Nicola's Trattoria - Menu

51 Railroad St. #f, Keene, 3431, United States Of America

🛍 Pasta, Salad, Italian, American

4.2 💬 1130 Reviews
Nicola's Trattoria

Phone: +16033555242

Address: 51 Railroad St. #f, Keene, 3431, United States Of America

City: Keene

Menu Dishes: 13

Reviews: 1130

"This was a birthday dinner on Christmas Eve (when many other restaurants in town were closed so grateful Nicola's was open , and the staff did everything they could to accommodate our party of six, including allowing us to bring our own cake to serve for dessert (thank you! . I will say, that we loved everything about the OLD Nicola's with one glaring exception the amount of wait time between courses. The new Nicola's has figured out how to change that up completely, and the mood and responses from every person working there was one of wanting to meet the desires of the customer, whatever they were. My husband even ordered something that wasn't even on the menu and they were able to accommodate him. Our waiter, Jennifer, was super competent, speedy and able to anticipate our needs. The chefs in the kitchen were fascinating to watch as they worked together to coordinate the dishes and put out perfectly cooked and presented food. I will also add that the wine list and cocktail options are now expanded and clearly chosen with care and expertise. All in all, a memorable night out. We will be back!"

Full menu - 13 options

All prices are estimates on menu.

Seafood

Pasta

Salads

Rice

Pork

Pasta / Small Pasta Dishes

Dessert

Desserts

Wrap

Sandwiches

User User

Terrific experience, great wine and perfect Bolognese!

Address

Show Map

Reviews

User
User

The food and service were excellent, looking forward to our next visit!


User
User

The food and service were excellent and look forward to our next visit!


User
User

We love Nicola's and are looking forward to it's new make-over and new name in the spring. View menu


User
User

Was a wonderful experience, accept that it is very loud, not very pleasant to play music. Several times had to ask for it to be switched off and there were several others there who had the same request. Would go back anytime!


User
User

It took us 3 years to get back here after an overpriced meal. we found the new ownership has changed the experience. The Sauce on my Veal Picatta was light with a hint of lemon. Ideal for soaking up with the last slice of moist and excellent bread. The Rack of lamb was tasty and not overwhelming. We splurged on sharing a chocolate cake dessert with a crunch of shaved chocolate to put it over the top. Oh and the VO on the rocks was a generous pour. Decafe coffee was even special too. we will return soon.


User
User

Nice atmosphere on Christmas Eve for a quiet dinner for two. Service was excellent. Drinks fantastic (blood orange margarita is highly recommended). Food was great. We had lobster spaghetti, Cesar salad, mushroom pizza. We were too full for desert but our waitress skillfully laid the desert menus on the table walk-by hit and run style and it worked. We shared the Zepole and were glad we did. A well-run establishment doing things right that I can recommend. Not inexpensive but delivers a quality dining experience. View menu


User
User

We visited NYE at 5:45 with a reserved seat in the bar. There were very few tables with seating when we arrived. We had an appetizer that was good. The salads lasted very long to get out, but were good. The meal took a long time to get out. I don't think we got our meals up to almost 6:45. If we were satisfied with the meals, waiting might not feel so long, but my husband and I were both disappointed by our courts. He had the salmon dish that had no taste at all. It seemed to be a piece of fish cooked without spices, maybe this is the way it is prepared. My dish that was the chicken Milanese, a dish that I got many times was over boiled, very dry and had little of the lemon sauce. I was not...


User
User

We visited NYE at 5:45 with a reserved seat in the bar. There were very few tables with seating when we arrived. We had an appetizer that was good. The salads took a long time to get out, but they were good. The meal took a long time to get out. I don't think we got our meals up to almost 6:45. If we were satisfied with the meals, waiting might not feel so long, but my husband and I were both disappointed by our courts. He had the salmon dish that had no taste at all. It seemed to be a piece of fish cooked without spices, maybe this is the way it is prepared. My dish that was the chicken Milanese, a dish that I got many times was over boiled, very dry and had little of the lemon sauce. I was...


User
User

This was a birthday dinner on Christmas Eve (when many other restaurants in town were closed so grateful Nicola's was open , and the staff did everything they could to accommodate our party of six, including allowing us to bring our own cake to serve for dessert (thank you! . I will say, that we loved everything about the OLD Nicola's with one glaring exception the amount of wait time between courses. The new Nicola's has figured out how to change that up completely, and the mood and responses from every person working there was one of wanting to meet the desires of the customer, whatever they were. My husband even ordered something that wasn't even on the menu and they were able to accommod... View menu

Categories

  • Pasta Delight in our selection of classic and contemporary pasta dishes, each crafted with fresh, quality ingredients and flavorful sauces that capture the essence of Italian cuisine in every bite.
  • Salad A delightful assortment of vibrant salads, featuring fresh greens, seasonal vegetables, and savory toppings, drizzled with our signature dressings for a refreshing and wholesome meal experience. View menu
  • Italian Savor the rich and diverse flavors of Italy with our menu, offering classic pasta, savory risottos, and traditional meat and seafood dishes, all crafted with authentic ingredients and passion. Buon appetito!
  • American Enjoy classic American flavors with our diverse menu, featuring juicy burgers, crispy fried chicken, hearty BBQ ribs, and fresh salads. Indulge in timeless comfort with each bite, crafted to satisfy all tastes.

Amenities

  • Romantic
  • Reservations
  • menu

Similar Restaurants

Little Zoe's Pizza

Little Zoe's Pizza

149 Emerald St, Keene, United States Of America, 03431

Menu • Pizza • Cafés • Lunch • American


"First impressions. I like brick oven pizza and this was in fact what I'd expect out of Brick Oven pizza. The crust of the regular crust is crispy and slightly blackened as you would expect. The pizza was prepared neatly and had adequately dispersed toppings so you didn't miss anything with each bite.Flavor and consistency. The crust was a little thin for my personal taste which is the only reason why I personally wouldn't give it 5 stars, but that doesn't detract from the quality. It was evenly cooked and delicious. The SAUCE though, best sauce I have had on a pizza in some time. I ended up eating the entire small pizza in an evening.Gluten free. The gluten free crust was different though and I understand it is likely because it was gluten free, but the crust was soggy and wet. I'm sure it would have held together better if there were a binding agent such as cheese at the top of the pizza, but unfortunately no vegan cheese options are offered. However, this again doesn't detract from my personal rating as I do not have such dietary restrictions and I understand the added expense, lack of consumption, and short shelf life of vegan cheeses typically limits these options, but I feel that it should be mentioned.I only live about 6 minutes away and had no stops from the shop to home, so I wouldn't expect time to be a factor in this. It was still hot when we began eating.Ultimately, I would eat here again, but it would be a place that I personally would go out of my way for. If you read this, take it with a grain of salt. It is excellent pizza, just not my preferred style."