Buon Appetito - Menu

745 Route 9 BAYVILLE, NJ 08721-2538, BAYVILLE, United States

🛍 Bars, Pizza, Italian, Seafood

3.9 💬 2810 Reviews
Buon Appetito

Phone: +17322694005

Address: 745 Route 9 Bayville, NJ 08721-2538, BAYVILLE, United States

City: BAYVILLE

Menu Dishes: 35

Reviews: 2810

Website: http://buonappetitobayville.com

"We hosted our son's communion party here last weekend, and it was a fantastic experience! The venue was lovely, the food was delicious, and the highlight of the day was the exceptional service. Numerous guests complimented the servers, praising their attentiveness and warmth. Their accommodating nature truly stood out. Having worked in the restaurant industry for 20 years, I can confidently say I was thoroughly impressed. Thank you once again for making our celebration so special!"

Full menu - 35 options

All prices are estimates on menu.

Sandwiches

Salads

Pizza

Subs

Uncategorized

Special Ramen

Penne

Individual Handpulled Flatbread Pizza

Al Forno*

Subs & Wraps

Soups

Whole Pizza Pies

Mixed Dishes

Chicken

Veal & Beef Dishes

Seafood

Chicken Dishes

"Hot Sandwiches"

Mixed Poultry Dishes

Calzones

Baked

Ideal For Sharing

Pretzel Sandwiches

Glamburgers® & Sandwiches

Sicilian Pizza

Lunch - Panini

Justyn Justyn

Buon Appetito is a great find in Bayville. The boli knots are awesome. We love the food and the friendly service!! Give it a try you won’t be disappointed.

Address

Show Map

Reviews

Connie
Connie

I visited this restaurant when everywhere else was either closed or about to close after the Melbourne Cup (what??), and it turned out to be a great choice. I had my first taste of Australian cider here.


Jabari
Jabari

Our family has been enjoying dine-in and takeout from here for many years and absolutely love it. We also hosted a surprise 70th birthday party a few years ago and it was amazing. Anna and her staff are top notch. Authentic Italian cuisine! Highly recommend!


Johnny
Johnny

This is one of the best Italian pizzerias in town. The staff is fantastic, and the food is always consistently excellent. I highly recommend trying the vodka sauce on a pizza or with any pasta dish you choose. The balsamic vinaigrette for the salad is also wonderful. View menu


Mariah
Mariah

He lived in Bayville for many years and had never stopped by until this weekend. We were pleasantly surprised! The atmosphere was cozy, the food was delicious, and the music was great. I think the musician's name was John, and he was excellent. We will definitely be back!


Eleanore
Eleanore

The best restaurant in the ocean. My family and I have come here for years and love it absolutely! The new owners are the sweetest people of all time! Definitely recommend trying this place! Especially on a Friday or Saturday when they have a live singer in the dining room.


Julia
Julia

This was the second stop on the William Martin Memories Motorcycle Pizza Slice Cruise Tour! The Grandma Slice had a softer texture than I prefer and was a bit oily. However, the sauce was sweet and flavorful, the cheese was delicious, and the crust was somewhat floppy. Overall, it was a good slice! View menu


Katie
Katie

Unfortunately, Google doesn't allow for zero-star ratings. We decided to order dinner tonight, having previously enjoyed meals at this restaurant. However, after this experience, we won't be coming back. The mussels we were served were completely spoiled. I attempted to inform the management, but I was met with a young, inexperienced staff member, which was quite disappointing. I have no intention of returning.


Louis
Louis

Had the pleasure of dining here with family to celebrate our anniversaries and so glad we chose this place. Nice atmosphere, it’s a BYOB which is always good, they had a nice singer last night that got the crowd involved but the topper is the food andservice. Food was delish and service was friendly quick and never hovering, but always right there when we needed them. Lookingforward to our next night out. See you soon


Loyce
Loyce

We hosted our son's communion party here last weekend, and it was a fantastic experience! The venue was lovely, the food was delicious, and the highlight of the day was the exceptional service. Numerous guests complimented the servers, praising their attentiveness and warmth. Their accommodating nature truly stood out. Having worked in the restaurant industry for 20 years, I can confidently say I was thoroughly impressed. Thank you once again for making our celebration so special! View menu

Categories

  • Bars Discover our selection of expertly crafted cocktails, refreshing beers, and our curated list of fine wines. Perfect for unwinding with friends or pairing with your favorite dishes from our menu. Cheers!
  • Pizza Delve into our perfectly baked pizzas, crafted with hand-tossed dough, rich tomato sauce, and a blend of gourmet cheeses. Each slice bursts with fresh toppings, ensuring a delightful bite every time. View menu
  • Italian Savor the rich and diverse flavors of Italy with our menu, offering classic pasta, savory risottos, and traditional meat and seafood dishes, all crafted with authentic ingredients and passion. Buon appetito!
  • Seafood Dive into the freshest catches of the sea with our seafood selection, featuring exquisite dishes prepared with high-quality fish and shellfish. Savor the flavors of the ocean in every bite!

Amenities

  • Wifi
  • Delivery
  • menu
  • Parking Area
  • menu
  • Reservations

Similar Restaurants

Mill Creek Tavern

Mill Creek Tavern

275 AveNY 11709, BAYVILLE, United States

Menu • Pizza • Coffee • Seafood • American


"Attended my first Elite Yelp event at the Mill Creek Tavern in Bayville. I attended other events as a plus one but this was better because now I was elite and I already knew some of the players like my friend Bill S who introduced me to this wonderful world of Yelp. What makes these events great to me are the friendly yelpers who attend with their honest fair reviews and most important is the generous hospitality of the restaurant owners. Once we arrived the Mill Creek Tavern Staff had everything prepared waiting for us. We started with their specialty drinks, Dark and Stormy, Pumpkin Ale and Sang-Rose with sorbet. My fav was the dark and stormy, Black Rum, Pumpkin Beer and Lime Juice. Then all the samples of food came out, Filet Mignon Crostini, Seafood Ceviche, Mussels Provençale, Sauerbraten Short Rib Sliders, Jager Schnitzel Sliders, Pan Seared Sea Scallops, Mac Cheese, Brat in a Blanket, Pretzel Baked Brie, Burrata Crostini, Shrimp Cocktail and Artichoke Risotto Cakes. There was so much to choose from, It was like cocktail hour at a weeding and the food just kept coming. Then desert, I was already full at this point but of course had to try. Berries Cream, Chocolate Mouse, Mini Purple Cow Floats and Mini Brownie Sundays. All were delicious. The event went fast, everyone was enjoying themselves socializing, eating and experiencing great service. The staff didn't miss a beat, they just kept coming out with food being efficient, friendly and courteous, even the owner Rich came out and not only served food he also mingled with us speaking to everyone and making sure we had everything we needed. This was a great time seemed to be had by all. I know a lot goes into this planning one of theses events. I am grateful for the Rich, the owner for opening up his restaurant to us, the staff for just great services and to Drew for organizing this. Mill Creek Tavern is a great place to eat, not only is the food really good, the décor is very pleasing, they even have a fireplace. One can enjoy this restaurant year round. I will return and would definitely recommend dining here."

Coach Grill Tavern

Coach Grill Tavern

Coach Grill Tavern, 22 Pine Hollow Rd, Oyster Bay, NY 11771, USA, OYSTER BAY, United States

Menu • Pizza • Salad • Grill • Asiatic


"My friends and I came here for dinner after checking out nearby Coe Hall and Planting Fields Arboretum. It was such a nice day out, so we opted to do outdoor dining in front of the restaurant. Upon being seated, we were served complimentary bread, including sesame seeds roll and mini baguettes. Both types of bread was warm and fresh, and was so tasty with butter. There were a couple of menu items I was eyeing, but finally decided to order the Roast Long Island Duck $34). The duck came topped with Bing cherry brandy sauce and was served with rice pilaf and assorted vegetables. The duck had decently crispy skin though it could've been more crunchy), along with tender, succulent meat, which was soaked in the aromatic, slightly sweet cherry sauce with a delightful hint of brandy taste. There were also actual soured bing cherries on top of the duck, which was a lovely touch. The rice pilaf was cooked perfectly and a great accompaniment. The medley of vegetables included broccoli, carrots, zucchini, and yellow squash. This was simply prepared, but made just right and pretty good. I got to try the lobster mac and cheese, which was absolutely delicious! Incredibly cheesy, with plenty of wonderfully well seasoned lobster filling. Service was decent. Our waiter was friendly and was on top of it. I just found the food to be a bit too expensive. I'm not sure the duck was worth the $34 it cost. If I am back in the area, I would probably look for a more reasonably priced place to eat."