Fireside - Menu

11934 Highway 42, 54210, Ellison Bay, United States

🛍 Food, Cheese, Seafood, American

3.9 💬 79 Reviews

Phone: +19208547999

Address: 11934 Highway 42, 54210, Ellison Bay, United States

City: Ellison Bay

Menu Dishes: 35

Reviews: 79

Website: http://www.thefiresiderestaurant.com/

"In the super busy dining scene during weekends in Door County, we had trouble finding reservations for our group of 8 people. We ended up choosing this Fireside even though it was a little farther North than we usually go. The restaurant doesn 't look that impressive from the outside, but it was GREAT. First complement is the interesting, but not too trendy menu. Secondly, the owners definitely understand kids. There was more than the typical children 's menu selections (and more nutritious) plus they brought us an interesting set of toys to play with at the table, which was a wonderful break from the standard coloring sheet. I would absolutely recommend this place!!"

Full menu - 35 options

All prices are estimates on menu.

Soups

Vegetarian

Cajun Supper Club Signatures

Fireside

Blush And Bubbly

Old School Classic Beers

Beers-American Premium

Side Dishes

Domestic Beer

Beers - Bottles

Bar Bites

American Food

Dry Drinks

Main Course

House Blend

Raw Bar

Soup & Salad

The Waffle Iron

Hoppy And Herbal

Steak, Chicken & Chops

Sammiches

Vegetables

Starters

Malty And Rich

Chicken

Birre

Dark And Bold

Paige Paige

Of course! Please share the full restaurant review you'd like me to rewrite.

Address

Show Map

Reviews

JenniferL
JenniferL

I absolutely enjoyed everything about this restaurant! The food was excellent, and the service was fantastic!


OpenTable
OpenTable

The meatloaf was amazing, and our server delivered exceptional service. The other dishes were also wonderful.


Clara
Clara

The service was terrific. They were very intentional about making sure we had a good experience. We loved the shrimp and grits, the salmon and the hanger steak. And the key lime pie was the best I've ever had (even better than when we're in FL). View menu


charles
charles

We have come to enjoy this restaurant quite a bit this summer. The menu is excellent and we have enjoyed our dining experience time and time again! Happy to know they will be open through at least the Holidays for those of us who are year round residents!!


User
User

The food we had was fantastic! I ordered the Monterey shrimp and grits, which had a creative twist with goat cheese that made it wonderfully creamy. My husband chose to have a soup and salad since he'd already had a big lunch. To finish off our relaxing and delightful meal, we all shared a Reese's mini peanut butter cup cheesecake. We'll definitely return on our next visit to Door County!


TandGTwinzMom
TandGTwinzMom

Let me tell you about the food: I ordered the Monterey Shrimp and Grits, which featured a unique twist with goat cheese that made the grits exceptionally creamy—it was fantastic! My husband opted for the soup and salad bar since he had already enjoyed a substantial lunch earlier. To wrap up our wonderful and leisurely meal, we all shared a Reese's Mini Peanut Butter Cup cheesecake. We will certainly come back on our next visit to Door County! View menu


Leslie
Leslie

Although the exterior might look like a motel, don’t be fooled—it’s a culinary gem! The food is outstanding! The cherry BBQ ribs were exceptionally tender and bursting with flavor. The buffalo cauliflower was a tasty and unique appetizer. The entire menu offered a delightful range of intriguing flavors and choices. We had a reservation for nine, and our meals arrived quickly and at the perfect temperature. They handled our large group exceptionally well. I highly recommend this restaurant!


Kent
Kent

The Fireside has put some nice touches on some old favorites, plus introduced some items not found elsewhere in Door County. My shrimp and grits were well enjoyed, and my wife raved about her fish and chips. And, yes, Mac n Cheese can be subbed for chips!!! Owner, Lauren, was very friendly and being local, we spent a great time conversing. Our hats off and high recommendations for this restaurant. This was our first time dining here, but certainly not our last. Any rating less than outstanding would be inappropriate.


spluringmomma
spluringmomma

In the super busy dining scene during weekends in Door County, we had trouble finding reservations for our group of 8 people. We ended up choosing this Fireside even though it was a little farther North than we usually go. The restaurant doesn 't look that impressive from the outside, but it was GREAT. First complement is the interesting, but not too trendy menu. Secondly, the owners definitely understand kids. There was more than the typical children 's menu selections (and more nutritious) plus they brought us an interesting set of toys to play with at the table, which was a wonderful break from the standard coloring sheet. I would absolutely recommend this place!! View menu

Categories

  • Food Delight in our diverse food selection, offering a blend of classic favorites and innovative dishes. Each item is crafted with the freshest ingredients to tantalize your taste buds and provide a memorable dining experience.
  • Cheese A curated selection of artisanal cheeses from around the world, featuring diverse flavors and textures that delight the palate. Perfect for sharing or savored individually with the ideal accompaniments. View menu
  • Seafood Dive into the freshest catches of the sea with our seafood selection, featuring exquisite dishes prepared with high-quality fish and shellfish. Savor the flavors of the ocean in every bite!
  • American Enjoy classic American flavors with our diverse menu, featuring juicy burgers, crispy fried chicken, hearty BBQ ribs, and fresh salads. Indulge in timeless comfort with each bite, crafted to satisfy all tastes.

Amenities

  • Amex
  • Wifi
  • menu
  • Takeout
  • menu
  • Discover

Similar Restaurants

Wickman House

Wickman House

11976 Mink River Road, Ellison Bay, United States

Menu • Fish • Seafood • American • Cocktail


"Nestled within the picturesque embrace of Door County, an epicurean gem beckons discerning palates to an ethereal gastronomic voyage unlike any other. Wickman, a culinary haven that transcends mere dining, emerges as an unequivocal masterpiece destined to redefine the very essence of culinary excellence. From the instant one traverses the threshold, a profound sense of enchantment envelops the senses, as if one has stepped into an alternate realm where gastronomy takes on a symphonic dimension. The ambiance, an orchestration of warmth and allure, resonates with an enchanting cadence that unfurls a tapestry of possibilities, all imbued with an ineffable sense of significance. The elegantly choreographed ballet of the front-of-house staff captivates, a veritable maestro of attentiveness and hospitality. Their acumen in navigating the intricate constellation of locally sourced delicacies and wine varietals is akin to a virtuoso's command over his instrument, elevating each dish into a harmonious crescendo of flavors. A rare alchemy indeed, as they unfurl tales of terroir with unparalleled finesse, painting a vivid portrait of each ingredient's origin. Wickman's culinary narrative, a symphony of innovation and artistry, pays homage to its stature as a James Beard nominee, an accolade richly deserved. With unabashed creativity, the menu unfolds as a manuscript of ingenuity, each dish an ode to culinary exploration. Yet, it is the meticulous devotion to minutiae that forges the true hallmark of distinction. No detail is spared, as every nuance is crafted with an unwavering commitment to perfection. A span of three years bears witness to an evolutionary odyssey, wherein Wickman's prowess has burgeoned exponentially, culminating in a crescendo of culinary splendor. Within these hallowed walls, the confluence of passion and expertise intermingle seamlessly, casting a spellbinding essence that binds guests in awe and reverence. A resounding ovation of gratitude is due to the architects of this culinary opus: Luke, Isaac, the Madisons, Harrison, Matis, and the entire coterie who have devoted heart and soul to sculpting an indelible culinary experience. A pilgrimage to Wickman is not a mere dining experience, but an odyssey of the senses, an unequivocal triumph that demands homage whether one finds themselves ensconced within this idyllic enclave or endeavors to traverse distances in its pursuit. In sum, Wickman reigns as an imperious testament to gastronomic artistry, an oasis of epicurean grandeur that tantalizes, captivates, and beckons all who dare to seek the zenith of culinary gratification. An imperishable proclamation is etched upon the annals of time: a sojourn to Wickman is an odyssey unto itself, an irrefutable imperative for those who revere the profound symphony of taste. Vegetarian options: Plenty of vegetarian options that are excellent. Kid-friendliness: Kids welcome, ask for the kid’s options! Dietary restrictions: The chefs do their best to accommodate any and all dietary restrictions. Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $50–100 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Deviled Eggs, Deviled Egg Du Jour, Fish Dip, Seasonal Salad, Flourless Chocolate Cake, Kale Salad, Risotto, Charcuterie, Beet Carpaccio, Orange Chicken, Fishmonger Stew Parking space Plenty of parking Parking options Free parking lot"

Hügel Haus

Hügel Haus

11934 WI-42, 54210, Ellison Bay, US, United States

Menu • Beer • German • Seafood • Burgers


"Keep Googling for a better restaurant in Door County. Let’s begin with the UNwelcome welcome at Hugel Haus. We waited for the doors to open at 4:00 p.m. on Saturday, October 14. We were second in line and seated promptly. While showing us to our table, the hostess stated that due to volume, we only have the table for one hour. We ordered quickly and our food was delivered to the table soon thereafter. One entrée was the Rouladen nightly special $28.00). The menu states it was slow roasted; however, the beef had a very hard sear rendering it difficult to cut and eat. It was stuffed with bacon that appeared to not have been cooked prior to stuffing it in the roulade – it was rubbery and flabby. My companion ordered the Wienerschnitzel $26.00). She wanted to switch the demi glaze for the Rahm sauce but was told that due to volume, they would not allow any substitutions – no exceptions. The breadcrumb mixture was so salty it tasted like saltine crackers were used for the crumbs. The demi glaze was also overly salted rendering the Schnitzel was inedible. Both entrées came with red cabbage it was cold on both of our plates. We asked our server, Cody, if it was supposed to be cold, and he replied no. Cody stated that he would tell the kitchen staff to check the temperature of the cabbage so it does not happen to anyone else. He did not offer to warm up the uneaten red cabbage on our plates or bring us another order of red cabbage that would have possibly been warmer. The information regarding their policies of time allowed at the table and no substitutions is for your information. This complaint is regarding the bad food and food that was not served at the correct temperature and was not rectified."