Cove Hollow Tavern - Menu

85 Montauk Highway, Village Of East Hampton, 11937, United States Of America, East Hampton North

🛍 Pizza, Cafés, Seafood, American

4.4 💬 2788 Reviews
Cove Hollow Tavern

Phone: +16315277131

Address: 85 Montauk Highway, Village Of East Hampton, 11937, United States Of America, East Hampton North

City: East Hampton North

Menu Dishes: 35

Reviews: 2788

Website: http://www.covehollowtavern.com

"Table of 5 experienced extremely poor service. 5:30 pm reservation with only one table of 2 seated. We waited 1/2 hour to have our drink order placed. It was another 1/2 hour to place our dinner order. A long wait to have our food served with very few tables seated. At almost 2 hrs. I had to ask to have the table cleared and dessert order taken. We finished 2 1/2 hrs later. We only gave it a second try because it was where our friend wanted to dine. Sad."

Full menu - 35 options

All prices are estimates on menu.

Dessert

Sides

Entrées

Salads

Chicken

Pasta

Appetizer

Chicken Wings

Vegetarian

Entree

Beef Dishes

Steaks

Tacos

Pork Dishes*

Quality Greens

Starters

Seafood

Specialties

Matthew Matthew

Food was mediocre and are server seemed like he hated us. Don’t think we’ll be back anytime soon.

Address

Show Map

Reviews

Michael
Michael

Tried for the first time. The rigatoni was delicious as was the cauliflower dish. We will definitely be back next year.


Toni
Toni

Wonderful food, great service. One of our favorite restaurants! Parking: If the restaurant is crowded, parking can sometimes be an issue!


Joel
Joel

The best thing I had here was the firecracker shrimp. The ribs were also great. Next time I will definitely be going to get that firecracker shrimp again! View menu


Jakob
Jakob

The hamburger role was stale, very stale. The mushroom bolognese didn't seem to be made by a chef. The scoop of ice cream was laughably small. Perhaps they were missing key employees?


Ashley
Ashley

Food was ok… service was horrible. Waited over 20 minutes for drinks. Asked for a lemon to sprinkle on my steak and they refused to give me one. Have been here over a dozen times and will never go back.


Kevin
Kevin

This is my local favorite, great people, great food and drink. I cannot say enough about the friendly staff. Whether you’re looking for a relaxing sit down dinner or a burger at the bar, this is a great spot. View menu


JohnF
JohnF

Great selection of apps and they could each feed 2 we ordered the Lobster Tacos and a spicy shrimp app both were excellent. Same on the beet salad we split it Both had the grilled Mahi-mahi prep was delicious and the profiteroles finished it off Great meal good pour on the wine. Definitely going back


EDC2244
EDC2244

Cove Hollow is a home run! Table was ready even though they were busy. Waiter was adorable and helpful and got all modifications right in our orders. The two things he recommended that we order were fantastic. All of the food from the bread to the salad to the Mahi Mahi and tuna burger and fries and onto the brownie were divine, flawless. Great ambiance and decor. Lively and fun with familiar faces. Prices were not too bad. Cannot wait to come back!


MaryR
MaryR

Table of 5 experienced extremely poor service. 5:30 pm reservation with only one table of 2 seated. We waited 1/2 hour to have our drink order placed. It was another 1/2 hour to place our dinner order. A long wait to have our food served with very few tables seated. At almost 2 hrs. I had to ask to have the table cleared and dessert order taken. We finished 2 1/2 hrs later. We only gave it a second try because it was where our friend wanted to dine. Sad. View menu

Categories

  • Pizza Delve into our perfectly baked pizzas, crafted with hand-tossed dough, rich tomato sauce, and a blend of gourmet cheeses. Each slice bursts with fresh toppings, ensuring a delightful bite every time.
  • Cafés Charming cafés offering a variety of freshly brewed coffees and teas, along with light snacks, pastries, and desserts. Perfect for a morning pick-me-up or an afternoon treat in a cozy atmosphere. View menu
  • Seafood Dive into the freshest catches of the sea with our seafood selection, featuring exquisite dishes prepared with high-quality fish and shellfish. Savor the flavors of the ocean in every bite!
  • American Enjoy classic American flavors with our diverse menu, featuring juicy burgers, crispy fried chicken, hearty BBQ ribs, and fresh salads. Indulge in timeless comfort with each bite, crafted to satisfy all tastes.

Amenities

  • Beer
  • Wine
  • menu
  • Amex
  • menu
  • Wifi

Similar Restaurants

Sam's Bar And Restaurant

Sam's Bar And Restaurant

36 Newtown LnNY 11937, East Hampton North, United States

Menu • Pizza • Salad • Italian • American


"Always very, very pleased with the food and the waitresses are lovely. Only four stars however because I was extremely disappointed by the hostess (specifically last night 06/05). I put my name in for two and was told about thirty minutes. It was super busy as usual, so I said we’d be waiting outside. We waited the time, sitting in chairs right out front of the restaurant and when the hostess popped her head out to call my name I whirled around and called out “oh, right here!” quite loudly. She didn’t wait or register what I said, but I was at the door and holding it open in seconds. I held the door for two people exiting with pizzas and stepped in less than a minute later from the initial name call to see two other people who arrived after us being seated at what was supposed to be our table. The hostess eventually came back over and while looking at me questioningly I said “you just called my name.” She barely apologized — and I do mean barely — with a toss of “oh sorry, another table should open up soon.” The look on her face very clearly expressed that she knew she should have given us a chance to walk in the door. Another 15 minutes went by before we sat, making for 45 minutes for a table for two because the hostess could not actually look around and/or wait a full minute for the waiting party. It left a very sour taste that was only salvaged by our absolutely delightful waitress (I wish I knew her name as we’ve gotten her every time and she’s always quick and attentive and sweet. She served us at the table just before the other dining room with the favorite seats plaque)."

Bostwick's Chowder House

Bostwick's Chowder House

277 Pantigo Road, East Hampton, New York, 11937, United States

Menu • Soup • Seafood • American • North American


"Meh. Maybe my expectations for this restaurant were a little too high, as I was a little disappointed in both my meal and the fact that they only use disposable cups utensils. For the high prices, I didn't expect the fast casual atmosphere and food quality. I was really disturbed about how many disposable cups/utensils were used at this very busy restaurant. It's so bad for our environment! The food was hit or miss for me. Although I didn't think my entree was amazing, I really enjoyed the shared appetizers. Shared Appetizers: Steamers $29): these were perfection. They came with clam broth and butter on the side for dipping. Delicious! I wish I ordered this as my main entree. Recommended! Mussels in Red Sauce $16.95): these were also delicious. We ate them ALL! Fried Calamari $16.95): pretty standard. Good but nothing special. Buffalo Chix Wings $13.95): very good. Came with a great blue cheese dipping sauce. My entree: Fluke Milanese $30.95): I found this dish kind of...boring. it was a very dry fried fluke in a panko crust which had absolutely no seasoning. Bland and boring, but it came with a good arugula salad on top. I can't speak about other's entrees but everyone seemed to enjoy their meal. My 9 yr old niece gave two thumbs up for her salmon teriyaki. Service and hospitality were friendly and efficient. This restaurant is very busy and does NOT accept reservations. Plenty of free parking available."