Johnny's New York Style Pizza

24 Old Jackson Road McDonough, GA 30252, McDonough, United States

🛍 Pizza, Salad, Italian, American

3.8 💬 739 Reviews
Johnny's New York Style Pizza

Phone: +17709544225

Address: 24 Old Jackson Road Mcdonough, GA 30252, McDonough, United States

City: McDonough

Menu Dishes: 35

Reviews: 739

Website: http://johnnyspizza.com/

"Oh my god their pizza is terrible and the chicken bites I paid $5.40 for must be a joke because what they gave me was just a few tiny pieces of store bought frozen chicken that was cold and mushy on some sides. Disgusting! I had to contact Seamless torequest a refund because the food was so nasty. The pizza was so tiny for it to be a medium and coming from a place called NEWYORK STYLE I can 't help but laugh because they are the smallest most pitiful slices of pizza I have ever saw not to mention howflavorless they are. ALL of the food I ordered and the drink went in the trash. I wouldn 't even feed it to my dogs. I will nevertry a new pizza place again, I should have known to stick with the I Love NY Pizza place here in Locust Grove because theyactually know how to make good food and give you portions that don 't make you feel like you are getting ripped off! Irealized after I wrote the above that the fruit punch I ordered for my daughter was NOT fruit punch! They sent a soda instead!!!One that was going flat even. We do not give our children soda so I am very annoyed that they sent that instead of the fruitpunch I ordered!"

Full menu - 35 options

All prices are estimates on menu.

Salads

Pizza

Sandwiches

Subs

Hot And Cold Subs

Chicken Dishes

Starters

Kids Menu

Calzone

Sides And Extras

Pasta

Sides

Entrées

3 Hour Open Bar

Specialty Pizzas

Specialty Calzone And Stromboli

Chicken

Stromboli

Hand Crafted Sandwiches

Wraps

Roderick Roderick

I really enjoy placing to-go orders from this Johnny's.

Address

Show Map

Reviews

Sam
Sam

This spot is great! Fair rates, considerable dishes and the staff members are regularly kind.


barbara
barbara

This is the best pizza we've had in quite a while! The service was excellent, and the atmosphere was relaxed and enjoyable. We will definitely be returning. Highly recommend!


Damon
Damon

Johnny's New York Style Pizza exceeded my daughter's expectations. Although the location was a bit further than we originally planned, we were pleased to have it as an option. We will definitely order from there again. View menu


Love
Love

We ended up here after wanting pizza. The wait staff looked confused. She never offered sauce with our parmesan bites. Walked over to the restroom every was standing around and the kitchen floor was so nasty I lost my appetite.


Lina
Lina

Great pizza and fast service! The crust was amazing and full of flavor. There are plenty of topping options to choose from. We ordered the house pizza, and it was generously topped. They certainly don't skimp on the ingredients. It was a fantastic value for delicious pizza!


Mary
Mary

We ordered a margherita pizza, and the crunch of the crust was incredible! The combination of the sweet basil and ripe tomatoes made it so addictive. We also tried the Stromboli with steak, peppers, and onions (Philly-style), and it had that same delightful crunch in the crust—absolutely delicious! View menu


Tad
Tad

I love Greek salad, but during my last couple of visits, the house dressing has been overly vinegary and lacking flavor. I also ordered a large salad for $10, but unfortunately, it wasn't enough for both my wife and me. Just a couple of points that I think need to be addressed. That said, the customer service is great!


Zita
Zita

Absolutely fantastic! This is one of my favorite pizza spots in Georgia! The pizza is amazing (I particularly love the classic pepperoni with light cheese), and the garlic bites are simply delicious! There's a waitress named Nicole E who is always there when I visit, and she's really friendly. She doesn't interrupt our meal too often, which allows us to enjoy our time. The staff is super nice, and the food is great!


Kimberly
Kimberly

Oh my god their pizza is terrible and the chicken bites I paid $5.40 for must be a joke because what they gave me was just a few tiny pieces of store bought frozen chicken that was cold and mushy on some sides. Disgusting! I had to contact Seamless torequest a refund because the food was so nasty. The pizza was so tiny for it to be a medium and coming from a place called NEWYORK STYLE I can 't help but laugh because they are the smallest most pitiful slices of pizza I have ever saw not to mention howflavorless they are. ALL of the food I ordered and the drink went in the trash. I wouldn 't even feed it to my dogs. I will nevertry a new pizza place again, I should have known to stick with the... View menu

Categories

  • Pizza Delve into our perfectly baked pizzas, crafted with hand-tossed dough, rich tomato sauce, and a blend of gourmet cheeses. Each slice bursts with fresh toppings, ensuring a delightful bite every time.
  • Salad A delightful assortment of vibrant salads, featuring fresh greens, seasonal vegetables, and savory toppings, drizzled with our signature dressings for a refreshing and wholesome meal experience. View menu
  • Italian Savor the rich and diverse flavors of Italy with our menu, offering classic pasta, savory risottos, and traditional meat and seafood dishes, all crafted with authentic ingredients and passion. Buon appetito!
  • American Enjoy classic American flavors with our diverse menu, featuring juicy burgers, crispy fried chicken, hearty BBQ ribs, and fresh salads. Indulge in timeless comfort with each bite, crafted to satisfy all tastes.

Amenities

  • Takeout
  • Delivery
  • menu

Similar Restaurants

Pasta Max Cafe

Pasta Max Cafe

50 Griffin St, 30253, McDonough, United States

Menu • Cafe • Pasta • Coffee • Italian


"I cannot believe I grew up so close to Pasta Max Cafe and am just now trying it! I came here on a weekend night and the place was packed! I can't remember if they take reservations or not, but if they do, I highly recommend making them, because the place was packed! The dining area is small, yet charming and intimate. The restaurant is locally owned and has been up and running for over 30 years. It is definitely a staple in Henry county. I love the complimentary bread service they offered. The rolls were light fluffy drizzled with olive oil and a touch of garlic. It was hard to eat just one, but I wanted to save room for my pasta entrée. There were several on the menu that I wanted to choose, but I selected Chicken Parmigiana dish. First of all, I was blown away by the portion sizes of their dishes. Their chefs are heavy-handed and you will definitely be leaving with leftovers. The piece of chicken I got was almost the size of my plate and the bowl was filled to the brim with pasta! Not to mention, the prices are very fair, especially in today's inflated market. The red sauce in my dish was unique to any red sauce I've tried before. I couldn't pinpoint what the special ingredient was, but it's definitely a standout taste in the sauce. I highly recommend any of the pastas that have red sauce. We also got the calamari appetizer that had the same yummy red sauce for dipping. The calamari was fresh, battered and fried well, and plenty was given for our table of three to share. We also ordered a large pepperoni pizza to see if their pies were as good as their pastas! Yep, they are, so I suggest ordering one of each for the table! Be sure to leave room for dessert because the tiramisu is to die for. Again, they give you a huge serving size of the cake and you can tell it's definitely homemade. This is some of the best tiramisu I've ever had, and I am very picky about my tiramisu. Last but not least, our service was outstanding. Even though the place was packed and only two servers working, they were on it! Our dishes came out quickly, food was hot, and drinks were refilled constantly. We were in and out at a reasonable time. I can't wait to go back and try some more of their food. If you are in the McDonough Square, make sure you choose this restaurant to dine at! You won't regret it, but only choose this place if you're hungry because you will be getting a lot of food!"