Phone: +12122431640
Address: 19 Commerce St, New York, NY 10014, City of New York, United States
City: City of New York
Menu Dishes: 35
Reviews: 558
"I'm visiting New Jersey from California and we saw this shop on the insider so we made the drive over to the city just for Milk and Cookies. There was a young lady and young man working who were amazing! The young lady was so charismatic and very welcoming! She was interacting with us as if we had known her for years. Of course the gentleman was working hard to make the ice cream sandwiches. Thank you for not only providing amazing dessert but also for amazing service and hospitality! I can't wait to come back and send my traveling friends here!"
Full menu - 35 options
All prices are estimates on menu.
Choose Your Mix-Ins
Dessert
Cupcakes
Delightful, moist cupcakes with creamy frosting, perfect for a sweet treat or special occasion indulgence.
Brownies
Rich, fudgy brownies packed with chocolatey goodness, perfect for satisfying any sweet craving.
Rice Crispy Treats
Sweet and crispy marshmallow-infused rice cereal squares; a classic treat delightfully light and gooey.
Ice Cream Sandwiches $5.50 Each
Cookie Special
Sweet Crapes
Brownies &Amp;Amp; Bars
Dessert Menu - Friend-Z
Negra Modelo
Side Dishes
Sweet Waffles Or Crepes
Old School Classics
Indian
Chai Latte
A warm, spiced tea blend with frothy, steamed milk, offering a comforting and aromatic experience.
Specialty Pizzas Ø 32Cm
Dessert Buffet
Home Made Ice Cream
Health Nuts
Extras
Rainbow Sprinkles
Colorful sugar sprinkles that add a fun, sweet crunch to any dessert.
Fresh From The Garden
C.b.c. Original Cravings
Dan
Very NYC. The best cookies I've ever had. Charming, owner-operated shop. Delicious.
Address
Reviews
Grace
Best Cookies, bars and brownies in NYC! It's on the top of my list when I'm back! We even take a box back with us to Zurich!
Kristen
THE best treat I've had in a long time. I went with salted caramel cookie with marshmallow caramel gelato, rolled in caramel bits
Tammy
We had ice sandwiches for our wedding dessert and it was a hit! Not only were they delicious but they were huge! Our guests along with us loved them! Thank you Milk Cookies! View menu
Kristen
Milk and Cookies is the best place. My family always stops here on our way home from a trip to the city since we live in NJ. Always fresh. Always delicious. And always so friendly there!
Peggy
I visited this place during a Foods of NY tour, and I can confidently say they have the best chocolate chip cookies I've ever tasted! The shop is adorable, and the staff were so wonderful. I will definitely come back!
Lisa
Best cookies ever! Salt and oats are my most fav!! My dog loves the peanut butter doggy bones too!! Love that they ship anywhere!! If your in the neighborhood Milk Cookies should most definately be on your To Do List!! View menu
Stephanie
This is the best cookie spot in NYC! The fresh milk is unbeatable too. If you're a fan of ice cream, you absolutely have to try making your own ice cream sandwich. You can select any two cookies and your favorite ice cream flavor for just $5!
Kelli
I had an expired Groupon from 2013, and this past Sunday, I happened to walk by this place. I remembered the unused Groupon and showed it to the cashier—no problem at all! The cookies were absolutely delicious! It's a really charming little cafe tucked away off the beaten path. The customer service was great, the prices were reasonable, and the atmosphere was comfortable. I give it two very enthusiastic thumbs up!
Lauren
I'm visiting New Jersey from California and we saw this shop on the insider so we made the drive over to the city just for Milk and Cookies. There was a young lady and young man working who were amazing! The young lady was so charismatic and very welcoming! She was interacting with us as if we had known her for years. Of course the gentleman was working hard to make the ice cream sandwiches. Thank you for not only providing amazing dessert but also for amazing service and hospitality! I can't wait to come back and send my traveling friends here! View menu
City of New York
New York City is renowned for its diverse culinary scene, featuring classic street foods like hot dogs and pretzels, along with international cuisines from every corner of the globe.
Categories
-
Bakery Delight in freshly baked goods offering a variety of breads, pastries, and sweet treats, each crafted with care and premium ingredients to satisfy any craving and complement any meal or coffee break.
-
Desserts Delight in our selection of indulgent desserts, from luscious chocolate creations to delicate fruit-infused treats, each crafted to end your meal on a sweet note and leave your taste buds craving for more. View menu
-
Bakeries A delightful assortment of freshly baked pastries, breads, and confections, crafted with love and premium ingredients for a sweet morning treat or an afternoon indulgence.
Amenities
-
Dog Treats
-
Custom Desserts
- menu
-
Ice Cream Sandwiches
- menu
