Jimmy's Diner - Menu

3301 Shelby St, Indianapolis I-46227-3257, United States

🛍 Steak, Diners, Cheese, Burgers

4.8 💬 1814 Reviews
Jimmy's Diner

Phone: +13177843752

Address: 3301 Shelby St, Indianapolis I-46227-3257, United States

City: Indianapolis

Menu Dishes: 9

Reviews: 1814

"A wonderful little gem in the neighborhood! It has a warm, family-like atmosphere, quick and friendly service, and most importantly, the food is absolutely delicious. We visited two mornings to sample a variety of dishes, and everything was fantastic. The coffee was outstanding too, and they keep refilling it until you ask them to stop. If you're visiting and splurging on museums and zoos, this place is also budget-friendly! I truly have no complaints. It was amazing. I’ll always remember those eggs!"

Full menu - 9 options

All prices are estimates on menu.

Sandwiches

Egg Dishes

Fries

Salads

Steaks

Entrées

Barbara Barbara

Jimmy is the best cook and everyone there is small town friendly. His daughter forgive me I can't remember her name but she is the most vibrant, intelligent, classy young lady!

Address

Show Map

Reviews

Cynthia
Cynthia

Charming atmosphere! The wait staff is very friendly! Jimmy is not only engaging but also an excellent chef and cook. The food is tasty, wholesome, and homemade. I can't wait to go back soon!


Anna
Anna

Amazing service, food was hot and as we requested. coffee was hot and feel of comfort if you are looking for a taste of home cooking and pleasant atmosphere this is a must visit Jimmy's Diner is a place to go.


Tom
Tom

Great stop for lunch just minutes off I-65. Burger was excellent as was my wife’s BLT (Jimmy added extra bacon! . Fries okra was very good too. Unpretesious, family-owned diner with great food and friendly staff! View menu


Tahni
Tahni

You guys need to check this place out if you want good food for a decent price. This place! Check out the cheese steak. No it doesn't come in a bun. It comes in a tasty toast and it's good! They are clean and friendly too.


Andrew
Andrew

This place is fantastic. Jimmy and his wife (forgive me I forget her name! run the entire show and are welcoming and make this place feel like home. 50s/60s style home cooking/diner vibe. Everything on the menu is delicious, you really can’t go wrong. Will be returning regularly.


Diana
Diana

The Best place in town!!! They have excellent service and even better food! You have to try the hash brown casserole. Home made and to know that Jimmy is the cook and takes so much pride in his work. He really does care about us and the community!!! One place I recommend you trying for yourself for sure!!! View menu


Steven
Steven

I was in town visiting and searching for a good local breakfast, and it turned out to be not just good, but GREAT! Anyone who rated it less than 5 stars wasn't being truthful. The food was excellent, and the service was outstanding. Just please don't come back when I'm in town—I really don't want to wait for a table!


John
John

I dropped by for lunch and was thoroughly pleased with my experience. The staff was welcoming and attentive, making for a pleasant atmosphere. The menu offered a wide variety of delicious options to choose from. I ordered the tenderloin, which was cooked to perfection and the breadcrumb coating was delightfully crisp. I highly recommend this restaurant for a great meal at very reasonable prices.


Laura
Laura

A wonderful little gem in the neighborhood! It has a warm, family-like atmosphere, quick and friendly service, and most importantly, the food is absolutely delicious. We visited two mornings to sample a variety of dishes, and everything was fantastic. The coffee was outstanding too, and they keep refilling it until you ask them to stop. If you're visiting and splurging on museums and zoos, this place is also budget-friendly! I truly have no complaints. It was amazing. I’ll always remember those eggs! View menu

Indianapolis

Indianapolis

Indianapolis, known for the Indy 500, offers Midwestern comfort food, with staples like pork tenderloin sandwiches and sugar cream pie, reflecting its rich cultural and culinary heritage.

Categories

  • Steak Savor prime cuts of juicy, tender steaks, expertly grilled to perfection. Each bite offers a burst of flavor, served with classic sides and delectable sauces to enhance your dining experience.
  • Diners Classic diners serve an array of hearty comfort foods, from all-day breakfasts and juicy burgers to home-style meatloaf, creamy milkshakes, and classic American pies in a cozy, nostalgic atmosphere. View menu
  • Cheese A curated selection of artisanal cheeses from around the world, featuring diverse flavors and textures that delight the palate. Perfect for sharing or savored individually with the ideal accompaniments.
  • Burgers Juicy, flavorful burgers crafted with premium ingredients, from classic beef to unique vegetarian options, all served with fresh toppings and a choice of hand-cut fries or a crisp salad.

Amenities

  • Cafe
  • Delivery
  • menu

Similar Restaurants

Ali'i Poke

Ali'i Poke

910 W 10th St Ste 4, Indianapolis, IN 46202, United States

Menu • Poke • Pizza • Sushi • Fusion


"Inside, you’ll find seating at tables and the bar, along with a pleasant patio area that overlooks the sidewalk. They also have a self-serve water station in the front. Unfortunately, the cleanliness of the place left much to be desired. I chose to sit at the bar, and it appeared to have not been wiped down all day. The floor was quite dirty as well. The staff did what was necessary, but seemed to lack enthusiasm. You can customize your own bowl or select one of their signature options. Feeling adventurous, I decided to create my own bowl. Regardless of your choice, you start with a base. I opted for traditional sushi rice over brown rice and spring mix salad. Next, I had to select a protein. The size of your bowl determines how many scoops you receive. The regular size allows for two scoops, so I chose one scoop of spicy tuna and one of marinated salmon, although options like octopus, tofu, and shrimp are also available. After that, you can add various toppings and sauces. I have to admit, my bowl was quite tasty and packed with protein. The atmosphere was relaxed, with music playing softly in the background. Unlike the other location I've visited, this one doesn't offer shaved ice, just poke. Overall, I found this place to be just average compared to other locations I've tried, which is why I’m giving it a 3-star rating. The poke was decent, but everything else felt pretty standard at best."