Brothers BBQ - Menu

2400-2402 New York 32, New Windsor, NY 12553, United States

🛍 Bbq, Barbecue, American, North American

4.3 💬 2807 Reviews
Brothers BBQ

Phone: +18455344227

Address: 2400-2402 New York 32, New Windsor, NY 12553, United States

City: New Windsor

Menu Dishes: 20

Reviews: 2807

Website: https://www.smokenallday.com

"I have wanted to go here for a while as a lot of people rave about the BBQ, so as always I will preface my post in saying a am a home pitmaster. Time of dining 7 pm. I prefer a BBQ spot between 4-6pm. Why, because BBQ dries out. We ordered the chickenwings and pulled pork nachos for apps. Nachos we're good the pulled pork was a little dry. The chicken wings l didn't personally try the others in my group liked them. For the main course we ordered the family feast. It says it serves 4-6. Let mejust say I had 3 full take out boxes of food and there were 4 grown men. The pulled pork in the family meal was much better. Mymain item the brisket had a good run on it but was a little dry. The ribs were good. I didn't try the chicken..... Yet. Thecornbread is so worth stopping to have. We ordered three sides the Mac n cheese was awesome one of the best I have had. Thecandied yams were awesome. I didn't have the smoked baked beans yet. Overall it's with the stop and felt we paid a fair pricefor what we had. No issues with service."

Full menu - 20 options

All prices are estimates on menu.

Chicken

Salads

Entrées

Sandwiches

Side Dishes

Chicken Wings

Main Courses

Beef Dishes

Ribs

Chicken Dishes

Vegetarian

Sides

Burger

Pork Dishes*

American Food

Bryan Bryan

To start, I’m accustomed to Tennessee BBQ, particularly from Memphis. So when I say that I found Brothers just okay, it’s mainly because I’m comparing it to what I’m familiar with in Memphis. On a positive note, the staff were very friendly, and I enjoyed the live music.

Address

Show Map

Reviews

Flavio
Flavio

Now, let's talk about the food—it was absolutely delicious! I especially enjoyed the fried chicken, which was incredibly juicy. There was so much food that I even had leftovers for breakfast the next day. I say "breakfast" in quotes because I ended up eating at 1 PM, but hey, I'm on vacation!


Montana
Montana

It was clear this restaurant was a hit, given the numerous cars waiting outside for it to open. Amanda provided outstanding service, and I was equally impressed by the rest of the team. The food was incredible and full of flavor. Be sure to arrive with an appetite—believe me, you'll want to savor every single bite!


Nicole
Nicole

What a delightful surprise during our road trip! The food was absolutely delicious. The service was outstanding. The brisket was among the best I've ever tasted, and the ribs had a perfect smoky and peppery flavor. They even offer custom sausage shipped in from Texas, which was flavorful and had just the right amount of heat. I wish we lived closer! I would love to come back and try the entire menu of Southern favorites. Highly recommend! View menu


Ernie
Ernie

As I perused the menu, the burger instantly grabbed my attention, so I decided to give it a try. I ordered the Brothers Classic, which included fries, as I wanted to keep my spending in check. It was quite delicious, particularly the juicy meat. I finished my meal rather quickly and felt very satisfied. The cornbread we had as an appetizer was also quite tasty. Overall, I would love to return, as there appears to be a lot to explore at this restaurant.


Amy
Amy

Absolutely great bbq! And we?ve eaten a lot of bbq in the Carolinas so this ranked with the best of them. Very happy it?s only 40 minutes from where we live and worth every mile. The cornbread was served warm, was moist and had a slightly sweet top. Allthe meats were juicy and flavorful and the sides of slaw, potato salad, mac n? cheese and beans were all just the way we likethem. Great service, loved the playlist and the metal trays we ate off! Oh?and the SAUCE! It?s perfect!


Isidro
Isidro

Really good complementary cornbread. The brisket is probably the best meat here. It is exceptional! Pulled pork is good. The ribs are the only thing I won't be getting again (too dry). The fried pickles were the best fried pickles I've ever had and their home made ranch dressing is similarly bomb. Great and fast service. A truck ton of food and beers for 3 people was $100. A good value for BBQ of this quality IMO. We'll be back here again after a hike! Looking forward to a plate of brisket. View menu


Judy
Judy

Really solid quality food. Service is okay but a bit slower they were short staffed . Portions are rather small for the price you pay. For example their fried chicken $18 came with 4 small pieces of what I'd call average fried chicken. Their brisket , ribs, and sausage though were quite on point. 3 meat combo $28 was delicious, but again, really small portions so plan accordingly. Photo attached of both meals. Minus a star for portion size and service time took over 30 minutes to get food, never got refills on drinks, etc.. .


Suzanne
Suzanne

The pulled pork in the family feast tasted much better than the appetizer version. I had the brisket as my main dish; it was decent but also a bit on the dry side. The ribs were tasty, although I didn’t sample the chicken. One standout dish was the cornbread – it’s definitely worth trying! We also ordered three sides of macaroni and cheese, which was excellent – possibly the best I’ve ever had. The candied yams were great as well, though I didn’t get the chance to try the smoked beans. Overall, it was a worthwhile visit. I felt we received a fair amount of food for the price. The service was good too, with no issues to report.


Michael
Michael

I have wanted to go here for a while as a lot of people rave about the BBQ, so as always I will preface my post in saying a am a home pitmaster. Time of dining 7 pm. I prefer a BBQ spot between 4-6pm. Why, because BBQ dries out. We ordered the chickenwings and pulled pork nachos for apps. Nachos we're good the pulled pork was a little dry. The chicken wings l didn't personally try the others in my group liked them. For the main course we ordered the family feast. It says it serves 4-6. Let mejust say I had 3 full take out boxes of food and there were 4 grown men. The pulled pork in the family meal was much better. Mymain item the brisket had a good run on it but was a little dry. The ribs we... View menu

Categories

  • Bbq Savor the smoky and savory flavors of our barbecue offerings. From tender ribs to juicy briskets, each dish is grilled to perfection with our signature sauces and spices for an authentic BBQ experience.
  • Barbecue Savor the smoky, juicy flavors of our barbecue delights. From tender ribs to succulent pulled pork, each dish is grilled to perfection with our signature sauces, offering a true taste of barbecue heaven. View menu
  • American Enjoy classic American flavors with our diverse menu, featuring juicy burgers, crispy fried chicken, hearty BBQ ribs, and fresh salads. Indulge in timeless comfort with each bite, crafted to satisfy all tastes.
  • North American Savor the diverse flavors of North America with dishes ranging from juicy burgers and crispy fried chicken to tangy BBQ ribs and fresh salads, all capturing the essence of regional favorites and comfort classics.

Amenities

  • Wifi
  • Takeout
  • menu
  • Delivery
  • menu
  • Television

Similar Restaurants