Michael Anthony's Pizzeria

2425 Middle Country Road, Town Of Brookhaven, 11720, United States Of America, Centereach

🛍 Cafés, Pizza, Mexican, Seafood

4.3 💬 3001 Reviews
Michael Anthony's Pizzeria

Phone: (+1)6312857722

Address: 2425 Middle Country Road, Town Of Brookhaven, 11720, United States Of America, Centereach

City: Centereach

Menu Dishes: 35

Reviews: 3001

Website: https://www.michaelanthonygf.com/

"This local restaurant is a hidden gem with delicious food and welcoming staff. The portion sizes are generous and the cozy decor creates a comfortable atmosphere. One small critique is that they no longer offer fountain sodas, which is unusual for a pizzeria. Evita provides excellent service and makes you feel right at home. I highly recommend trying the Chicken Alla Vodka Parmigiana. Overall, a fantastic dining experience with an average price of $10–20 per person for dinner. Food and service both receive a 5-star rating, while the atmosphere is a 4."

Full menu - 35 options

All prices are estimates on menu.

Pasta

Salads

Entrées

Sandwiches

Chicken Wings

Starters

Al Forno*

Appetizer

Sides

Side Orders

Dinners And Entrees

Filled Paninis

Seafood Dishes

Seafood

Dinners - Pasta Al Forno / Baked Pasta

Paninis

Main Course

Seafood*

Pasta Dishes

Lynda Lynda

Excellent... We can always count on Michael Anthony

Address

Show Map

Reviews

David
David

The Reg Slice and Buffalo Chicken Slice at this restaurant are absolutely delicious.


Lynda
Lynda

The delivered pizza was cold and the box was open, but fortunately this pizzeria serves the best pizza.


Megan
Megan

Delicious food!! The lady there was super sweet!!! Chicken ala vodka was PERFECT. Will be back Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 View menu


Lucy
Lucy

The BEST fried Calamari I've had!! They also make a DEELISH Pizza (vodka sauce, pesto sauce, marinara sauce)!! Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5


Joseph
Joseph

Wonderful!!! Delicious and large portions and very low prices. Service was top notch . We found our new spot. I hope they do really well. Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $10–20 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Baked Ziti, House Salad Parking space Plenty of parking Parking options Free parking lot


Barbara
Barbara

After a shopping trip, we stumbled upon a pizza restaurant and decided to give it a try. It was our first visit and we were pleasantly surprised. The pizza was delicious, the service was excellent, and the staff were very friendly. We will definitely be returning. Overall rating: Food: 5, Service: 5, Atmosphere: 5. Meal type: Lunch. Price per person: $10-20. View menu


Alex
Alex

The food at this restaurant is consistently delicious, fresh, and amazing. I am thrilled to see it available again on doordash. The fried Mozzarella is fantastic - crispy, golden, and perfectly square. The homemade pasta sauces are delicious and the Small Gorgonzola Salad is fresh and yummy with plenty of toppings. I love this salad every time I order it. It's always on point.


Brad
Brad

I am a big fan of Micheal Anthony's. The food is delicious and reasonably priced. They offer frequent specials that are great for family dinners or entertaining guests. I have always enjoyed my meals here and have never had a negative experience. The customer service is excellent, with friendly servers and hosts who go out of their way to make sure your visit is enjoyable. I highly recommend this restaurant. It's worth mentioning that I have only gotten takeout from here so far. Service: Takeout.


George
George

This local restaurant is a hidden gem with delicious food and welcoming staff. The portion sizes are generous and the cozy decor creates a comfortable atmosphere. One small critique is that they no longer offer fountain sodas, which is unusual for a pizzeria. Evita provides excellent service and makes you feel right at home. I highly recommend trying the Chicken Alla Vodka Parmigiana. Overall, a fantastic dining experience with an average price of $10–20 per person for dinner. Food and service both receive a 5-star rating, while the atmosphere is a 4. View menu

Categories

  • Cafés Charming cafés offering a variety of freshly brewed coffees and teas, along with light snacks, pastries, and desserts. Perfect for a morning pick-me-up or an afternoon treat in a cozy atmosphere.
  • Pizza Delve into our perfectly baked pizzas, crafted with hand-tossed dough, rich tomato sauce, and a blend of gourmet cheeses. Each slice bursts with fresh toppings, ensuring a delightful bite every time. View menu
  • Mexican Authentic Mexican flavors await you with sizzling fajitas, savory tacos, zesty enchiladas, and fresh guacamole, all crafted with rich, traditional spices and served with vibrant sides. Enjoy a fiesta on your plate!
  • Seafood Dive into the freshest catches of the sea with our seafood selection, featuring exquisite dishes prepared with high-quality fish and shellfish. Savor the flavors of the ocean in every bite!

Amenities

  • Takeout
  • Delivery
  • menu
  • Television
  • menu
  • Parking Area

Similar Restaurants

Old City Public House

Old City Public House

200 Portion Rd, 11779, Ronkonkoma, United States

Menu • Cafés • Pizza • Seafood • Mexican


"I am far from a restaurant connoisseur nor do I leave reviews on any establishment regularly. But I have to say the food and drinks are top notch and they serve one of the best French dip sandwiches I’ve ever eaten and I’ve had quite a few in my time, at quite a few different restaurants on Long Island. I enjoyed it so much that I decided to look at some of the reviews for this particular establishment And I found quite a few people who had choice words to say about a business they’ve probably never owned or personally run themselves and about a profession they’ve probably never worked in themselves meaning being a restaurant owner and/or a waiter or waitress but they have plenty to say about it. One review says about how it needs to be updated, well I don’t know if you’ve noticed the name of the place but it’s the old city Public House not the new city Public House, it’s rustic and charming. Another reviewer made comments about the “older woman” waitress who works there and how she has “no personality” I will agree that she’s a little rough around the edges but she is a pissa and I don’t know too many waitresses that can handle an entire restaurant by herself and seemingly pay attention to all the tables that she’s serving so she means business and I guess that could be misconstrued as “grumpy”, said in another review. If you’re looking for really good food and a rustic charming atmosphere with a no nonsense waitress who’s going to get your order correct and make sure that you have everything you need throughout your dining experience then this is the place."