Michelangelo Pizzeria

East On Main

➤ 10560 Main Road, Mattituck, NY 11952, United States

Carte • Pizza • American • Fast Food • Bar-lounge

---

"We pass this place all time. Finally decided to come back after having it at a catered event last night. (Which was very good) I was pleasantly surprised that the Italian was good coming from a place that you would expect to be more of a steak house. I hadthe mozzarella square. Loved the pesto they put on it. I decided to get the mushroom raviolis expecting it to be salty and mushybut it was fabulous! Better then some of the local Italian joints. Perfectly el dente… not salty and love the peas they put infor added texture. The sauce was nice and creamy. I would order it again for sure. The chicken fingers were good although theyseem to have a different breading than the catered ones we had at the party last night. The only thing I would change is theFrench fries. It would be awesome if they could make a fry closer to Hellenic or the old Omally’s. They seemed a little likefast food fries at best but at least the main food was terrific. I would recommend this place to anyone. Lookong forward tocoming back tomorrow!"

Cj's American Grill

➤ 10095 Main Rd, 11952, Mattituck, United States

Carte • Seafood • American • Sandwiches • North American

---

"**Service:** Dine-in **Meal Type:** Dinner **Price per Person:** $30–50 **Food Rating:** 5/5 **Service Rating:** 5/5 **Atmosphere Rating:** 5/5 **Recommended Dish:** Seafood Bisque I had a wonderful dining experience at this restaurant. The service was exceptional, making me feel welcomed and attended to throughout the evening. The meal was truly outstanding, with each dish meticulously prepared and bursting with flavor—especially the seafood bisque, which I highly recommend. The atmosphere was inviting and pleasant, making it a perfect setting for dinner. Overall, a fantastic evening with top-notch food and service!"

Magic Fountain Ice Cream

➤ 9825 Main Rd, Mattituck, New York, USA, 11952, United States

Carte • Pizza • Vegan • Coffee • Ice Cream

---

"Cool little ice cream shop. They have really good banana splits and sundaes. They also have their own type of McFlurry, called a “Magic Wonder”. They have wacky flavors like goat cheese and avocado. They also have vegan options, soft serve, and weekly flavors like candy cane, lavender, pumpkin, etc. Cheaper than other places nearby. Vegetarian options: They have some vegan (not vegetarian) options. Very little vegan options, but they still have some. Parking: Empty during weekdays, packed to the brim during summer weekends. Kid-friendliness: Kid friendliness indeed. The employees are nice, not rude, and have quick service."

Love Lane Kitchen

➤ 240 Love Lane, Mattituck, New York, USA, 11952, United States

Carte • Pizza • Kitchen • American • Breakfast

---

"Love Lane Kitchen is a little gem tucked away in a little enclave in Mattituck that is a must-go-to if you're in the area. The lobster roll was chock full of lobster meat, and the Chicken Avacado Mango salad was excellent. Portion sizes are generous and there's a wide variety of cocktails and beers. If it's nice weather opt for sitting outside under the tent."

North Fork Doughnut Company

➤ 100 Love Ln, 11952, Mattituck, US, United States

Carte • Pizza • Donuts • Coffee • Catering

---

"If you're a donut lover like I am, you absolutely need to check out the North Fork Donut Company, known as NOFO DOCO. From the instant I walked in, I realized I was in for a delightful experience! First off, the freshness of their donuts is unparalleled. It's clear that they take immense pride in making these delicious treats from scratch each day. In comparison to other donut shops I've visited, the offerings at NOFO DOCO stand out as truly exceptional. Each bite is a burst of flavor that leaves you craving more. One of the most remarkable aspects of NOFO DOCO is their generous portion sizes. These donuts are massive, and I mean really big! You definitely get your money's worth, and the size alone makes them an indulgent treat. Whether you're treating yourself or wanting to share with friends and family, their donuts are perfect for any occasion. Now, let's discuss their innovative creations. The idea of putting cereal on a donut is pure brilliance. It adds a delightful crunch and an additional layer of flavor that elevates the whole experience. Among their many tempting options, I highly recommend trying the Samoa Donut. It features the classic flavors of caramel, chocolate, and coconut, creating a dreamy combination that will transport your taste buds to paradise. Whether you indulge in the Samoa Donut or explore their other enticing choices, you won't be disappointed. NOFO DOCO is a paradise for donut enthusiasts, and I can't wait to return for another delicious treat. Happy donut indulgence!"