Mister Softee - Menu

1580 Lakewood Road, Toms River, United States Of America

🛍 Ice Cream, Milk Shakes

★ 4.7 💬 462 Reviews

Phone: (+1)8482244512

Address: 1580 Lakewood Road, Toms River, United States Of America

City: Toms River

Menu Dishes: 30

Reviews: 462

"The ice cream was slightly melted, but that's not really their fault. They provided a generous amount of toppings, so I’ll definitely have leftovers for another bowl. Once it hardened a bit, the ice cream was absolutely perfect!"

Full menu - 30 options

All prices are estimates on menu.

Dessert

Cookie
Cookie
Soft Serve Vanilla
Soft Serve Vanilla
Blueberry Cheesecake
Blueberry Cheesecake
Soft Serve Strawberry
Soft Serve Strawberry

Desserts

Kit Kat
Kit Kat

A sweet treat featuring crispy wafers coated in smooth milk chocolate, perfect for a delightful break.

Butterscotch
Butterscotch
Birthday Cake
Birthday Cake

Classic vanilla cake with rainbow sprinkles and creamy frosting, perfect for celebrating life's special moments.

Cinnamon Toast Crunch
Cinnamon Toast Crunch

Ice Cream*

Hard Vanilla
Hard Vanilla
Hard Strawberry
Hard Strawberry
Sugar -Free Cherry Vanilla
Sugar -Free Cherry Vanilla menu
Soft Serve Strawberry And Vanilla Swirl
Soft Serve Strawberry And Vanilla Swirl

Extras

Whipped Cream
Whipped Cream
Chocolate Syrup
Chocolate Syrup
Rainbow Sprinkles
Rainbow Sprinkles

Colorful sugar sprinkles that add a fun, sweet crunch to any dessert.

Malted Milk Powder
Malted Milk Powder

Candies

Andes Mints
Andes Mints
Reese’s Cups
Reese’s Cups

Dessert Menu - Friend-Z

M&Ms
M&Ms

Confiteria

Nerds
Nerds

Entrées

Oreos
Oreos

Sundae

Hot Fudge
Hot Fudge

Delicious Mixins

Gummy Bears
Gummy Bears

Ben & Jerry's

Cookie Dough
Cookie Dough

Dips

Chocolate Dip
Chocolate Dip

A rich, velvety chocolate sauce perfect for dipping fresh fruits, marshmallows, or cookies for a sweet treat.

Add Ons

Crushed Peanuts
Crushed Peanuts

Cool Toppings

Crushed Cherries
Crushed Cherries

Toppings On The Side

Confetti Sprinkles
Confetti Sprinkles

Mods_Syrups

Peanut Butter Sauce
Peanut Butter Sauce

Cream Ices

Vanilla Peanut Butter
Vanilla Peanut Butter
Edward Edward
★ ★ ★ ★ ★

Excellent ice cream! Very tasty!

View More Reviews

Address

Show Map

Reviews

Chris
Chris
★

Expensive and flavor less ice cream. Definitely prefer sundaes over this.

Edward
Edward
★ ★ ★ ★ ★

The ice cream here is outstanding! My Cookie Monster flavor is crafted to perfection.

Madison
Madison
★ ★ ★ ★ ★

The customer service was outstanding, and the ice cream was delicious! They were very generous with the portions in my cup. I will definitely be returning! View menu

Julie
Julie
★ ★ ★ ★ ★

The ice cream was slightly melted, but that's not really their fault. They provided a generous amount of toppings, so I’ll definitely have leftovers for another bowl. Once it hardened a bit, the ice cream was absolutely perfect!

Categories

  • Ice Cream A delightful selection of creamy, handcrafted ice creams with a variety of flavors ranging from classic vanilla and chocolate to unique options like lavender honey and spicy mango, perfect for satisfying your sweet tooth.
  • Milk Shakes Indulge in our creamy and delicious milkshakes, offering a mix of classic and inventive flavors. Made with premium ingredients, each shake is a delightful treat perfect for satisfying your sweet cravings. View menu

Similar Restaurants

Schiano's Pizzeria

Schiano's Pizzeria

➤ 560 Lakehurst Road, Toms River, 08755, United States Of America

Menu • Pizza • Cheese • Italian • Chicken

"What a disappointment. This used to be my go to place for Italian food but not anymore. I ordered the chicken franchise with rigatoni. The chicken was so dry and overcooked I could hardly get my knife through it. The rigatoni was thick and gummy and there was little to no sauce making everything dry except for a couple of drippings that were at the bottom of the foil container. A total waste of my money and I won't be ordering from them again Food: 1"

Sal's Pizza

Sal's Pizza

➤ 1606 Route 37 E, Toms River I-08753, United States, 08753-5742

Menu • Lunch • Pizza • Italian • Salads

"I ordered a Sicilian pizza with meatballs and mushrooms, but it was only topped on one half. The topping side was burnt, while the plain side was slightly undercooked—how does that even happen? The dough and cheese lacked flavor, though the sauce was well-seasoned. As for the hot antipasto, it was a complete disappointment; everything was soggy and tasteless. The pizzeria should be embarrassed to serve such calamari and mozzarella sticks. The eggplant tasted like it had been washed in bleach. The only highlight was the mussels, which I would definitely order again."

Cool Beans Coffee House

Cool Beans Coffee House

➤ 635 Bay Ave, 08753, Toms River, US, United States

Menu • Casual • Coffee • Mexican • Pasta Salad

"My friends and I went to Cool Beans for their open mic night last Wednesday. It was our first visit and we were pleasantly surprised. The interior was spacious and decorated with beautiful art. The staff were friendly and polite. We tried their margarita and white personal pizzas, as well as the roasted red pepper flatbread, all of which were delicious. They have a diverse menu with plenty of options to choose from. We can't wait to go back and try more dishes soon."

Rosato's Pub & Pizzeria

Rosato's Pub & Pizzeria

➤ Mule Rd 600, 08757, Toms River, United States

Menu • Pub • Pubs • Pizza • Lunch

"We had a white pie, the ricotta cheese was put on first then it was covered with so much mozzarella on top. There was no olive oil with garlic. We give them a second chance with a pie with mushrooms and onions. The sauce was so watery, it was crushed tomatoes right out of the can. The mushrooms were right out of the can. The dough was mushy cause of the watery can tomatoes. Just horrible! This place has a new owner, good luck"

El Familiar

El Familiar

➤ 1246 NJ-166, Toms River, USA, 08753, United States

Menu • Wine • Mexican • American • Colombian

"A cozy, fantastic place to eat.. I recently ate at El Familiar on a cold Jersey afternoon, looking for something warm. I pulled up the Urbanspoon reference on my Iphone, and El Familiar popped up on a random search. El Familiar is a medium sized eatery, with tasteful decor that sets a casual mood. They start you off with chips and two bowls (two! of salsa, a chunky, spicy mix and one smooth and mild mix. Both are very good, and the chips are nicely salty, without being too greasy. The food itself is wonderful and served with spanish-style rice, pinto refried beans with a topping of cheese, a lettuce-tomato-guacamole mix, and the main entree itself. My flautas were beautifully crispy...read more"