Papa Jay's Pizzeria

18 Broadway, 3820, Dover, United States

🛍 Pizza, Sushi, Cafés, Asiatic

3.8 💬 4308 Reviews

Phone: +16037507272

Address: 18 Broadway, 3820, Dover, United States

City: Dover

Menu Dishes: 35

Reviews: 4308

Website: http://www.papajays.net/

"I lived just down the street from this place, and my significant other worked there at the time, so I used to eat there quite often. I can confidently say that my favorite item was the Steak TIP Sub with extra American cheese. It was absolutely delicious! I recently returned to the area and I'm really looking forward to enjoying that sub again, along with the chicken quesadilla (if they still have it)."

Full menu - 35 options

All prices are estimates on menu.

Salads

Entrées

Sandwiches

Pizza

Hot Chips

Burger

Wings

American Food

Cold Subs

Hot Dog & Co.

Tagliatelle

Salad

Wraps

Chili Fries

Fried Potatoes

Your Creation

Fast Food

Chili

Fresh Wings

Chicken

Calzones

Cold Subs & Wraps

Chicken Dishes

User User

Excellent pizza asked for extra sauce, extra cheese and well cooked. You nailed it! And pepperoni mushroom onion. Fast delivery and a large personal employee. Very happy, and the pest of sauce with the perfect amount of oregano.

Address

Show Map

Reviews

User
User

The pizza here is excellent, featuring a perfect crust, tasty pepperoni, and delicious sauce. The balance of richness is just right, and the cheese is pleasantly light without being overly chewy. The owners are wonderful—polite and always happy to accommodate special requests.


User
User

The pizza was outstanding! I hadn't visited in years and decided to give it another try. The pizza was excellent, but during my first visit, I mistakenly thought they served large pizzas because I hadn’t looked at the menu. Today, I discovered they offer XL pizzas, which was perfect for my kids and me. It's definitely the biggest pizza I've seen here, and it was well worth it!


User
User

I lived just down the street from this place, and my significant other worked there at the time, so I used to eat there quite often. I can confidently say that my favorite item was the Steak TIP Sub with extra American cheese. It was absolutely delicious! I recently returned to the area and I'm really looking forward to enjoying that sub again, along with the chicken quesadilla (if they still have it). View menu

Categories

  • Pizza Delve into our perfectly baked pizzas, crafted with hand-tossed dough, rich tomato sauce, and a blend of gourmet cheeses. Each slice bursts with fresh toppings, ensuring a delightful bite every time.
  • Sushi Delight in our exquisite sushi selection, featuring fresh ingredients, expertly crafted rolls, and traditional nigiri. Each bite offers a harmonious blend of flavors, promising a true taste of Japan. View menu
  • Cafés Charming cafés offering a variety of freshly brewed coffees and teas, along with light snacks, pastries, and desserts. Perfect for a morning pick-me-up or an afternoon treat in a cozy atmosphere.
  • Asiatic

Similar Restaurants