Carvel Ice Cream - Setauket- East Setauket (menu)

Phone: (+1)6316892920

Address: 178 New York 25A, Setauket- East Setauket, United States Of America

Menu Dishes: 30

Reviews: 550

"I ordered two large vanilla soft serves with peanut sauce and hot fudge in separate cups. Unfortunately, the store misunderstood my request and mixed the toppings in with the ice cream, resulting in a soupy mess by the time it arrived, which I had to throw away. Additionally, I ordered a large chocolate soft serve but received one that was only filled like a medium. I was really disappointed. It ended up being a waste of money."

Full menu - 30 options

All prices are estimates on menu.

Limited Time Offer

Sundae Dashers

Desserts

Ice Cream Celebration Cakes

Dessert Packs

Celebration Cakes

Dessert

Ice Cream Sundae

A delightful blend of creamy ice cream topped with rich chocolate sauce, crunchy nuts, and a cherry on top. Perfect indulgence!

Ice Cream*

Sundae

A classic ice cream treat with scoops of vanilla ice cream, topped with rich chocolate syrup, whipped cream, and a cherry on top.

Cookies And Cream Formula 1

Candles & Toppings

Ally

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

Amazing ice cream

View More Reviews

Address

Reviews

Owen

★ ★

both sundaes were the wrong ice cream and neither had whipped cream on it.

Jim

★ ★ ★

The sundae had too little topping, and the hot fudge didn't taste very good.

Samantha

★ ★ ★

I ordered vanilla chip ice cream, but they gave me soft serve with just a few chocolate chips on top instead. View menu

Deanna

★

I ordered two large vanilla soft serves with peanut sauce and hot fudge in separate cups. Unfortunately, the store misunderstood my request and mixed the toppings in with the ice cream, resulting in a soupy mess by the time it arrived, which I had to throw away. Additionally, I ordered a large chocolate soft serve but received one that was only filled like a medium. I was really disappointed. It ended up being a waste of money.

Similar Restaurants

Z Pizza

➤ 217 Main StNY 11777, PORT JEFFERSON, United States

Menu • Pizza • Fondue • Italian • Seafood

"I ordered a chicken parm hero and a chicken gyro, and it was the worst experience I've ever had! The chicken in the gyro was dry and lacking flavor. The pita was stale and tough. The fries had a strange taste, likely due to old oil. The chicken parm hero was priced at $10.99, but it was only half a sandwich! It was bland, and there was hardly any chicken in it. Overall, the experience was terrible, and I would never order from here again!"

Ichi Sushi Ramen

➤ 700 N Country Rd, Setauket- East Setauket, United States

Menu • Asian • Sushi • Casual • Japanese

"First time here as a vegetarian and I would say their vegetarian menu is quite limited. Highlight would be the service. Food: 3/5 Ordered Vegetable Ramen and Mix Vegetable Roll. Ramen was flavorful, but the type of noodles used was a little bit different from what I expected. Roll was not bad. I enjoyed it. Portion size was okay and I think the food is not bad, but not anything out of the world. Price: Not bad. About the price of a meal compared to nearby places. Service: 5/5 Staff was helpful in serving us and checked in on us every now and then to make sure we were enjoying our meal. While selection was limited and food was nothing out of the ordinary, I still enjoyed my meal and appreciated their service. I would come again!"

Bliss Catering

➤ Bliss, 766 NY-25A, Setauket- East Setauket, NY 11733, USA, United States

Menu • Cafés • Salad • Seafood • American

"We sat outside and had a nice meal. They had a really unique range of food options. Two of us had the red snapper and it was cooked perfectly. Another one of us enjoyed the paella. Our fourth got a burger and request a fried egg, which they accommodated. It was big enough that he had to smush it down to fit in his mouth. Parking: You might not get right near the restaurant, but there was plenty. Wheelchair accessibility: They had a big ramp to get up to the elevated door and deck seating. Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $30–50 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 4 Parking space: Plenty of parking Parking options: Free parking lot"

The Pie

➤ 216 Main St, Port Jefferson, United States Of America, 11777, PORT JEFFERSON

Menu • Pizza • Pasta • Salad • Italian

"We took the ferry from Connecticut and decided to skip our usual seafood lunch in favor of pizza. I believe the best way to evaluate a pizzeria is to order the classic cheese, though I also enjoy a half-and-half with pepperoni. The pizza was outstanding! The crust was large, thin yet foldable, with a delicious sauce and fresh mozzarella. The interior of the restaurant was really nice, the server was pleasant, and the service was quick. The only downside was that the pizza got cold pretty quickly, but it was still delicious! I will definitely return and spread the word; this place is a must-visit for anyone looking for pizza while on a trip to Port Jeff! I also noticed that the rest of the menu and specials sounded tempting—maybe I’ll try them next time!"

Pasta Pasta

➤ 234 East Main Street Port Jefferson, NY 11777, 11777-1865, PORT JEFFERSON, United States

Menu • Wine • Pizza • Italian • Seafood

"The food here is amazing. I actually didn’t get the pasta when I went so I can’t say it’s the best pasta on Long Island. I had the lobster pizza and it was absolutely amazing. They also bring out a huge loaf of garlic bread right out of the oven it’s so fluffy and moist and delicious! Some of the best bread I’ve ever had. All their ingredients are quality and everything tastes really fresh. The place is a bit small and the first time I went it was a Saturday and they kinda rudely said you had to have a reservation on Saturdays but the food by far makes up for it."

Carvel Ice Cream - Menu