The Grotto Pizzeria

New York, NY 10004, 69 New St, United States, New York City

🛍 European, Ossetian Cuisine, American Cuisine, Caucasian Cuisine

4.6 💬 240 Reviews
The Grotto Pizzeria

Phone: +12128096990

Address: New York, NY 10004, 69 New St, United States, New York City

City: New York City

Menu Dishes: 35

Reviews: 240

Website: http://www.thegrottony.com/

"Pretty good cheese pizza. They still have the Tuesday special 2 cheese slices a fountain drink for $6.50 (cash), if using credit card $6.76. Their fountain drinks are weird. The fanta one spat out a bit of thick syrup, and the sprite doesn’t taste normal. They don’t provide napkins when giving me my order, or tell me where the cap and straw would be. It’s an underground pizza spot, indoor eating area is small, creative but tight still. Great place for pizza grab and go. They offer specialty pi … – show"


Images

The Grotto Pizzeria

Full menu - 35 options

All prices are estimates on menu.

Salads

Soups

Entrées

Hot Heroes

Dessert

Pizza

Chicken

Snacks / Light Bites

Appetizers

Seafood Dishes

Calzone

Chicken Dishes

Green Menu - Starters

Strombolis

Sandwiches

Baked Calzone & Rolls

Heros

Stuffed Breads & Calzones

Calzones & Rolls

Hot Heros

Starters

Side Orders

Thamer Thamer

Not what you expect

Address

Show Map

Reviews

Marie
Marie

Excellent pizza! Big portions for a great price


Jaala
Jaala

Jr. High class trip from Arizona. BEST PIZZA WE HAVE EVER HAD!


Elke
Elke

Cool place with great pizza. They had the cleanest restrooms we have had in NY. View menu


Jorge
Jorge

I've been coming here over 20 years and I always get the same thing. Chicago slice. Best. Sauce. Ever.


Sophie
Sophie

Good gluten free pizza. The crust was from the freezer and wasn't the best, but the toppings were incredible. My family got regular pizza and enjoyed it.


Martin
Martin

Great pizza place for a slice and a drink. Wide selection and quick service with a small eat-in area at the back — free additional seasonings at no extra charge. Huge portions and very tasty indeed. Great value as well — best pizza I've had in a while. View menu


Lamer
Lamer

Looking for authentic New York pie!!! This is the spot. Tried 5 other highly recommended places and this one was the best hidden gem off the beaten path. If you've tried Joey's in times square you'd shoot yourself for not going here first. Especially cozy spot for 2.


Gastrophilist
Gastrophilist

Veggie Slice $6 A little on the expensive side based on price and size but it’s so delicious. The veggies tasted so good, I wonder what they put on them. One of the best pizzas in NYC. Can’t wait to try more pizzas from Grotto. I went back from more, I got the grandma and eggplant slice. Both were delicious. Can’t wait to try even more.


Evelna
Evelna

Pretty good cheese pizza. They still have the Tuesday special 2 cheese slices a fountain drink for $6.50 (cash), if using credit card $6.76. Their fountain drinks are weird. The fanta one spat out a bit of thick syrup, and the sprite doesn’t taste normal. They don’t provide napkins when giving me my order, or tell me where the cap and straw would be. It’s an underground pizza spot, indoor eating area is small, creative but tight still. Great place for pizza grab and go. They offer specialty pi … – show View menu

Categories

  • European Delight in a culinary journey across Europe with our exquisitely crafted menu, featuring authentic dishes from France, Italy, Spain, and beyond, using the freshest ingredients to bring traditional flavors to life.
  • Ossetian Cuisine Ossetian Cuisine features traditional dishes from the Caucasus region, highlighting hearty pies filled with cheese, potatoes, or meat, warming soups, and savory grilled meats, offering a taste of rich cultural heritage. View menu
  • American Cuisine American cuisine offers a diverse menu featuring hearty classics like burgers, fried chicken, and BBQ alongside vibrant salads, indulgent desserts, and innovative twists on traditional favorites.
  • Caucasian Cuisine Discover the rich flavors of Caucasian Cuisine with a selection of hearty meats, vibrant vegetables, and aromatic spices, offering a culinary journey through the diverse traditions of the Caucasus region.

Similar Restaurants