Traders Cafe - Isla de Sanibel (menu)

Address: 1551 Periwinkle Way, Sanibel, 33957, United States Of America, Isla de Sanibel

City: Isla de Sanibel

Menu Dishes: 35

Reviews: 91

Full menu - 35 options

All prices are estimates on menu.

Entrees

Desserts

Dessert

Peanut Butter Pie

Creamy peanut butter filling on a graham cracker crust, topped with chocolate drizzle and whipped cream.

Starters

Bottle Selections

Alcoholic Coffee

Surf Your Turf

Reds / Light To Full Intensity

Wine List

Sweet Wine & Prosecco

Ice Creams

Red Wines By The Bottle

Red Wine - By The Glass

Small Plate

Raw Bar

Something Sweet

Whites From North To South

By The Bottle- Whites

Bottled Reds

Aperitivos

Platinum Wines

Main Plates

Sandwiches

Grilled Chicken Sandwich

Grilled Chicken Sandwich: Juicy grilled chicken breast, lettuce, tomato, and onions, served on a toasted bun with a hint of mayo.

Soups

New England Clam Chowder

Creamy and hearty soup with tender clams, potatoes, and aromatic herbs, capturing the essence of New England coastal flavors.

White, Rose, Orange And Sparkling Wine (Must Be 21 To Purchase)

Address

Similar Restaurants

Cielo

➤ 1244 Periwinkle Way, Sanibel, 33957, United States Of America, 33957-4704, SANIBEL

Menu • Pizza • Seafood • American • International

"I had a terrible experience at the bar. I ordered the pork chop, which was overcooked and tough despite being recommended. When I mentioned this to the bartender, she still charged us full price. Later, the head bartender approached us and said they would have comped the meal, but by then, it was too late. They didn't offer any resolution or acknowledgment after we paid, which made things even more uncomfortable. This was especially disappointing since it was our anniversary, and they had recognized that but chose not to do anything. I really dislike giving negative reviews, but this felt like a slap in the face. I'm still waiting for my refund."

Sweet Melissa's Cafe

➤ Sanibel Island, 1625 Periwinkle Way, 33957-4403, SANIBEL, United States

Menu • Cafe • Pizza • Coffee • American

"I almost hate to rate this James Beard recognized cafe as a 1 star. We went with another couple who love their fish stew, a clientele favorite. We were dinning at 5:30 and feel that both my wife's stew and my oysters were under cooked and over spicy. My wife had the octopus small plate appetizer. Tasted a bit like lobster, but it had a sauce that was like a strong BBQ sauce that over powered the octopus. My oysters were a bit gelatinous inside, under cooked. The mole sauce was way over powering and to be avoided. The seared top was heavily dusted with a very salty seasoning, I had to scrape it off or just tast salt. My cubed vegetables were also undercooked and without taste. My wife's stew was also undercooked, with raw garlic and other vegetables. Sorry, Melissa, likely won't be back."

Lighthouse Cafe

➤ 362 Periwinkle Way, Sanibel, 33957, United States Of America, SANIBEL

Menu • Cafe • American • North American • Delivery Services

"We dined there on Saturday, August 26th, 2023. Our waitress was incredibly sweet and knowledgeable, which was a highlight of our visit. However, the food was just average—acceptable but nothing special. The biggest issue was the heat in the dining room. All four of us at the table felt uncomfortably warm and were even sweating, which made it hard to enjoy our meal. The manager explained that the air conditioning was working fine but attributed the discomfort to a full house and the frequent opening and closing of the front doors. However, the entrance was quite far from our area, separated by walls, and the bar and nearby dining areas felt perfectly comfortable. It seemed to us that management was trying to deflect responsibility rather than addressing the issue. I would suggest they change their name to the Hothouse Café. Unfortunately, I won’t be returning."

Traders

➤ 1551 Periwinkle Way, Sanibel, 33957, United States Of America, SANIBEL

Menu • Cafe • Bars • Pizza • Store

"-Gotta say, I been trying to get a table here for years.. true story. I tried almost all of the restaurants on this island, and everytime I wanted this place, it happed to be closed. Then one day, it just worked out. -The restaurant itself was huge (parking lot, building, tons of tables). Inside was nicely designed, looked awesome. Bathroom was super clean, so far was impressed. -Waitress was super nice, kept this great vibe going so far. -Then the food came. Maybe it was the fact that this place has finally been checked off our list, on top of already having a good day (so many outside influences could effect a meal), but I wasn't the only one that said this was one of the best meals I've ever eaten. It was ridiculously good, and I wasn't the only one that felt this way. I ate my meal, I tried some of another, both were worthy of a last meal. -This was long winded, but I just had to let someone know to stop in this place if they're hungry and on this island. -The waitress said the chef was named Mike, worked there for many years. -Well he was a wizard in that kitchen... Magic Mike..."

Doc Ford's Rum Grille

➤ 2500 Island Inn Rd, 33957-5717, SANIBEL, United States

Menu • Grill • Seafood • American • North American

"Fantastic restaurant! The staff was friendly, the venue had stylish decor, and everything was spotless. They have an impressive drink menu, and even brew their own beer. Despite being extremely busy, we found parking and were seated indoors within 30 minutes. Our food arrived promptly and was absolutely delicious. For appetizers, we ordered the mussels and clam chowder, and our little one especially enjoyed the chowder. For the main course, we chose two different grouper dishes, which were outstanding—the grouper was thick and cooked to perfection. Even the fish sticks for our child were tasty. For dessert, we had the carrot cake and chocolate mousse, and I must say, the carrot cake is among the best I’ve ever tasted. Overall, we highly recommend this restaurant!"

Traders Cafe - Menu