall, it was a fantastic experience, although I would have liked a bit more flavor in the other dishes.

The portions are generous, and the customer service at the counter is truly excellent. However, the food itself was just average. Based on other reviews, we were expecting to be wowed, but unfortunately, it didn't live up to our expectations. Overall, I recommend giving it a try, as each menu item is unique (we only had the shrimp boat with fries). There were plenty of seats available in the outdoor area, and they are pet-friendly since you're sitting outside. And I must emphasize again, the counter staff was fantastic, which is definitely worth mentioning!

I hadn't had a lobster roll in five years, so I had high expectations when I saw the sign outside. After taking my time to read reviews of Hooked and other nearby places, I decided this would be the best choice. As I stood there, I had high hopes. The ambiance inside was beautiful, and at first glance, I thought the price of $32 for a lobster roll was reasonable. However, I found myself somewhat underwhelmed. The amount of lobster was decent, but something about the bun didn’t sit well with me. Given the price and the reputation, I anticipated something more impressive. A better quality bun would have significantly enhanced the overall experience. View menu