La Rustica Pizza - Menu

1426 Lexington Ave, New York City I-10128-1609, United States

🛍 Pizza, Lunch, Magpie, Italian

4.1 💬 2833 Reviews

Phone: +12128603822

Address: 1426 Lexington Ave, New York City I-10128-1609, United States

City: New York City

Menu Dishes: 35

Reviews: 2833

Website: https://www.orderlarusticapizza.com/

"Wow, their pizza is absolutely amazing! I’m a huge fan of the Margherita. You can really taste the high-quality ingredients. I've never had cheese and sweet tomatoes of this caliber at a typical mom-and-pop pizza place. The amount of cheese is perfect—it has a nice bite to it, unlike most Margheritas that just have a thin layer. The crust is crispy too, even with all the delicious toppings. It’s truly satisfying!"

Full menu - 35 options

All prices are estimates on menu.

Specialty Pies

Pizza

Pizza Pies

Dessert

Gourmet Pizza 18"

Vegetarian

Sides

Entrées

Chicken

Sicilian Pies

Pasta

Entrées / Appetizers

Paninis And Pizzas

New York Style Pizza Slice

Seafood Dishes

Chicken Dishes

Pizza By Slice

Pasta Dishes

Hand Tossed Gourmet Pizzas

Brick Oven Pizza

Appetizers &Amp; Sides

Sandwiches

By The Slice

Pizza (By The Pie)

White Pies (Pizza)

Hot & Cold Heros

Cold Sandwiches Boar's Head

Heroes

Sandwiches & Pizzas

Maxwell Maxwell

Ordered a pesto chicken pizza. Crust was excellent, pizza showed up a little bit late.

Address

Show Map

Reviews

Ted
Ted

The Cauliflower gluten free crust was small, but delicious and perfect for a personal pie.


Angela
Angela

Their pizza is GROSS!I ordered from seamless and it arrived cold, the dough was NASTY and the flavors non existent.


Nanite
Nanite

The marinara sauce was lacking in flavor, and the pizza was just decent. However, the garlic knots were the highlight of the meal. View menu


Holly
Holly

Holy moly, SO good!! We got a cheese pizza delivered and it was fast and probably the BEST pizza I have ever had!!! Can't wait to visit NYC again and try ALL the things on the menu!!! Bravo!


Jordan
Jordan

The pizza was delightful, and while the tiramisu was on the smaller side, it was still very tasty. The only downside was that the garlic knots could have used a bit more seasoning and were slightly burnt in some spots, but we polished them off anyway!


Sydney
Sydney

The rainbow pie was absolutely delicious, and they are generous with the sauces, which definitely adds to its value. The portion sizes for the chicken parmesan are fantastic in relation to the price. With such great food, this is definitely a restaurant I’ll be returning to! View menu


Taylor
Taylor

The pepperoni and cheese slices and the garlic knots were cold. Idk what it is that they put at the bottom of the pizza to give it texture, it was great just a little too much for my liking. The garlic knots were amazingly delightful. Besides the order being cold, Yeah the garlic knots are a hit.


Faisal
Faisal

This is definitely my favorite pizza place on the Upper East Side. The crust is perfect! It's crispy and has a generous amount of cornmeal on the bottom, which I absolutely love. The prices for the pizzas are reasonable, with a slice of cheese costing $3. I highly recommend this spot if you're looking for delicious pizza in the area!


Fnky
Fnky

Wow, their pizza is absolutely amazing! I’m a huge fan of the Margherita. You can really taste the high-quality ingredients. I've never had cheese and sweet tomatoes of this caliber at a typical mom-and-pop pizza place. The amount of cheese is perfect—it has a nice bite to it, unlike most Margheritas that just have a thin layer. The crust is crispy too, even with all the delicious toppings. It’s truly satisfying! View menu

Categories

  • Pizza Delve into our perfectly baked pizzas, crafted with hand-tossed dough, rich tomato sauce, and a blend of gourmet cheeses. Each slice bursts with fresh toppings, ensuring a delightful bite every time.
  • Lunch Satisfy your midday cravings with our delicious lunch menu. From fresh salads and hearty sandwiches to savory soups and vibrant bowls, each dish is crafted to give you the perfect midday boost. View menu
  • Magpie
  • Italian Savor the rich and diverse flavors of Italy with our menu, offering classic pasta, savory risottos, and traditional meat and seafood dishes, all crafted with authentic ingredients and passion. Buon appetito!

Amenities

  • Wifi
  • Takeout
  • menu
  • Delivery
  • menu
  • Television

Similar Restaurants