Carmela's - Menu

912 Hempstead Turnpike, 11010, Franklin Square, US, United States

🛍 Soup, Pizza, Casual, Italian

3.8 💬 1327 Reviews
Carmela's

Phone: +15164889898,+15164887884

Address: 912 Hempstead Turnpike, 11010, Franklin Square, US, United States

City: Franklin Square

Menu Dishes: 35

Reviews: 1327

Website: https://carmelasfranklinsquare.com/

"there is no option for no stars so 1 is a gift. We have been coming here for years especially for the Grandpa pizza. Today my friend I ordered a mesculun salad the waiter didn 't know what it was so called over the boss who then read in the menu the ingredients???? said ok I 'll make that?? We also ordered 2 mini Grandpa pies! When the salad came it was less than adequate contained 4 grape tomatoes in total for 14.95. Then we get 2 slices of Grandpa pizza not what we ordered after waiting we got 2 Grandpa mini pies the quotes are for the fact that we never saw or have eaten anything like this before. No provolone cheese raw onions never experienced that before either. They were horrible. The ladies room was a disgrace with a clogged up toilet filled with toilet paper. Then the bill comes we are charged $19.95 for the salad!!!!! the menu says $14.95! it certainly wasnt worth that much either! We paid $60 total we 're way less than satisfied with the entire experience. Not one person there had any idea what was going on the bathroom situation was disgusting So long Carmela 's never again!!!"

Full menu - 35 options

All prices are estimates on menu.

Salads

Entrées

Soups

Sandwiches

Main Courses

Veal

Pasta

Beef Noodle Soup Side Orders

Al Forno*

Hot & Cold Heroes

Pizza - Klein (Ø 24Cm)

Grinders Or Homemade Syrian

Seafood

Sides

Seafood Dishes

Chicken

Mini Pies

Pizzette - Individual Pizza

Veal & Beef Dishes

Specialty Rolls & Calzones

Carmela's Fabulous Pasta Specialties

Joey Joey

Amazing service one of the workers there Jared was very helpful and kind best pizza in town!

Address

Show Map

Reviews

Elisa
Elisa

The food, ambiance, and service at this restaurant were exceptional. The owners were extraordinarily welcoming, and the entertainment was outstanding.


Stephanie
Stephanie

Best Restaurant in area !!! I don't know what all these reviews are talking about. Every service and every plate given has been the best ever!! Amazing food !


Tiffany
Tiffany

Horrible experience. Service was horrible, food was horrible, owner was rude and disrespectful! Mike the owner is very unprofessional and should not be in the hospitality business. He is vulgar and rude. I was forced to give 1 star but should be a 0. View menu


Dominique
Dominique

Terrible new owners. My family and I made reservations just to be TOLD that we "LIED ABOUT EVEN CALLING IN THE FIRST PLACE. VERY DISRESPECTFUL!!! My family has been coming here for over a life time and now these pieces of garbage running the restaurant into the ground. Smh sad.


Keith
Keith

They used to be, years ago, one of the best Italian restaurants in the area. I have tried them multiple times in the past year and the food quality has hit the all time low. Very high prices for the quality of food. Not friendly or helpful to the disabled. I know because I’m disabled. 4 people at the counter and they stand there and watch you struggle to carry the food and open the door to get out. Amazing! I will now drive the extra 1/2 mile to Umberto's pizza. Too bad, they at one time were great .


Jazlyn
Jazlyn

Carmela provides an excellent dining experience for those seeking both casual and upscale options. Guests can indulge in a diverse array of Italian dishes, pizzas, and unique specialties in the pizzeria area or choose a more refined setting. The menu is innovative and fresh, featuring special celebrity-inspired dishes for special occasions. Regardless of where you choose to dine, you can count on the food being delightful, as everything is prepared by the same kitchen and chef. And rest assured, any leftovers will still taste great the next day! View menu


Brandy
Brandy

I visited this restaurant for a special karaoke night on Sunday, and it was a fantastic experience. The waitstaff were delightful and very accommodating. The food was absolutely delicious. The amateur karaoke performers were impressive; I was especially taken by the large man who sang Elvis tunes from Atlantic City, as well as the guy who belted out Billy Idol's "Jimmy's Son," and the gentleman in black who entertained us with classics from the 50s and 60s. I truly didn't want the evening to end. I’m definitely planning to return for more food, drinks, singing, and laughter. I can't help but wonder if there was a record producer or someone exceptionally talented in the audience—it's a myster...


Rachel
Rachel

We wanted to love it. Went in randomly for a slice and the options were impressive. Got a Margherita since that's typically a good way to test a pizzerias metal. It was pretty good. Good sauce, thin, crisp crust, fresh cheese basil. I decided we should try more from the menu. So we ordered delivery, salad, a small Margherita pie, zucchini sticks and 2 pasta dishes. The pizza was NOT anything like the slice I had eaten previously. The pie was doughy and undercooked....though the sauce was still good. Pasta was overcooked in both dishes. I prefer al dente....but can still enjoy it a little softer......but this was bordering on mushy with overcooked veggies.The salad was the worst part though,...


Linda
Linda

there is no option for no stars so 1 is a gift. We have been coming here for years especially for the Grandpa pizza. Today my friend I ordered a mesculun salad the waiter didn 't know what it was so called over the boss who then read in the menu the ingredients???? said ok I 'll make that?? We also ordered 2 mini Grandpa pies! When the salad came it was less than adequate contained 4 grape tomatoes in total for 14.95. Then we get 2 slices of Grandpa pizza not what we ordered after waiting we got 2 Grandpa mini pies the quotes are for the fact that we never saw or have eaten anything like this before. No provolone cheese raw onions never experienced that before either. They were horrible. The... View menu

Categories

  • Soup Warm and comforting soups to nourish your soul. Choose from a variety of flavorful broths and hearty ingredients, perfect for a simple appetizer or a satisfying meal on a chilly day.
  • Pizza Delve into our perfectly baked pizzas, crafted with hand-tossed dough, rich tomato sauce, and a blend of gourmet cheeses. Each slice bursts with fresh toppings, ensuring a delightful bite every time. View menu
  • Casual Our Casual menu offers delicious comfort food for effortless dining. From juicy burgers and scrumptious sandwiches to fresh salads and hearty mains, our diverse selection provides a delightful experience for any casual outing.
  • Italian Savor the rich and diverse flavors of Italy with our menu, offering classic pasta, savory risottos, and traditional meat and seafood dishes, all crafted with authentic ingredients and passion. Buon appetito!

Amenities

  • Takeout
  • Delivery
  • menu
  • Television
  • menu
  • Reservations

Similar Restaurants

Prince Umberto

Prince Umberto

721 Franklin Ave, 11010, Franklin Square, United States

Menu • Pizza • Pasta • Italian • Seafood


"'FRESHER IS ALWAYS BETTER! Prince Umberto Pizzeria Restaurant 721 Franklin Ave, Franklin Square, NY 11010 Today 10/26/2023, I took my Honey for lunch for the first time to Prince Umberto 's in Franklin Square, NY. We both love good home made Italian food. I read some nice reviews, checked out their menu online and saw items we both like to eat, so to not far away Franklin Square we went! It was about 2;30 pm when we got there, the pizzeria side was busy but the dinning area side was wasn 't busy at all, and that 's exactly where we wanted to go. Our waiter and server Johnathan greeted us and sat us at a nice comfortable table. I ordered something for my Honey and I to drink, nothing with alcohol, while we looked over the menu. I told Johnathan we were going to first try a few appetizers, and after that, if we were still hungry we would order something else. I asked Johnathan, please, DO NOT bring us all the food at once, as so many other restaurants seem to want to do! All that food at once just overwhelms you, plus sitting there, the food just gets cold before you get to eat it. Johnathan said, not a problem, tell me what to bring you, and I will bring it when you tell me, YES! We started off first with Littleneck Clams on the half shell, then we had whole backed clams that were just made, nice and piping hot, and so, so, delicious. Next we enjoyed a nice size pot of mussels cooked with white wine and garlic, Johnathan brought us their just baked HOT pizza dough bread with butter on the side, it was excellent especially when we were dunking the bread into the mussel juice! After that my Honey and I had to try their Trippa Napoletana, we both love tripe! This tripe with the sauce made at Prince Umbertos was so good, my Honey had to take some home! It had no potatoes, no peas, just tender cooked tripe in a delicious mild sauce, which I was also enjoying on the hot pizza dough bread too. Just delicious. Wow! While were eating, the owner, and the chef came over to us a couple of times to ask if everything was okay and to our liking, and if we needed anything else, which was very nice of them to do. We now were both pretty full, but I had to check out their dessert menu first, before we left. I spotted their Italian ice cream Tartufo, and my Honey spotted the Tiramisu. We suddenly found a little space to tackle dessert, OMG! They both were so yummy! Now as far as prices go in this day and age of high prices, this restaurant has very, very, fair prices for quality fresh food! And I might add, this is one of the very few restaurants that is not charging any extra fee for using your credit card, I hope they can continue doing that, we shall see? We shall return for sure. Their food was so good, and freshly cooked to order, just as if we were home, it was a delight to go to Prince Umberto 's in Franklin Square today! Johnathan did an excellent job taking good care of us. And if I am going write an honest review, which I am, I have one wish, we both love clams on the half shell, ice cold. The clams on the half shell we had today were really fresh, but they were room temperature and not cold at all? I wish they can serve them ice cold, the next time we come. All in all, Prince Umberto 's still gets 5 stars! One tip for all, go for lunch or early dinner, You will have plenty of space in their dining room!"