Cattleman's Burger And Brew

205 S Main St, Algonquin I-60102-2669, United States

🛍 Cafés, Grill, Burgers, Barbecue

4.4 💬 941 Reviews
Cattleman's Burger And Brew

Phone: +12246789444,+12247776000

Address: 205 S Main St, Algonquin I-60102-2669, United States

City: Algonquin

Menu Dishes: 18

Reviews: 941

"I’ve lived in “Old Algonquin” for 4+ years and have always considered this place a neighborhood institution.The appetizers were always delicious. The cheese curds calamari were always my favorite.For dinner, I always would go with the Patty Melt, substitute tater tots. It was always extremely filling, cooked perfectly medium-rare, and the bread toasted and crisp.We always enjoyed dining outside on a gorgeous day in “Old” Downtown Algonquin.The winter came and went. We recently ordered delivery as the weather was terrible and it wasn’t walkable. I live in the apartments within view. You can easily walk it on a nice day.My father and I both ordered the patty melt with tater tots. I’ve never been so disappointed in my life. Something has changed in a big, bad way here.The food isn’t the same. The patty melt was one big lump of dry, overcooked ground beef. They refused to allow me to order it medium or medium rare. It was cooked well done to a crisp.The bread was extremely soggy and the tater tots were WAY over cooked. Our dinners went into the garbage.We also got curds and the calamari. The calamari clearly changed. It’s tough and just terrible.There were rumors the business was sold. I can’t vouch for that. I can tell you something has changed. The food is terrible. Reviews are beginning to slide in a bad direction.If it was sold, I’d suggest the new owner return to what we know and love. Otherwise, you will not last here.I may give it another try down the road. However, for now food is too expensive to throw away.I truly hope they return to what I and others are used to.Parking: Paid Parking Lot on Front Street next to Texan BBQ.Free Street Parking Along the Downtown Algonquin area."

Full menu - 18 options

All prices are estimates on menu.

Chicken

Side Dishes

Entrées

Chicken Wings

Beef

Seafood

Fish Dishes

Salads

Burger

Steaks

Sandwiches

American Food

Main Course

Wraps

Sherry Sherry

Believe it or not the BEST spaghetti with marinara sauce I've ever had!

Address

Show Map

Reviews

Tina
Tina

Chicken Fresco was excellent. Bartender was very attentive. Will come here again and try something else.


Dan
Dan

As for kid-friendliness, the waitstaff was very accommodating and engaging with our lively little ones, providing extra crayons and chatting with them.


Dan
Dan

Crowded to sit inside. We had a party of 5 and was not very comfortable sitting. Cobb salad was very good. Side of fries was small. Drink selection is very limited for non-alcoholic. Burgers were okay.Parking: Parking behind the restaurant.Wheelchair accessibility: I would say no to wheelchairs. View menu


باورد
باورد

Our group had an amazing experience at Cattleman’s last night. The food was delicious, the servers and owners were friendly and attentive, and the atmosphere was lovely. Many in our group ordered the ribs and absolutely loved them. We will certainly be coming back to this wonderful gathering spot!


Heather
Heather

I've been to Cattlemens about three times now. Two other times just for standard cocktails. The bartender was very nice. The Cobb salad was excellent, ample with homemade ranch and blue cheese. The grilled chicken pieces within the salad was generous too. It is a bit of a tight squeeze in there and street parking to be a bit tricky. I give this place 3.5 stars.


Chas
Chas

We took my wife's business partner out for her birthday. I ordered the pulled pork sandwich. It was dry and pieces were so hard that I thought I had a chicken bone in my mouth. We are our food and moved on. When I got the electronic receipt, the pork sandwich was $2 more that in the menu or online. Now I wish I would've checked all the other meals. $2 isn't going to kill me but not sure how this happens and if they're doing it on several items, not cool. Check your bills. View menu


Elizabeth
Elizabeth

This was our first time and we were really satisfied with the food, price, and service from our waiter. He brought refills before we had to ask, he checked in on us often and was kind enough to make sure the kitchen didn't have nuts because our son has a food allergy.We had curds, wings, and burgers amongst the family. My son has autism and going to restaurants can be really difficult but we chose to try this place because the the booth option and lower ceilings. With 4 meals, appetizer and 4 drinks, and a box full of leftovers, we spent about $64 before tip which is a great deal for a family night out. My kids loved the crayons and coloring sheets and the music. We will definitely be back....


Brandy
Brandy

After a fantastic first visit earlier this week, we decided to return. This time, however, we encountered a server who was quite abrupt and informed us that the restaurant closes at 10 PM, even though the Google listing states it closes at midnight. During our previous visit, the kitchen indeed closed at 10 PM, but we had an excellent server who positively influenced my experience and rating. While it’s perfectly fine for a business to close early, it would be helpful for them to communicate this to customers rather than providing incorrect information about their regular hours. I recommend that this small business update their Google listing to reflect any early closures and ensure that the...


Megan
Megan

I’ve lived in “Old Algonquin” for 4+ years and have always considered this place a neighborhood institution.The appetizers were always delicious. The cheese curds calamari were always my favorite.For dinner, I always would go with the Patty Melt, substitute tater tots. It was always extremely filling, cooked perfectly medium-rare, and the bread toasted and crisp.We always enjoyed dining outside on a gorgeous day in “Old” Downtown Algonquin.The winter came and went. We recently ordered delivery as the weather was terrible and it wasn’t walkable. I live in the apartments within view. You can easily walk it on a nice day.My father and I both ordered the patty melt with tater tots. I’ve never be... View menu

Categories

  • Cafés Charming cafés offering a variety of freshly brewed coffees and teas, along with light snacks, pastries, and desserts. Perfect for a morning pick-me-up or an afternoon treat in a cozy atmosphere.
  • Grill Succulent meats and fresh vegetables perfectly cooked over an open flame, delivering rich smoky flavors. Savor tender steaks, juicy burgers, and tangy marinated kebabs, all grilled to perfection for an unforgettable dining experience. View menu
  • Burgers Juicy, flavorful burgers crafted with premium ingredients, from classic beef to unique vegetarian options, all served with fresh toppings and a choice of hand-cut fries or a crisp salad.
  • Barbecue Savor the smoky, juicy flavors of our barbecue delights. From tender ribs to succulent pulled pork, each dish is grilled to perfection with our signature sauces, offering a true taste of barbecue heaven.

Amenities

  • Wifi
  • Takeout
  • menu
  • Delivery
  • menu
  • Full Bar

Similar Restaurants