Maya Mezcal - Menu

304 East 6th St., New York, United States

🛍 Meat, Cheese, Mexican, Chicken

4.1 💬 1919 Reviews
Maya Mezcal

Phone: +12122535888

Address: 304 East 6th St., New York, United States

City: New York

Menu Dishes: 35

Reviews: 1919

Website: http://Mayamezcal.com

"They seated us minutes after our reserved time. It wasn’t an issue with OpenTable we could see the reservation on their system. They simply weren’t prepared. There was no apology for our delayed seating. The food ranged from terrible (a paella that seemed to have come out of a Trader Joe’s box) to mediocre (decent meat was made mediocre by Walmart tortillas). The drinks were pretty good. They have a wide selection of mezcal. The service was otherwise okay. The bathroom featured the toilet cleaning brush in a plastic box in the middle of the floor. And hopefully no one was waiting because the door didn’t lock. Would not return."

Full menu - 35 options

All prices are estimates on menu.

Agave Frescas

Caliente

Flights To Mexico

Some Like It Hot

Sherrynice Cocktails

Mariposa Cocktails

Strange Stirrings

Tex-Mex Combos

Speciality Rolls

Warm Tapas

Light Spirited

Starters

Sotol Cocktails

Gin & Fever - Tree

Classics With Mezcal

Sours

Martas Martas

I absolutely love this restaurant. The food always tastes amazing and they have an incredible selection of drinks to choose from.

Address

Show Map

Reviews

User
User

I am going to miss this spot, what a wonderful restaurant. The drinks were inventive and delish, the food shared that luster. So sad to see them close.


User
User

Can't believe this legendary mezcal and tequila bar is closing, due to a dispute with a terrible landlord (who is threatening to open his own in the same space don't go


User
User

WHAT A GEM. The tequila menu is extensive and delicious. Great for drinks and smaller shareable bites with friends. Sad it's closing in a week! Hoping they find somewhere to relocate soon. View menu


User
User

Mayahuel is under new ownership—do not be fooled! This is not the place it used to be. The drinks are watered down and the menu is now a very misguided mix of Mexican appetizers and middle eastern/Mediterranean entrees. Service is hilariously inept.


User
User

Absolutely awful! Nothing like what it used to be under the new owners. I’m so sad because that was the best and was once my favorite restaurant. The queso fundido literally had the texture of Elmer’s crazy glue that just kept getting chewier and chewier as you ate.


Opentable
Opentable

We absolutely love Maya Mezcal and this was our third visit to the restaurant. The cocktails are creative and consistently excellent. The food is also incredibly tasty, with high quality ingredients and a very welcoming staff. Maya Mezcal has become one of our go-to spots for a fun night out. View menu


User
User

Our server didn’t greet us for the first minutes we were there, although she was delivering drinks and food to the tables on both sides of ours. Drinks were great, guacamole was too. The queso was over cooked causing the cheese to curdle. The tacos arrived cold, and the chicken and beef tacos were mostly gristle.


User
User

We were excited to hear this place was reopening but we were supremely disappointed. They need to officially change the name as everything about this place has not changed, less the interior which they left thankfully. That is about the only positive thing I can say about this place. Nothing like the old spot unfortunately.


User
User

They seated us minutes after our reserved time. It wasn’t an issue with OpenTable we could see the reservation on their system. They simply weren’t prepared. There was no apology for our delayed seating. The food ranged from terrible (a paella that seemed to have come out of a Trader Joe’s box) to mediocre (decent meat was made mediocre by Walmart tortillas). The drinks were pretty good. They have a wide selection of mezcal. The service was otherwise okay. The bathroom featured the toilet cleaning brush in a plastic box in the middle of the floor. And hopefully no one was waiting because the door didn’t lock. Would not return. View menu

Categories

  • Meat Explore our mouth-watering meat selection, featuring expertly grilled steaks, tender chicken, and flavorful lamb dishes, each seasoned to perfection for an unforgettable dining experience.
  • Cheese A curated selection of artisanal cheeses from around the world, featuring diverse flavors and textures that delight the palate. Perfect for sharing or savored individually with the ideal accompaniments. View menu
  • Mexican Authentic Mexican flavors await you with sizzling fajitas, savory tacos, zesty enchiladas, and fresh guacamole, all crafted with rich, traditional spices and served with vibrant sides. Enjoy a fiesta on your plate!
  • Chicken Succulent and savory, our chicken dishes are crafted with tender meat, flavorful seasonings, and diverse culinary inspirations. Enjoy a delectable variety that's sure to satisfy every palate.

Amenities

  • Amex
  • Wifi
  • menu
  • Outdoor
  • menu
  • Takeout

Similar Restaurants

Bread N Wine

Bread N Wine

1417 Lexington Ave, New York City I-10128-1613, United States

Menu • Wine • French • Coffee • American


"We went to Bread N Wine on a early Saturday afternoon for brunch. We were greeted and seated by the servers who were attentive. The food was okay the bread was really soft and fresh. My partner got the French Lentil Soup, Spinach and Tomato Egg Bake andI got the French onion soup, egg omelette with spicy tomato avocado and onions. I wasn 't happy with my omelette because thespicy just meant it was covered in hot sauce within. For beverages, we got chai lattes (we later found out it wasn 't tea basedbut rather coffee) and we had the option of oat milk, almond milk or regular milk. In terms of our overall experience we feltby the end too many things were steering the experience south; the worst was when we were accused of using counterfeit money topay for the tip. There was no special marker used to prove that the money was counterfeit or technology to back up this claim.That experience alone left a bad taste in our mouth as we left embarrassed by that claim, kind of shook from that, we stilladded the tip to our credit card 18%. As we walked out and talked about how weird that was, the owner of the business nextdoor overheard us and asked to see the $20 bill he showed us that our money was real and validated what we knew, that themoney wasn 't counterfeit. When we went back into Bread N Wine to discuss this there was no apology, just well, it felt thatway , shrug. It left a terrible feeling. We would not go back after that, this is not how you treat customers from start tofinish, hence the 2 star review."